Skip to main content

British Telecom launches broad patent case against Google

The BT Tower
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Businesses the size of Google tend to attract all manner of litigation, and Google has felt the sting of legal battle. The company is already facing its share of high-profile cases, including an major infringement suit with Oracle — and a looming mano-a-mano with Apple — over its Android operating system. Now, the Internet giant faces another patent infringement battle, and this one is from across the pond. British Telecommunications has filed suit against Google in Delaware (full complaint), alleging that a broad range of Google products infringe on six key BT patents ranging granted from 2000 to 2004. BT is seeking unspecified damages and an injunction that would prevent Google from using those patented technologies in its products. And that would be quite a range of Google products: Google Search, Gmail, Google Places, Google Offers, Google’s location-based advertising services, Google Music, Google Docs, Google Plus, Google Maps, and Android are all named in the complaint.

Recommended Videos

The six patents named in the filing all center on location-based services, including navigation, and the ability to personalize and customize data and content to particular users based on the their location. BT’s complaint implies that it has been in negotiation with Google over licensing, but that Google refused to come to terms.

Examples of infringement cited in the filing including Google Maps’ ability to provide different information to users at different zoom levels, and Android’s ability to restrict music downloading to Wi-Fi connections, rather than mobile data services. The latter is an instance of the so-called Busuioc patent, granted to BT back in 2000.

Although ostensibly a mobile, telecom, and broadband operator, BT claims a portfolio of more than 5,600 patents and patent applications. And in financial terms, BT is a giant: for the full year ending March 2011, the company pulled in over US$30 billion in revenue.

The BT lawsuit increases the patent pressure on Google’s “free and open” Android operating system. Android is currently the top-selling smartphone platform, and its success has been fueled in part by the fact that device manufacturers don’t have to pay anything to Google to use it. However, Microsoft claims more than half of Android device makers are now paying it royalties to protect them in the event Microsoft ever decides to sue Google for patent violations. Google is also facing a major challenge to Android from Oracle over the Java virtual machine included in Android, and is looming closer to a direct confrontation with Apple over Android, which Steve Jobs characterized as a “stolen” product that he was willing to go “thermonuclear” to destroy — although it remains to be seen whether Apple’s current leadership shares that commitment. With BT added to the mix, the cloud over Android’s “free and open” future gets even darker, and some industry watchers are speculating Google may have no choice but to consider charging royalties to device makers to use Android.

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
How to watch today’s WWDC keynote, and 3 reasons to do so
You can livestream the WWDC 2025 keynote for free
Apple WWDC 2025 logo

Apple’s WWDC 2025 (Worldwide Developer’s Conference) starts today. In case you didn't already know, WWDC is an annual event used by the tech giant to showcase new software and technologies across its product ecosystem, while also providing developers with sessions and tools to help them build apps for Apple's devices.

How to watch the WWDC 2025 keynote

Read more
Will my iPhone get iOS 26? Here’s every supported model
We've got the full list of iOS 26 supported devices - find out if you're getting the new iPhone update
iOS 26 features on a series of iPhone screens

Apple announced iOS 26 at WWDC 2025, and the new iPhone update comes with a fresh new 'Liquid Glass' look and plenty of features - and there are loads of iOS 26 supported devices, which is great news.

And no, you haven't missed a volley of updates since iOS 18 in 2024. Apple has skipped a bunch of numbers, so instead of giving us iOS 19 in 2025, we got iOS 26 alongside iPadOS 26, macOS 26, watchOS 26 and tvOS 26. In short, Apple's brought its operating system numbering into line. Nice.

Read more
Will my iPad get iPadOS 26? Here’s every supported model
We've got the full list of iPadOS 26 supported devices - find out if you're getting the new iPad update
iPadOS 26 home screen on an iPad

Apple announced iPadOS 26 at WWDC 2025, and the new iPad update comes with a fresh new look and plenty of features. Apple has ensured there are plenty of iPadOS 26 supported slates, so if you have a relatively new iPad you should get the update this year.

And no, you haven't missed a volley of updates since iPadOS 18 in 2024. Apple has skipped a bunch of numbers, so instead of giving us iPadOS 19 in 2025, we got iPadOS 26 alongside iOS 26, macOS 26, watchOS 26 and tvOS 26.

Read more