Skip to main content

Calorie Counting Controversy: Indiegogo and Healbe defend against fraud allegations

indiegogo and healbe hit back over gobe calorie tracker
Image used with permission by copyright holder

We previously reported on the questions surrounding Moscow-based company Healbe’s Indiegogo campaign for its GoBe activity tracker. The crowdfunding venture, which recently breached the $1 million mark in spite of negative media scrutiny, has prompted both Healbe and Indiegogo to answer allegations of fraud and negligence. The wearable device, which claims to measure calories through your skin and track your glucose in a non-invasive manner, has been dismissed as a scam in some circles. Indiegogo and Healbe are answering dissenting voices and ensuring backers that everything’s above board. 

The campaign has amplified a debate over the role of crowdfunding when it comes to propping up new ventures. Some see crowdfunding as a sort of advance order Amazon for placing orders on cool things before they’re available to the mass market. Others see crowdfunding as a way of helping new businesses that otherwise wouldn’t get picked up by venture capitalists, and getting a small token in return.

It is like Google searching algorithm – everybody knows that it exists, but Google tells nobody details about it, or like the Coca-Cola formula.

“Regarding Healbe and the broader discussion about our approach, we see this as two separate topics: the issue of a campaigner who intends to deceive and the issue of the feasibility or deliverability of the campaign,” Indiegogo CEO Slava Rubin told Digital Trends. “To date, the Healbe team has been responsive and cooperative with our inquiries. Their campaign continues to follow our trust guidelines and they have voluntarily offered refunds upon request.”         

When we first reached out to Healbe, representatives told us that the criticism they received from the likes of Dr. David Ahn, was based on incomplete information. “This article was written before we updated information about the technology we used. This means it is not based on full information about the technology we use.” 

We asked a medical expert to assess the new information released by Healbe. Similar to previous analyses, the technology was met with skepticism.

“As a clinician, I would find it difficult to recommend this technology to patients without further information demonstrating scientifically  rigorous outcome findings,” Dr. Amber Featherstone, a medical director for Doctors of the World with a master’s degree in public health from Columbia University, told Digital Trends. Aside from disputing the claim of Healbe expert Dr. Vladimir Leonidovich Emmanuel that the GoBe’s accuracy rate of 15-20 percent for glucose calculation is good enough for day-to-day applications, she also questioned the lack of peer reviewed journals for the project.       

Assessments such as Dr. Featherstone’s are just what Healbe Managing Director George Mikaberydze is trying to avoid.

“I hope that you understand that some information about the technology could remain confidential,” Mikaberydze told Digital Trends. “It is like Google searching algorithm – everybody knows that it exists, but Google tells nobody details about it, or like the Coca-Cola formula. What we would like to avoid is that medical experts would make conclusions based only on some part of the technology we use, because in this case it could lead to wrong conclusions.” 

If Healbe really is holding on to this kind of groundbreaking technology, it’s caught between a rock and hard place. It must provide enough information to calm down panicking funders, but also keep things vague enough so competitors can’t sniff out clues. If this is outright fraud, it may call into question the credibility of not just Indiegogo, but crowdfunding as a whole. If you want to evaluate the strength of HealBe’s claims for yourself, you can check out the Indiegogo page here.

Christian Brazil Bautista
Christian Brazil Bautista is an experienced journalist who has been writing about technology and music for the past decade…
Garmin just launched a new $300 Apple Watch alternative
Garmin Vivoactive 5 smartwatch.

Garmin's latest smartwatch, the Vivoactive 5, looks like an impressive device offering a wide range of features for health and fitness enthusiasts. The wearable, which was just announced on September 20, features a long-lasting 11-day battery life and a 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen display that should deliver a solid viewing experience.

The Vivoactive 5 is designed with a lightweight aluminum bezel and silicone band to provide comfort and durability. It is available in four color combinations -- black/slate, ivory/cream gold, navy/metallic navy, and orchid/metallic orchid -- to suit different preferences and styles.

Read more
You can already use the Apple Watch Series 9’s best new feature
An Apple Watch Ultra showing off the AssistiveTouch Hand Gestures screen.

Apple’s Wonderlust event gave us plenty of shiny new hardware, from the iPhone 15 lineup to the Apple Watch Series 9 and Apple Watch Ultra 2. Oh, and don’t forget the USB-C AirPods Pro 2!

During the event, Apple also showed off a cool new gesture that’s coming to the Apple Watch Series 9 and Apple Watch Ultra 2: Double Tap. Though Apple made it seem like a completely new thing, it’s actually been around since the Apple Watch Series 4 as an accessibility feature called AssistiveTouch.

Read more
How to increase your internet speed
Man working at a desk at home.

There is nothing more frustrating than your internet moving along at a snail’s pace. Web pages take forever to load, and games and streaming services experience lag. With Zoom meetings becoming a more regular occurrence, any significant slowdown in your internet makes working at home much more difficult, too.

Read more