Skip to main content

The NSA claims its systems are too complex to stop deleting incriminating data

spying is expensive nsa surveillance program may cost more than 35 billion seal
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The NSA is claiming that its systems are so complex that it cannot prevent the destruction of evidence that may be damaging to its case in a lawsuit against privacy group Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF). 

In the case in question, Jewel vs. NSA, which was filed in 2008, the EFF sued the NSA on behalf of AT&T customers. The EFF claims that the NSA unlawfully collected information and records of Americans’ Internet and telephone use. Last week, U.S. District Court Judge Jeffrey White issued an emergency order that prohibited the NSA from destroying data that the EFF had asked for in the lawsuit. The agency is fighting the directive. According to the Washington Post, the NSA is arguing that holding on to the data it collects about the phone and Internet activities of American citizens is too burdensome.  

“A requirement to preserve all data acquired under section 702 presents significant operational problems, only one of which is that the NSA may have to shut down all systems and databases that contain Section 702 information,” said NSA Deputy Director Richard Ledgett in a court filing.

“Communications acquired pursuant to Section 702 reside within multiple databases contained on multiple systems and the precise manner in which NSA stays consistent with its legal obligations under the [FISA Amendments Act] has resulted from years of detailed interaction,” he added.

Section 702 refers to a portion of the Amendments Act of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. The legislation, which allowed the NSA to collect “content of communications” such as emails, Facebook messages, and web browsing histories, has been used by the NSA to justify its surveillance activities. 

Declassified documents that contain the testimony of Teresa H. Shea, the agency’s director for its Signals Intelligence Directorate (SID), outline the prescribed period for retaining the data. “Since May 2006, the NSA has collected bulk telephony metadata pursuant to FISC (Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court) orders directing telecommunications service providers to produce to the NSA on a daily basis electronic copies of ‘call detail’ records created by the recipient providers for calls to, from, or wholly within the United States,” Shea said.

“To protect U.S. person information the FISC’s orders impose procedures to minimize access to use, dissemination, and retention of the data consistent with the need to acquire, produce and disseminate foreign intelligence information. Among these is the requirement to destroy all bulk telephony metadata obtained under the FISC’s Section 215 orders within five years (60 months) of the data’s collection,” Shea said.  

Ledgett also stated that the agency erases data through “a combination of technical and human-based processes.”

The EFF is using the NSA’s argument to its advantage. Cindy Cohn, the EFF’s legal director, said that the agency’s inability to track the data it collects shows the dangers of conducting such a wide-reaching surveillance program.

“To me, it demonstrates that once the government has custody of this information even they can’t keep track of it anymore even for purposes of what they don’t want to destroy,” she told the Washington Post. “With the huge amounts of data that they’re gathering it’s not surprising to me that it’s difficult to keep track– that’s why I think it’s so dangerous for them to be collecting all this data en masse.” 

The EFF’s full complaint can be found here. If you want a more detailed look at how the NSA collects your phone and Internet records, you can read Shea’s testimony here. However, know that some details are still hidden because parts of Shea’s comments have been redacted.

Christian Brazil Bautista
Christian Brazil Bautista is an experienced journalist who has been writing about technology and music for the past decade…
These Sennheiser All-Day OTC self-fitting hearing aids are $500 off
A man wears the Sennheiser All-Day Clear OTC hearing aid while on a hike.

A less-considered piece of tech that can go a long way toward helping the hard of hearing better interact with the world is a hearing aid. Right now you can save big at Best Buy on the Sennheiser All-Day Clear over-the-counter hearing aids. They would regularly cost $1,500 for a pair, but this deal sees them marked down to $1,000, which makes for $500 in savings. Free next-day shipping is available, and you can even pick the hearing aids up at your nearest Best Buy within one hour in many areas.

Why you should buy the Sennheiser All-Day Clear OTC hearing aid
Sennheiser is one of the more sought after brand names in consumer audio, and it’s almost always in consideration to be one of the best speaker brands. With the All-Day Clear hearing aids Sennheiser has taken all of that audio know-how and produced its first over-the-counter hearing aids. They’re made for those with mild to moderate hearing loss who are looking for a better hearing experience. They come ready to wear and combine clear, vibrant hearing performance with seamless connectivity. The All-Day Clear hearing aids have advanced sound processing technologies for better hearing and a range of customizable settings for a personalized experience.

Read more
Is the Facebook algorithm bypass a scam? Or is it a hack?
The viral Facebook algorithm bypass post is nonsense.

Here we go again, folks. It's not uncommon — especially at this time of year for some reason — to start seeing all kinds of people posting the same thing on Facebook. Something about somehow "bypassing the Facebook system" or about how you hereby disallow Facebook from doing something that you absolutely allowed it to do by using Facebook in the first place.

No, it's not a Facebook hack. No, you're not telling Facebook to do anything. Or not to do anything. And, no, someone who posts this sort of stuff isn't deserving of mockery. In fact, this isn't new at all. Meta (nee Facebook) itself addressed it as far back as 2019.

Read more
Apple AirTag, Samsung Galaxy SmartTag2, Tile Mate prices slashed
Person holding an Apple AirTag.

If you're always losing and misplacing stuff, you may want to invest in Bluetooth trackers. These handy devices can be placed or attached to any object -- and even held by people or pets! If you think they'll be very useful for you, there are three options with discounts right now from Amazon -- the Tile Mate for $18, down $7 from $25; the Samsung Galaxy SmartTag2 for $20, down $10 from $30; and the Apple AirTag for $27, down $2 from $29. You're going to have to hurry if you want to take advantage of any of these offers though, especially if you're planning to buy multiples, because they may expire at any moment.
Tile Mate -- 

Samsung Galaxy SmartTag2 -- 

Read more