Skip to main content

Patent déjà vu: Nokia files suit against HTC in U.S. (again)

supreme_court_building
Image used with permission by copyright holder

In case you haven’t heard already, software patents are terrible. That being said, it certainly won’t stop companies like Nokia and Apple from going on a finger-pointing field day against competitors in court. This time around Nokia is continuing a slew of patents against Taiwanese phone manufacturer HTC, and it’s starting to look like a bad case of déjà vu.

If you lost count, the number of recent patent lawsuits, we don’t blame you. Just last month Nokia filed several lawsuits in Germany and The Netherlands against HTC for a number of various patent violations. Here in America, the latest patent lawsuit is circling around an apparent violation of three different patents that pertain to a “terminal, method and computer program product for interacting with a signaling tag.” While this may sound about one of the vaguest patents ever – or perhaps some sort of computer-beacon – it’s the latest way Nokia hopes to intimidate HTC with the power of the legal system.

What’s a little comical about this is that Nokia already sued HTC less than a year ago over other patent complaints. The reason why Nokia is doing this simple: to make some settlement cash as quickly as possible. It’s what Apple did with HTC while it was on the warpath against Samsung last year, and Nokia is continuing its litigation efforts to show a little more money to stockholders in the coming months. It’s also what Nokia is doing as a way to utilize the sheer massive number of vague, abstract software patents the Finnish phone-maker holds.

Unfortunately, this style of litigation is just starting as phone manufacturers turn to dirty tactics to compete against one another, and it’s really just beginning. All it does is push costs to the consumer and reveal a serious fault in American and European patent law.

Editors' Recommendations

Joshua Sherman
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Joshua Sherman is a contributor for Digital Trends who writes about all things mobile from Apple to Zynga. Josh pulls his…
I keep forgetting about the Apple Watch Series 9’s coolest feature
Apps on the Apple Watch Series 9's screen.

I’m just going to come out and say it: I love the Apple Watch Series 9. A couple of weeks ago, I returned to wearing it every day after an extended period of not doing so. And you know what? I was surprised by how much I’d missed it.

But one thing has bothered me this time around: There's a feature I haven't been using. Not because it’s bad, but because I tend to forget it's there.
Effortless to own and wear

Read more
3 foldable phone deals you should seriously consider today
The Google Pixel Fold with the screen open.

For those who are thinking about getting a foldable phone, we've rounded up three foldable phone deals for you to consider as your next purchase. Motorola is currently selling the Motorola Razr at $200 off, which brings its price down to $500 from $700, and the Motorola Razr Plus at $300 off, which lowers its price to $700 from $1,000. Meanwhile, the Google Pixel Fold is available from Best Buy with a $500 discount that slashes its price to $1,299 from $1,799. You can be sure that you won't regret purchasing any of these devices because they're all included in our roundup of the best folding phones, but you need to hurry because the offers may expire at any moment.
Motorola Razr -- $500, was $700

The Motorola Razr features a 1.5-inch external OLED display and a 6.9-inch Full HD+ internal pOLED display, with decent performance provided by its Qualcomm Snapdragon 7 Gen 1 processor and 8GB of RAM. It's got a 64MP main camera and a 13MP wide-angle camera at the back, plus a 32MP selfie camera inside. The folding phone features a metal chassis that's surrounded by soft but durable leather, and it folds without a gap.

Read more
The OnePlus 12R is still one of 2024’s best smartphone deals
OnePlus 12R Genshin Impact Edition in hand.

OnePlus is still quite new to me, as I was a lifelong iPhone user until I joined Digital Trends. However, OnePlus has a pretty solid reputation in the mobile world, and now I can see why, as the OnePlus 12 is one of my favorite smartphones that I’ve used so far this year.

But the OnePlus 12 isn’t the only phone that OnePlus launched in 2024. There is also the more affordable value option, the OnePlus 12R, which even comes in a cool Genshin Impact Edition.

Read more