Skip to main content

WeChat reportedly spying on foreigners to feed censorship algorithms in China

A study has revealed that China-based WeChat is monitoring foreigners, prompting people with non-China-registered accounts to think twice about using the messaging app.

WeChat, owned by Chinese internet giant Tencent, is the most popular social media platform in China, and is also widely used in the rest of the world with 1 billion users globally.

However, the University of Toronto’s Citizen Lab claimed that the app, which follows China’s stringent censorship rules, also monitors messages shared by people registered with non-China-based phone numbers, feeding the content into censorship algorithms to help build up the database it uses to censor China-based accounts.

The conclusions were based on an experiment that started by sending politically sensitive content between non-China-registered accounts. Afterward, when the same content was sent between China-registered accounts, it was flagged and subsequently censored.

While accounts outside of China were not censored, they are reportedly subject to content surveillance, information on which was not found on any public documents and data access requests, including discussions with Tencent representatives.

Tencent responds

Citizen Lab clarified that there is no evidence that WeChat’s surveillance on international users was directed by the Chinese government. Tencent, however, told CNBC that it received the findings of the research, and that it was taking it “seriously” as the company considers “user privacy and data security” as core values.

“With regard to the suggestion that we engage in content surveillance of international users, we can confirm that all content shared among international users of WeChat is private. As a publicly listed global company we hold ourselves to the highest standards, and our policies and procedures comply with all laws and regulations in each country in which we operate,” a Tencent spokesperson told CNBC.

The accusations against WeChat follows similar claims against TikTok, another popular China-based app. To build user trust, the company behind the app opened the TikTok Transparency Center, a location where its moderators may be observed by outside experts.

It remains to be seen if Tencent will do something similar for WeChat, after the release of Citizen Lab’s research. The findings may also affect the app’s listing on Apple’s App Store and the Google Play Store, as both platforms require developers to disclose the data that they collect.

Editors' Recommendations

Aaron Mamiit
Aaron received a NES and a copy of Super Mario Bros. for Christmas when he was 4 years old, and he has been fascinated with…
Apple and Tencent reach deal to again let WeChat app users tip each other
apple tencent wechat tip deal

Last year, Apple announced a change in its policy that recategorized tips made within an app as in-app purchases, causing Tencent's WeChat messaging app to disable tipping because of the fact that Apple takes a cut of in-app purchases. Now, it seems as though Apple and Tencent have come to an agreement -- and tipping in WeChat will reportedly be re-enabled.

As part of the deal, first reported in the Wall Street Journal, Tencent will revamp the tipping system in WeChat to send tips directly to individuals. WeChat is the most popular messaging app in China.

Read more
Apple clashes with Chinese social network giants over in-app money transfers
Apple store logo

Apple is reportedly clashing with several developers of social networking apps that are prominent in China, according to The Wall Street Journal. The issue concerns the "tipping" feature common in many of these apps, which allows users to pay content creators directly.

One of those developers is Tencent, the company responsible for producing WeChat, China's most prominent messaging and payment platform. According to the report, Apple's stance is that the money exchanged by users -- specifically tips -- are in fact a form of in-app payment. That would allow the company to take a 30-percent cut of each transaction, per App Store rules.

Read more
WeChat joins BlackBerry Messenger and Line as apps that are banned in Russia
apple tencent wechat tip deal

WeChat, a popular mobile messaging and money transfer service in China, has become the latest social app blocked in Russia, according to the Hong Kong Free Press. Roskomnadzor, the Russian government's media supervision body, reportedly shut down the app for allowing the transmission of citizens' personal information without the state's consent. It is Russian law that such data must be kept within the country's borders for a limited time and provided to law enforcement if necessary.

WeChat reportedly boasts nearly 900 million users in China, the home of the app's developer, Tencent. A representative from Tencent apologized for the outage on the company's website and added the following statement:

Read more