Skip to main content

Petition forces White House to address why unlocking smartphones is illegal


A petition demanding the White House “make unlocking cell phones legal” again has surpassed the 100,000-signature threshold, meaning the Obama administration must now respond to citizens’ call for gadget justice. The question is, will it do any good?

The “We The People” petition to overturn the Librarian’s decision was launched by San Francisco-based entrepreneur Sina Khanifar on January 24, two days before the 90-day grace period for cell phone unlocking expired. Until a few days ago, the petition remained stuck at around 80,000, but, according to The Next Web, a last-minute push on Twitter and social news giant Reddit apparently tipped the signature count over the 100,000 mark.

Exempted under the 1998 Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DCMA) for six years, the unlocking of new cell phones became illegal under the DCMA once again after the Librarian of Congress overturned the DMCA exemption in October of last year. The Librarian was convinced by CTIA, the wireless industry’s lobbying group, and other proponents of the no-unlock rule that an exemption for unlocking was no longer necessary because phones that come pre-unlocked are much more widely available than they once were.

Unlocking cell phones removes the digital locks installed by wireless carriers, freeing users to take their phones to a carrier other than the one from which they purchased their devices, or to use their smartphones on local networks during international travel. To remove the digital lock on a device requires users to alter the firmware installed by the carrier, which is protected by the DMCA.

It is not illegal to unlock all cell phones, however. The rule only applies to devices purchased after October 26, 2012. Older phones may still be unlocked, and many carriers will unlock devices on their networks as long as the customers have been with the company for a certain period of time and have an account in good standing, or are no longer on contract.

Those who decide to unlock their new smartphones anyway could face lawsuits, though experts on the DMCA doubt wireless carriers will go after individual infringers – and it’s not yet clear whether there is any way for a wireless carrier to know whether a phone on their network has been unlocked.

People who make money by unlocking other people’s cell phones, or sell illegally unlocked devices risk fines of up to $500,000 and up to five years in prison, or both, for a first offense. For repeat offenders, those consequences double.

For Khanifar, the decision to make unlocking illegal again is a personal one. According to a blog post published early this month, he received a cease and desist letter from Motorola after he launched The company threatened him with half a million dollars in fines and jail time. An attorney from Stanford’s Cyberlaw Clinic, Jennifer Granick, offered to help the 20-year-old Khanifar fight Motorola. The company eventually dropped its threats, and Granick went on to help persuade the Librarian to exempt cell phone unlocking under the DMCA in 2006.

Unfortunately for Khanifar and other opponents of the no-unlock rule, there is little chance that the White House itself can change the Librarian’s decision, as the Library of Congress is not subject to presidential oversight. Obama could urge Congress to pass legislation that would make cell phone unlocking permanently exempt from the DMCA – but such efforts seems unlikely, given the president’s other legislative priorities. Still, Khanifar remains determined.

In an email, Khanifar said he hopes the petition’s success will “start a meaningful discussion about some of the problems with the anti-circumvention provisions of the DMCA.”

“I expect they’ll write back discussing those provisions, and if we’re lucky perhaps they’ll say they agree that unlocking is good for consumers,” he said.

But for Khanifar, “the petition is just the start.” He has launched up a new website,, “to coordinate activism on this issue,” and make unlocking legal for good.

Image via Condor 36/Shuttstock

Editors' Recommendations

Andrew Couts
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Features Editor for Digital Trends, Andrew Couts covers a wide swath of consumer technology topics, with particular focus on…
Leaked photo shows why you should be excited about the folding Razr smartphone
Motorola Razr Folding Phone Leak

Motorola is gearing up to launch the 2019 reimagining of the original Motorola Razr very soon, this time as an ultramodern folding smartphone, and a leaked photo has shown why we should be excited about this intriguing device. It appears Motorola has stayed exceptionally close to the iconic design of the original Razr, a device that introduced mobile phones to a great many users.

The leaked photo appears to have been lifted from press promotional material and shows the classic clamshell shape slightly open, and resting in the palm of a hand. What’s notable here is the size of the phone, as it’s very compact, especially as it’s clearly a female hand holding the device. The open top reveals the reflective surface of the screen, which is expected to run from the bottom to the top of the open phone.

Read more
Amazon drops $108 off this unlocked Samsung Galaxy S9 smartphone
samsung galaxy s9 review

It's been about six months since Samsung introduced its latest flagship smartphone,  the Samsung Galaxy S10+,  and it's understandable that the price is still pretty steep. If you are aiming for a flagship phone but unwilling to shell out over $800 on the S10+, then the Samsung Galaxy S9 Unlocked (64GB) is your best alternative. Normally priced at $600, Amazon dropped it to only $492, giving you an enormous discount of $108. If you can't wait for the Galaxy Fold to come out — or are still not convinced it's a better design — then this cheaper alternative might be best for you.

True, this is not the newest product from Samsung, but the Galaxy S9 is their former best smartphone prior to the release of the S10 series. It means that you're still getting a flagship quality smartphone comparable to the iPhone XS but at a more affordable price. It has a remarkable Infinity display, an exceptional camera, and a lightning-fast processor that will take you to another level of digital experience.

Read more
Amazon’s Google Pixel 3 discount is the best unlocked smartphone deal today
Google Pixel 3

American software giant Google has made its move for greener pastures with the release of its very own flagship of smartphones. The world may be divided into iOS and Android users, but we can all agree that the Google Pixel 3 is one of the best smartphones released in 2018. If you're an Android fan looking for an upgrade, then consider yourself lucky as Amazon reduced the $799 list price of a factory unlocked Google Pixel 3 by 38%. If $499 doesn't cut it for you, you could qualify for another $50 discount with your Amazon Rewards Visa Card, making it one of the best smartphone deals you'll find today.

Since this smartphone is factory unlocked, this Google Pixel 3 would work with any carrier of your choice with the plan that suits your lifestyle. Also, its sale price of $499 may be a lot less than the actual price you're willing to pay to lease your device on a monthly basis. For international travelers, a factory unlocked phone may come as an advantage as it makes it easier to simply buy a prepaid SIM and avoid expensive roaming charges.

Read more