Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Features

25 years ago, this underrated supernatural thriller was overshadowed by The Sixth Sense

By
A ghost girl looks at a light bulb in Stir of Echoes.
Artisan

If you watched one movie about someone who saw dead people in the summer of 1999, then it was probably The Sixth Sense. M. Night Shyamalan — who directed this summer’s divisive thriller, Trap — rode The Sixth Sense to the top of the box office as it became a blockbuster and eventually earned six Oscar nominations. But that meant that Stir of Echoes, another supernatural thriller that shared many of the same themes, was almost completely overshadowed by Shyamalan’s breakout film when it arrived a month later in September 1999.

Screenwriter and director David Koepp adapted Richard Matheson’s 1958 novel of the same name and gave it a modern update. Regardless, Stir of Echoes only finished with $23.1 million worldwide. That may be one of the key reasons why Stir of Echoes has never fully been fully embraced on its own terms. But now that the 25th anniversary of Stir of Echoes has arrived, it’s time to look back and see if it still holds up as a great horror movie.

Recommended Videos

Kevin Bacon delivers a great performance

A woman comforts a man in Stir of Echoes.
Artisan

Considering that Kevin Bacon has been acting professionally since 1977, he’s got a remarkably high percentage of good films to his credit. Stir of Echoes may be underrated, but it’s also got one of Bacon’s best performances as everyman Tom Witzky. Aside from the fact that his son, Jake (Zachary David Cope), can already perceive the dead at the beginning of the story, Tom is about as normal as it gets.

Related

Things take a strange turn for Tom when his sister-in-law, Lisa (Illeana Douglas), accidentally unlocks his own supernatural perceptions with a hypnotic suggestion. Bacon makes Tom’s subsequent freakouts really believable, as he’s both scared and angered by his new gift. Future Law & Order: Criminal Intent star Kathryn Erbe is also quite good as Tom’s wife, Maggie Witzky, but Bacon keeps this film grounded in reality even when his character is losing control of his life.

It’s a genuinely creepy ghost story

Kevin Bacon and Jennifer Morrison in Stir of Echoes
Artisan Entertainment

One of the common threads between this movie and The Sixth Sense is that the dead have unfinished business on Earth, and they won’t rest until someone takes care of it for them. The thing that separates Stir of Echoes from Shyamalan’s film is that the ghosts really feel like they don’t belong in this world.

The primary ghost in this movie is a recently deceased young girl named Samantha Kozac (House and Once Upon a Time star Jennifer Morrison). Samantha isn’t a malevolent spirit, but once she starts haunting Tom, she nearly drives him insane in order to get him to do what she wants. It’s a creepy experience on its own, and it also makes Tom’s waking life begin to crumble.

Stir of Echoes also works as a crime thriller

Kevin Bacon in Stir of Echoes.
Artisan Entertainment

It would be too big of a spoiler to explain why Samantha’s spirit is so restless, but we can say that a heinous crime was committed against her. That forces Tom to play amateur detective as he has to figure out what happened to Samantha, and why his neighbors are so eager to see her case swept under the rug.

Ghosts only have limited powers in the land of the living, and the people that Tom really has to worry about are the ones who are still breathing.

The ending leaves a strong impression

Zachary David Cope in Stir of Echoes.
Artisan Entertainment

Without giving any specifics away, the film does resolve Samantha’s unfinished business and it brings Tom’s story to an end. But the conclusion also reminds us that Jake had his second sight first, and it’s not going away just because this particular problem has been resolved.

Instead, the movie closes on a semi-ominous note by giving viewers a taste of what it’s like to have Jake’s gift in a world filled with spirits who want something from him.

Watch Stir of Echoes on Freevee.

Editors’ Recommendations

Topics
Blair Marnell
Blair Marnell
Blair Marnell has been an entertainment journalist for over 15 years. His bylines have appeared in Wizard Magazine, Geek…
25 years ago, one of the best horror movies ever made became a box office sensation
Three people hang from nooses in The Sixth Sense.

M. Night Shyamalan is best known among moviegoers now as a maker of high-concept, trashy (non-derogatory) genre thrillers, but his reputation has evolved quite a lot throughout his career. For a long time, he was seen as a gimmicky filmmaker — one who relied too much on the kind of third-act, eye-opening twists that had become the biggest talking points of his earliest movies. Viewers began to see him as a one-trick pony and — due to the failures of The Happening, The Last Airbender, and After Earth — not even a particularly good one.

In recent years, however, capably made, uncomfortably gripping films like Trap, Old, Knock at the Cabin, and Split have elevated and deepened his reputation. Now, it seems as though more viewers and critics are willing to recognize him, despite his consistent flaws as a writer, for the high-level, genre-driven visual artist and craftsman that he is. To this day, though, even Shyamalan's biggest defenders don't often tout him as a revolutionary or particularly forward-thinking filmmaker.

Read more
25 years later, the superhero genre has forgotten this overlooked movie’s greatest message
A nuclear missile soars into the air above the Iron Giant.

Nowadays, superhero movies are more common than most other Hollywood blockbusters. That wasn't the case in 1999. Back then, not only were comic book films still few and far between but good ones were even rarer and more difficult to find. A lot has, of course, changed since then. Entire superhero-driven cinematic universes have been born, taken over Hollywood, and -- in the case of Warner Bros.' DC Extended Universe -- even been put out to pasture. What hasn't changed, however, is The Iron Giant's status as one of the best superhero movies that Hollywood has ever produced.

Directed and co-written by Brad Bird, The Iron Giant received immediate and widespread praise when it was originally released in August 1999, but it was a box office bomb. Thankfully, its poor financial performance didn't stop it from gradually earning a special place in the hearts of a lot of comic book fans. In the years since its theatrical debut, the film has frequently been cited as one of the best American animated movies of the past 30 years, and it has become a comfort food-esque go-to for many of its admirers.

Read more
25 years ago, The Matrix led a mini movement of sci-fi simulation thrillers
A man walks into a simulation in The Thirteenth Floor.

One way to grasp how fully our relationship to computers changed over the 1990s is to look at the cyberthrillers Hollywood made during that time. Mass surveillance, identity theft, the hacking of the soul — all the nascent technological anxieties of this new era were uploaded to movie screens like a virus. But there was no stopping what was coming, and over just 10 years, a world merely flirting with mass connectivity went irreversibly online. By the end of the decade (and, by extension, the century and millennium), the internet had become a major part of everyday life for many people. In turn, the word of warning evolved at the movies. Suddenly, computers weren’t just threatening your safety, your privacy, and your humanity. They were replacing life itself.

In the spring of 1999, the American multiplex was inundated with variations on that scary conclusion. First came The Matrix, a savvy sleeper blockbuster that used irresistible pop philosophy as the Krazy Glue of its spirited genre pastiche. Mere weeks later, eXistenZ, a weird Canadian thriller, dabbled in similar ideas, while bending them into the less mainstream shape of a drolly deranged espionage movie. And a few weeks later still, on Memorial Day weekend, we got The Thirteenth Floor, a twisty neo-noir about realities within realities that had the misfortune of opening in the wake of not just Matrix mania, but also the box-office event that was Star Wars: Episode 1—The Phantom Menace.

Read more