Skip to main content

HBO cancels controversial Confederate series from Game of Thrones creators

Philip K. Dick’s 1962 novel  The Man in the High Castle (and the television series by Amazon Studios based on it) imagines an alternate version of 1962, with the Axis powers having emerged victorious from World War II. Game of Thrones showrunners David Benioff and D.B. Weiss conceptualized a similar series, Confederate, set in a reality where the South won the Civil War after seceding from the Union

That project received the green light from HBO in July 2017, but has now officially been canceled in the aftermath of a massive deal that will have the duo creating TV shows and movies for Netflix.

The move doesn’t come as much of a surprise, given the pair’s busy schedule, which also has them working on a mysterious Star Wars project set within the sci-fi saga’s universe, in addition to other announced projects. The controversy surrounding Confederate also makes the cancellation less surprising, as the show had been plagued by criticism regarding its premise — and whether Benioff and Weiss were capable of handling such a sensitive theme — since it was first announced.

As it was first announced, Confederate was expected to be set in a nation where slavery remains legal and has grown into a more modernized economy. As with Game of Thrones, the series would have cast a wide eye across its fictional world — this time, America, minus the Emancipation Proclamation — following the stories of several different characters and weaving those stories together at opportune moments. The lives of slaves, slave owners, freedom fighters, politicians, journalists, and more were to be explored.

In the fictional world, the Mason-Dixon line has been transformed into the Mason-Dixon Demilitarized Zone, signaling that the North and South are likely still in conflict.

HBO Programming President Casey Bloys was initially effusive in his praise of the two, saying, “We are thrilled to be able to continue our relationship with Dan and David, knowing that any subject they take on will result in a unique and ambitious series.”

In addition to Benioff and Weiss, Thrones executive producers Carolyn Strauss and Bernadette Caulfield were expected to serve the same roles on Confederate. The same goes for Nichelle Tramble Spellman (Justified) and Malcolm Spellman (Empire), who were to assume co-writing duties.

Editors' Recommendations

Rick Marshall
A veteran journalist with more than two decades of experience covering local and national news, arts and entertainment, and…
Star Wars’ distant past has potential for Game of Thrones-like drama
A collage of characters in "Star Wars: The Old Republic" promo art.

While pondering yet another big IP Disney+ series can seem like an exhaustive thought considering its current breakneck output, Andor's critical success for both the streaming platform and the Star Wars franchise as a whole gives a taste of the potential that the Old Republic could provide to a TV series. That's in addition to the benefit of being heavily separated from the Skywalker Saga legacy.

No series needs to be darker and more serious to be inherently better, but the level of tension and drama found in Cassian Andor's gritty origin story should be a seamless fit somewhere within the literal thousands of years worth of history in Star Wars' distant past. In the Old Republic, there's no shortage of Jedi, Sith, intergalactic factions, political intrigue, and more that could give Disney+ and Lucasfilm a major and long-running Game of Thrones-level drama to keep audiences reeled in season in and season out.
The Old Republic provides an embarrassment of riches

Read more
How House of the Dragon saved Game of Thrones’ tarnished legacy
Alicent and Rhaenyra clutch each other in House of the Dragon.

May 19, 2019, is a date branded on the pop culture lexicon. The finale to Game of Thrones, the television phenomenon that single-handedly revitalized the fantasy genre and redefined what "event television" meant, aired to the collective disappointment of millions of fans. The show's decline in quality had begun in season 7, with some questionable choices happening as far back as season 5, but the train wreck that was season 8 was beyond words. Consistency went out the window in favor of spectacle, resulting in a rushed season that reduced the world's greatest TV show into a sad shadow of its former self.

The controversial finale put a seemingly permanent stain on Game of Thrones. In the years leading up to its conclusion, HBO expressed interest in creating a franchise based around George R. R. Martin's World of Ice and Fire. However, the episode's terrible reception put the network's plan in doubt, with many wondering if the Game of Thrones brand was in a healthy enough place to support a franchise. Things got worse when the first spinoff, starring Naomi Watts, got unceremoniously axed -- even after shooting a $30 million pilot -- spelling doom for the would-be franchise. Alas, not all was lost; GoT still had an ace up its sleeve, and it was called House Targaryen.
Mother of Dragons

Read more
HBO sets a January 2023 debut for The Last of Us series
Joel and Ellie in HBO's The Last of Us.

Many years ago, film critic Roger Ebert infamously declared that "video games could not in principle be art." Because of his position, gamers took Ebert to task and tried to explain that the medium had come a long way since the days of Atari. Ironically, the late Mr. Ebert died a few months before the release of The Last of Us in June 2013. Sony and developer Naughty Dog's powerful fusion of gameplay and cinematic storytelling created an experience that rivals any film or TV show. This game is art. And early next year, the first-ever live-action adaptation of The Last of Us is coming to HBO.

Read more