Has purpose become a punchline? Among startups, the debate rages

startups purpose collision 2019 frank cooper alain sylvain

Can tech companies really change the world for the better, or has Silicon Valley’s do-gooder posturing gotten out of hand?

Depends who you ask.

At Collision 2019 in Toronto, the startup conference where tech luminaries from journalist Kara Swisher to Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau have come to talk tech, it’s a sticky issue that’s bubbling up everywhere. At one panel discussion, Alain Sylvain, founder of the strategy and design consultancy Sylvain Labs, and Frank Cooper, chief marketing officer of investment firm BlackRock, offered their perspectives on the scale of the problem, and what do about it.

“Big companies have weaponized purpose,” Sylvain said. “They’ve exploited it from a marketing point of view, to try to tap into people’s soft spots.” His contention: Purpose should be core to a company’s entire existence, not merely a PR wrapper.

While Google’s “do no evil” motto comes immediately to mind, the problem extends outside tech. Sylvain pointed to Gillette’s recent “Best a man can be” ad campaign as an example of do-goodism gone awry. While the campaign encouraged men to take responsibility in the wake of the #metoo movement, Sylvain contends it didn’t reflect the company on any deeper level.

“That was just a campaign,” he said. “They didn’t really adopt that philosophy as an organization.”

Contrast that with Nike’s Colin Kaepernick ad campaign, which, he says, takes a stance. “By aligning with a celebrity that only appeals to half the population, Nike made a political commitment,” he said.

What’s the difference? “Behavior. That’s the difference between exploiting purpose and committing to purpose. It goes beyond marketing to something more operational.”

BlackRock’s Cooper agrees. “You have to worry about behavior more than words. How do you get it into the bloodstream of a company?”

Startups, Sylvain says, can be particularly vulnerable to posturing. “The CEO of the startup is desperate and just looking for a shortcut to get out the gate. They see the need for purpose to just attract attention quicker.”

Cooper agrees. “Right now, there’s no real pressure. In fact, a lot of startups will state a purpose, don’t live that purpose, and there’s no real penalty. There’s one company which will remained unnamed, that actually did it for years, after year, after year. They would state a purpose, be caught out violating that purpose, apologize, and go back to violating the purpose again, with very little penalty.”

But he doesn’t want companies to shy away from striving to do more than make money. “All good things in life can be misused and abused. Medicine can be misused and abused. Food and beverage can be misused and abused.”

How do we fix it? “It’s about the end customers, and the pressure they put on corporations to make the right choices,” Sylvain said. “As consumers, that is probably our greatest political currency, is the way we shop and buy things.”

Cooper sees it coming more from within. “I think the employees have much more power than they realize,” he said. Sylvain agreed, citing Theranos as an example of a company that unraveled from the inside as employees revealed its lies.

But even if consumers and employees hold companies to a higher standard, they still need to answer to a higher power: Investors. “Investors have to change their mindset first,” Cooper conceded. “As long as investors decide they want short-term profit, everyone is going to dance to that tune.”

“You can’t break it if the whole system is designed for short-termism.”

Social Media

A new Senate bill would fundamentally change the internet as we know it

A new bill in the U.S. Senate could cause the internet as we know it to cease to exist by holding major tech companies like Facebook or YouTube liable for anything posted on their platforms. 

A library at your fingertips: The best free Kindle books

Reading shouldn't be an expensive hobby. Here, we've put together a list of some of the better free offerings currently available for Kindle devices, so you don't have to sort through thousands of titles on Amazon and Google Play.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix right now (June 2019)

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.

T-Mobile and Sprint may sell $6 billion in assets to win merger approval

T-Mobile and Sprint are getting closer to merging. After a few failed attempts, the two companies announced their merger at the start of 2018. The new T-Mobile could be better positioned to take on the likes of Verizon and AT&T.
Emerging Tech

U.S. Navy is working on making its fleet invisible to computerized surveillance

The U.S. Navy’s ever-innovative Office of Naval Research is working on a way to turn the United States military fleet invisible. Well, to cutting-edge image-recognition systems, at least.

The MacOS Catalina public beta is live. Here’s how to download it

Apple's latest MacOS update, known as Catalina, is finally available for developer preview, which means if you're willing to pay a little for the privilege, you can be one of the first to try it out.
Smart Home

GE-backed startup brings crystal-clear ice to fans of bourbon and other spirits

Spherical, crystal-clear ice to water down drinks used to be the purview of innovative bartenders, but a startup called FirstBuild, backed by GE Appliances, has a new device that will produce it in mere hours.

Researchers sent a fake, unblockable presidential alert to a 50,000-seat stadium

A group of researchers was able to send out fake, unblockable presidential alerts to phones in a 50,000-seat football stadium. The team from the University of Colorado Boulder figured out a way to spoof the alert and send it out.

Cyberpunk 2077 will feature romance options beyond heterosexual relationships

CD Projekt Red’s upcoming Cyberpunk 2077 will feature a gender-fluid character creator, and the game’s lead quest designer reveals that the romance options will be more diverse than The Witcher 3's.

Apple’s new Seattle campus may mean big things for Siri, artificial intelligence

Apple plans to hire 2,000 more employees for a new Seattle campus, the company announced Monday, with a significant number of those jobs focused on Siri and artificial intelligence.

The best new gear from the Summer Outdoor Retailer 2019 convention

At the 2019 summer Outdoor Retailer convention in Denver, Colorado the top gear manufacturers revealed the latest and greatest camping, hiking, and backpacking products to keep us safe and comfortable.
Emerging Tech

How to watch SpaceX’s most difficult Falcon Heavy launch ever

SpaceX will launch a Falcon Heavy rocket Monday evening in its most challenging launch yet. The launch is scheduled for Monday June 24 at 8:30 p.m. PT, but is dependent on weather conditions. You can watch NASA's livestream with coverage…

U.S. firm plans to power soccer stadiums using aging Nissan Leaf batteries

We've heard of aging EV batteries being repurposed to power homes and other facilities, but how about an entire sports stadium? An American firm is already doing just that, and now has plans to expand its system across Europe.

Amazon announces Prime Day 2019 date: Prepare for 2 days of deals

The once one-day event is slated to span a whole 48 hours, with the best deals beginning as early as midnight on Monday, July 15, and carrying on through July 16. This is the longest Amazon Prime Day ever.