Let’s Burn The Flag

I trust the top headline got your attention. For the record, I wouldn?t dream of doing violence to the stars and stripes. However another flag, the broadcast flag, is in the news again with the Federal Communications Commission?s announcement that it has approved 13 different ways of implementing the copy protection technology.

Actually, isn?t the term ?copy protection? a bit vague? Whom does it protect? Not the consumer. The term ?copyright protection? comes a bit closer to the truth though the term ?digital rights management??copyright protection for the era of zeroes and ones?is becoming trendier. Perhaps we should just call a spade a spade and call it ?anti-copying? technology.

Anyhow, the broadcast flag got started as a way of preventing broadcast television programming from finding its way into the file-sharing moshpit. The assumption is that what flies through the airwaves must not be allowed to fly through the Internet. The controversial solution is to embed a code, or flag, in digital TV programming to prevent unauthorized use.

Of course this doesn?t make a bit of sense. Broadcast television programming, digital or otherwise, is free and it?s delivered over the public airwaves?which, as I?ve pointed out in a past column, are owned by you and me. Under the Supreme Court?s 1984 Betamax Decision, broadcast TV programs may be recorded for time-shifting purposes and personal use in general. File sharing of these programs seems a logical extension of that court-sanctioned right.

Nonetheless the entertainment industry is waging an indiscriminate war against file sharing in all its forms and has jawboned the government and the consumer electronics industry into accepting the broadcast flag. That?s the bad news.

The good news is that there?s some wiggle room here. Each of these 13 FCC-approved ?digital output technologies and recording methods? is designed to fit a specific type of product or technology?something the electronics industry would like you to buy?so various players have opened up various loopholes for various products.

For instance, JVC, the developer of the D-VHS VCR, lets you hook up two of these digital-recording products and dub flagged programming from one to the other. The kinds of programming you might legally dub would include broadcast TV or something you shot with your camcorder. To protect movie copyrights, JVC has built various kinds of anti-copying technology into D-VHS, but they won?t be triggered unless you try to do something you know you shouldn?t do, like dub a commercial copy of a movie.

Philips and Hewlett-Packard got approval for another form of flag compliance that would affect their Vidi recordable-DVD format. This scheme would bind content to the physical medium. In other words, you could copy flag-encoded material with a Vidi drive, but someone else?s Vidi drive couldn?t copy the copy. That one-generation-only loophole is the same one used by the Serial Copy Management System (or SCMS, pronounced ?scums?), which affects black-box CD-R decks.

What about networking? Thomson, better known for its RCA brandname, provides a flexible implementation of the flag in its SmartRight networking system. Flagged content is encoded as a ?private copy? that may be shared over a ?private personal network,? which might include up to 10 displays, and an unlimited number of storage devices, and could even extend to a second home, office, or boat.

 In Microsoft?s Windows Media Digital Rights Management Technology, the idea is to limit streaming and storage devices with ?proximity controls? that cap the number of milliseconds the signal may travel. You could probably fling stuff to just about any corner of your home but wouldn?t be able to send it down the street.

You get the idea. Manufacturers are willing to accept some degree of copyright protection, but are not willing to give away all your fair-use rights, because they need you to buy their products. They?re looking for a compromise you?ll accept. If you want to know what a prospective purchase is capable?and not capable?of, you?ll have to read every word of reviews written by people like, say, oh, myself.

For the libertarians of the electronics world the best copyright protection is none at all. They assert that the broadcast flag is a Trojan horse for less acceptable anti-copying schemes. That?s why the Electronic Frontier Foundation has launched the Digital Television Liberation Front (www.eff.org/broadcastflag) to encourage consumers to buy flag-noncompliant gear before flag compliance becomes mandated in new gear on July 1, 2005. In the meantime you?re free to buy a high-def-capable tuner card, like the pcHDTV HD-3000 (www.pchdtv.com), and an HD-capable video recorder like the one from MythTV (www.mythtv.org).

As an author of books, I do have at least some sympathy for the entertainment industry. Just as Hollywood needs revenue so that it can keep on making movies with those big-budget effects of which we?re all so fond, I need people to buy my books so that I can pay rent, buy health insurance, keep the fridge full?and keep writing books.

An author/publisher like myself has it relatively easy. Your basic tree-killing book is relatively hack-proof. Most people would rather buy a new book than use a photocopier or scanner to duplicate every page. There are loopholes?you might buy a secondhand copy for less money or check a book out of your public library for free. However, I accept those loopholes, and consider them fair use, partly because I read plenty of secondhand and library books myself.

Copyright protection is not so much a question of yes or no as a matter of how and what. We should accept it?in some reasonably fair form?so that the entertainment industry will feel secure enough to give HDTV, high-def DVD, DVD-Audio, and SACD the support they so richly deserve. These initial implementations of the broadcast flag contain some interesting ideas. Maybe we could live with some of them. Why not use proximity controls to allow networking on a limited basis?

Worse solutions are on the horizon?like the proposed Inducing Infringement of Copyrights Act, which would outlaw products we now take for granted such as unfettered CD-R drives. Any senator or congressman who approves such a draconian law is unworthy of your vote.

Letting the market decide would be healthier in the long run. Manufacturers know that if you don?t like something, you?ll take your business elsewhere, migrating to other forms of electronic entertainment, and make no mistake?these people want to sell stuff!

Digital rights management schemes that hit the sweet spot for program producers, manufacturers, and consumers alike will bring prosperity and give the breath of life to whole new product categories. Unacceptable ones contain the seeds of their own destruction.


Mark Fleischmann is the author of Practical Home Theater (www.quietriverpress.com).

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Movies & TV

He created comics, movies, and superheroes. But Stan Lee lived for joy

Stan Lee was a creator, a celebrity, an icon, and beneath it all, a real-life good guy with all the same human qualities that made his superheroes so relatable. And his greatest joy was sharing his creations with the world.

How to easily record your laptop screen with apps you already have

Learning how to record your computer screen shouldn't be a challenge. Lucky for you, our comprehensive guide lays out how to do so using a host of methods, including both free and premium utilities, in both MacOS and Windows 10.
Digital Trends Live

Singer Racella talks recording, drawing inspiration from trauma

On episode 15 of DT Daily, Digital Trend's daily morning show, host Greg Nibler talked to singer-songwriter Racella about her new EP, Waves, how to make music with an iPhone, and more.

Protecting your PDF with a password isn't difficult. Just follow these steps

If you need to learn how to password protect a PDF, you have come to the right place. This guide will walk you through the process of protecting your documents step-by-step, whether you're running a MacOS or Windows machine.
Home Theater

I’ve seen the 8K TV future, and you should be excited. Here’s why

Samsung set the tech world on fire when it announced it would sell an 85-inch 8K TV in the U.S. along with several 8K screen sizes in Europe. Debates over the validity and value of such a high resolution have continued since, and we're here…

Inferiority is a feature now! Palm's new plan is psychotic

The Palm is a smartphone to reduce your smartphone usage, or a small smartphone for when you don't want to carry your big smartphone. Palm itself doesn't seem sure which it is, but either way, it's a product that's so witless, we're amazed…
Home Theater

Budget TVs are finally worth buying, and you can thank Roku

Not all that long ago, budget TVs were only worth looking at if, well, you were on a budget. Thanks to Roku, not only are budget TVs now a viable option for anyone, but they might even be a better buy than more expensive TVs.

Huawei and Leica’s monochrome lens is dead, so we celebrate its life

The Huawei Mate 20 and Mate 20 Pro do not have a dedicated monochrome camera lens, unlike the P20 Pro, and various Huawei and Leica phones before it. It's the end of an era, and also the start of a new one, as Leica has worked on its…

Smartphone makers are vomiting a torrent of new phones, and we’re sick of it

Smartphone manufacturers like Huawei, LG, Sony, and Motorola are releasing far too many similar phones. The update cycle has accelerated, but more choice is not always a good thing.

Do we even need 5G at all?

Faster phones, easier access to on-demand video, simpler networking -- on the surface, 5G sounds like a dream. So why is it more of a nightmare?

Razer’s most basic Blade 15 is the one most gamers should buy

Razer's Blade 15 is an awesome laptop for both gamers, streamers, professionals, and anyone else needing serious go in a slim profile, but its price is out of reach for many games. The new Blade 15 Base solves that problem with few…

Going to hell, again. The Switch makes 'Diablo 3' feel brand-new

I've played every version of Diablo 3 released since 2012, racking up hundreds of hours in the process. Six years later, I'm playing it yet again on Nintendo Switch. Somehow, it still feels fresh.
Home Theater

The Apple AirPods 2 needed to come out today. Here are four reasons why

Apple announced numerous new products at its October 30 event, a lineup that included a new iPad Pro, a MacBook Air, as well as a new Mac Mini. Here are four reasons we wish a new set of AirPods were on that list.

‘Fallout 76’ may have online multiplayer but it’s still a desolate wasteland

"Is Fallout 76 an MMO?" That depends on who you ask. Critics and players often cite its online multiplayer capabilities as a reason it qualifies. Yet calling the game an MMO only confuses matters, and takes away from what could make…