Can you spot a faked photo? Here’s how National Geographic does it

how nat geo finds fake photos
National Geographic Society
When National Geographic moved pyramids with early editing equipment in 1982, digital photo editing was in its infancy. Today, Photoshop is commonplace — and faked photos are that much harder to spot. Susan Goldberg, Nat Geo’s editor in chief, recently shared where the magazine stands on manipulated images, and how it spots them.

The concept behind spotting a fake is simple — Nat Geo asks for the RAW files. While there are workarounds, RAW photos keep track of the adjustments made to the images. With metadata, spotting a faked RAW photo is simpler than eyeing an altered JPEG. Since the RAW file type differs between cameras, a simple “Save As” is an ineffective workaround.

The only Photoshop adjustments the publication allows are changes that show how the photographer saw the real scene.

While supplying RAW files may be a simple method, Goldberg says it’s not always so easy to spot altered images — and part of that comes from finding where to draw the line. The only Photoshop adjustments the publication allows are changes that show how the photographer saw the real scene. For example, the camera may not always capture colors accurately, either through an incorrect white balance or the limited range of digital camera sensors. Moving objects and adding or removing elements from the scene, on the other hand, will quickly get images rejected, the guidelines suggest.

Along with the 1982 pyramid photo that was altered, recent controversy surrounding Steve McCurry’s use of Photoshop also showed that an image he took for the cover was altered through the cloning of parts of the background to make a horizontal shot fit in a vertical space.

“In the digital age, when it’s easy to manipulate a photo, it’s harder than ever to ensure that the images we publish, whether on paper or on a screen, reflect the reality of what a photographer saw through his or her viewfinder,” she wrote.

While digging down to the original RAW photo helps identify doctored images, that procedure is not always available. In 2010, the magazine published a photo from their Your Shot contributors, only to learn later that the image had been altered.

If the RAW photo isn’t available, Goldberg says the firm asks a lot of detailed questions about the shot — even if the photo in question is a stock image or a Your Shot contribution. The magazine also asks writers for their original notes.

While Goldberg says the magazine is committed to not repeating past mistakes (like altering the horizontal pyramid photo in 1982 to fit a vertical cover space by actually moving the pyramids closer together), deciding where to draw the line is still a matter of opinion. “One of our photographers recently entered a photo in a contest” she wrote. “It was rejected as being over-processed; our editors, on the other hand, saw the same photo and thought it was OK. We published it. Were we right, or were the contest judges right? That’s a subject that we can continue to discuss.”

Smart Home

Amazon patents a technology to help Alexa fight fake voice attacks

Amazon filed a patent this month for a new technology that looks like it would help its digital assistant Alexa fight fake voice attacks that could potentially fool Alexa's biometric security protocols.
Photography

From DIY to AAA, here's how to take a passport photo in 6 different ways

If you're applying for a passport or renewing one, you need to submit a photo in your official application. There are strict guidelines, but fortunately, it's something you can do at home. Here's how to take a passport photo.
Social Media

Nearly a million Facebook users followed these fake Russian accounts

Facebook purged two separate groups behind more than 500 fake accounts with Russian ties. One group had ties to Russian news agency Sputnik, while the other had behavior similar to the Internet Research Agency's midterm actions.
Music

Tidal faces legal jeopardy over fake stream numbers accusation

In another challenging chapter for music subscription service Tidal, Norwegian authorities have begun a formal investigation into charges that the company faked millions of streams for artists such as Kanye West and Beyoncé.
Photography

The best mirrorless cameras pack all the power of a DSLR, minus the bulk

Mirrorless cameras offer a lot of photography firepower, inside a compact body. Explore the best mirrorless cameras, from the pro-level to the beginner-friendly shooters, in this guide.
Photography

This A.I.-powered camera follows the action to produce epic selfie videos

Want to capture more epic action selfies? The Obsbot Tail is a camera-gimbal combo that uses artificial intelligence to follow the action. Using a handful of different modes, the camera works to keep the action in the frame.
Photography

Sony crams its best camera tech into the new $900 A6400

Love Sony's autofocus, but can't stomach the full-frame price? The Sony A6400 mirrorless camera uses some of the same autofocus technology and the processor of the A9 in a compact, more affordable crop-sensor camera.
Photography

These point-and-shoot cameras make your smartphone pics look like cave paintings

If your smartphone camera just isn't giving you the results you're looking for, maybe it's time to step up your game. The latest and greatest point-and-shoot cameras offer large sensors, tough bodies, and long lenses -- something no phone…
Photography

GoPro bumps resolution on Fusion 360 cam to 5.6K with new firmware

Currently available in public beta, Fusion firmware version 2.0 offers a new 5.8K mode that results in 5.6K output when the 360 camera's two hemispheres are stitched together. It also adds support for 24 fps video and RAW time-lapse…
Photography

With 5-stop optical stabilization, Fujifilm GF 100-200mm is ready for adventure

Fujifilm revealed a new lens designed to deliver on the GFX system's promise of adventure-ready medium-format photography. The GF 100-200mm F5.6 R is a weather resistant, relatively lightweight, 2x telephoto with impressive stabilization.
Photography

Olympus teaser shares glimpse of OM-D camera that’s good for more than sports

Is Olympus about to release a new mirrorless camera geared toward sports photographers? The latest teaser offers a glimpse of an upcoming OM-D camera set to launch on January 24, and by the looks of the teasers, it's capable for landscapes…
Photography

Nikon A1000, B600 pack big zooms into compact, budget-friendly cameras

The new Nikon Coolpix A1000 packs in a 35x zoom lens, 4K video, and an optical viewfinder, while Nikon's B600 brings a 60x zoom lens to the table. The cameras are modest updates to Nikon's budget-friendly zoom models.
Emerging Tech

The best drone photos from around the world will take your breath away

Most of today's drones come equipped with high-end cameras, which are quickly revolutionizing the world of aerial photography as we know it. Here are some of the best drone photos from around the world.
Photography

Photography news: Careful, self-driving cars can ruin your camera sensor

In this week's photography news, learn how self-driving cars destroyed a digital camera via lasers. Find out how many patents Canon filed for in 2018. Read about what Tamron lenses are available for the Nikon Z6.