Skip to main content

No, the government can’t go undercover with fake profiles, Facebook says

Juan Pablo Arenas / Pexels

The U.S. Department of Homeland Security now allows officers to create fake profiles to try to catch lies on visa, green card and citizenship applications — but Facebook doesn’t. After the DHS updated its policies last week, Facebook released a statement saying that the network will remove any fake accounts, even if those fake accounts come from undercover government agents.

“Law enforcement authorities, like everyone else, are required to use their real names on Facebook and we make this policy clear. Operating fake accounts is not allowed, and we will act on any violating accounts,” Facebook’s Sarah Pollack said in a statement to the Associated Press.

The updated DHS policy allows officers to create fake online profiles — which was previously banned by the agency — in order to spot potential security concerns, as well as fraud. The policy, updated in July and shared online last week, keeps a few restrictions in place, however. 

Officers are not allowed to interact with users and cannot send friend requests or follow a user to access posts with more stringent privacy settings. According to the AP, officers are required to undergo annual training related to the policy. While the change doesn’t allow officers to access private posts, some content is difficult to access without an account.

 A review of social media accounts are now part of the application process for a U.S. visa, but the way some social networks are designed makes much of the user’s information inaccessible to third parties who do not have an active account. Fake accounts could potentially allow the agent reviewing the application to have easier access to this data. According to the AP, the practice would likely be used on applications that are flagged for further review.

Fake accounts have long been against Facebook rules and the network says automated processes help find and block millions of fake accounts on a daily basis. The network says that all detected fake accounts — including any that could come from the DHS policy change — are blocked and removed. Facebook has previously removed fake accounts that the network believes had ties to government agencies, including a recent shutdown of accounts with suspected ties to the Chinese government.

Twitter’s policy also bans fake accounts, but the network says it is reviewing the new DHS guidelines to determine how to proceed.

Editors' Recommendations

Hillary K. Grigonis
Hillary never planned on becoming a photographer—and then she was handed a camera at her first writing job and she's been…
Twitter ditches legacy check marks, and it’s already confusing
A stylized composite of the Twitter logo.

Twitter has started removing the blue check marks from accounts that have not signed up to its Blue subscription service.

Before Elon Musk acquired Twitter last October in a deal worth $44 billion, verification check marks were given to high-profile accounts belonging to celebrities, politicians, sports stars, journalists, and businesses, among others.

Read more
Twitter gives blue check mark to dead folks
Twitter logo in white stacked on top of a blue stylized background with the Twitter logo repeating in shades of blue.

The continuing saga of Twitter and its blue check mark has taken a bizarre twist as it seems that a number of deal celebrities are now paying for Twitter Blue.

On the orders of new owner Elon Musk, Twitter last week started removing blue check marks from accounts that have not signed up for Twitter Blue, its premium tier.

Read more
These are the 10 most-viewed YouTube videos of all time
The red and white YouTube logo on a phone screen. The phone is on a white background.

Being popular is about the only thing the current most-viewed YouTube videos have in common with their top-performing predecessors. Even though YouTube videos like Chocolate Rain went viral during the first few years of YouTube's content, they probably wouldn't be among the kinds of videos that go viral on the platform now.

In fact, children's programming and music videos are now among the most-viewed content on YouTube. Music videos, in particular, have enjoyed great success on the streaming site and, until recently, had been the majority of the most-viewed videos in YouTube's history. Music videos still account for 40% of the top 10 most-viewed videos, however. The other 60% is content for young children. If these view counts are anything to go by, the video-sharing site could be considered a leading platform for music videos and kid-friendly content, rather than just the memeworthy viral videos the site was known for in its early days.
What is the most-viewed YouTube video of all time?
Baby Shark Dance is the most-viewed video ever on YouTube. The children's song overtook the all-Spanish version of Despacito in November 2020.
What are the top 10 most-viewed YouTube videos?

Read more