Skip to main content

Will the companies feeding Vine’s growth ultimately poison it?

Vine App IconVine just launched a month ago, but it’s growing faster than a baby elephant on an all-carb diet. The fledgling app already weathered its first major PR crisis after it developed a porn problem, and now famous users and big brands are joining in droves.

Celebrities love to interact with fans and promote their work (and themselves) on Twitter, and now they’re flocking to new video-sharing social network Vine to do the same. Big names like Jimmy Fallon and Kate Upton are uploading goofy six-second looping videos to the site, giving fans a glimpse into their lives. And brands already figured out the app’s value as a promotional tool. From Cadbury’s to Armani to Gap, big names are signing up to stay up-to-date on the latest social marketing trend. There’s even a site called Brands on Vine collecting the best of these corporate-sponsored video snippets.

And Vine is following Twitter’s footsteps and handing out verification badges to noteworthy users, establishing a hierarchy amongst users that values people and companies on the hunt for yet more exposure – because there is no such thing as enough when it comes to social self-promotion.

More users, more creative content

Vine’s explosive popularity isn’t a bad thing – this is the stuff of startup app-maker dreams. As more people use the service, chances increase that someone will do something really original with the platform. Most people are embarrassed by the first things they tweeted years ago, and some of our first Instagrams were likewise lame – that fact that most of them were taken with the iPhone 3 means quality suffered greatly. That will probably be the case for Vine in a few years. People using Vine are just getting a feel for what you can do with its services, and they will get better at making entertaining Vines as time progresses. (Sidenote: have we settled on a verb for making a Vine yet? Vine-ing? Vining? Vineifying? Get back to me.)

You can already see how people are getting in the swing of things with this new medium and having fun. If you go to the “Explore” section and check out the “How to” section, you’ll see tons of clever instructional videos, ranging from straightforward gaming tips to silly entries on how to get fired or be a ladies’ man.

And even if people join Vine to showcase their talents instead of just on a lark, that doesn’t mean what they produce will necessarily be self-promotional garbage. Animators and artists are using the medium to create beautiful, funny pieces:

Professional funny people like The Daily Show correspondent John Hodgman and show writer Travon Free played with the app and with hilarious results, releasing a slew of funny videos. These clips show how people can use Vine to communicate and joke around with each other, just as they do Twitter.

And journalists are getting the hang of Vine, too. One intrepid reporter in Ankara, Turkey, used Vine to capture the aftermath of the bombing of the American Embassy at the beginning of February. As writers and newsmakers get more accustomed to the app, they may pull it out to spontaneously record important moments.

Introducing Vine, the PR service

Twitter manages to straddle the line well between creative communication outlet and publicity tool, but with so many big brands and self-promotional celebrities glomming onto Vine so soon, it might prioritize monetizing the service over making it as interesting as possible. When something blow up like this, it’s a boon for the creators, but sometimes a bust for users. Risks get avoided and focus shifts to how to profit.

Vine isn’t just a random app skyrocketing to success. Twitter bought it back in October 2012, and this lightning-fast rise is no coincidence.

Trendy clothing outlet Urban Outfitters led the charge for brands on Vine, preying on the Internet’s universal obsession with cute animals and posting a dog video. Content providers like BuzzFeed uploaded silly dancing videos.

Vine undoubtedly wants to keep growing. But it needs to keep a firm grip on expanding without diluting the quality of the videos uploaded with promotional materials. Companies are going to keep trying to use it as a PR vehicle, and the app may need to do something to prevent companies from becoming too dominant a voice. There’s already Vine analytics services and a tutorials prepping companies to take advantage of the app, and we’ve barely just gotten our hands on it.

If you go to the website Vinepeek, you’ll see a constant stream of unedited new Vines playing. Some are boring, but many are wonderful – footage of babies playing, dogs frolicking, delicious foods being cooked, people working and laughing. There are celebrity spottings and artfully edited videos of morning commutes. It’s a hypnotizing site that gives you a glimpse of how interesting Vine can be. But if brands and companies start to embrace Vine as a marketing tool, Vinepeek might start looking less like a collection of slices of life and more like a collection of slogans.

Vine’s exponential growth is great, but hopefully Twitter won’t over-do it trying to monetize the service and lose sight of what could make it truly great: It’s a platform that offers a lot of wiggle room to get weird and be creative.

No privacy, no magic?

Social networks like Facebook and Instagram have both come under fire for privacy snafus, but at one point each held a special place in users’ hearts as a beloved tool. Facebook traded exclusivity for mainstream success, and even though it lead to massive expansion and going public, it also changed the way people used it. When it was solely the domain of college kids, people weren’t as worried about what they put on the site; it was a way to see peers, not establish a new public persona. All of that changed as it grew, and though the site remains extremely popular, people don’t hold it in the same esteem. And Instagram’s trajectory is looking similar. What started as a little, unique place to share with friends online exploded into one of the most popular mobile apps, and Instagram’s deal with Facebook and privacy agreement scandal diminished its status as a truly special social app.

Vine’s videos are automatically set to public. You can’t fine-tune the privacy settings because there are none. What you put up is meant for everyone’s eyes. This reflects the way things are headed at Facebook and Instagram, and it doesn’t take away from Vine’s potential as an awesome creative tool. But it also might stymy an environment of experimentation. Since Vine is already affiliated with Twitter and designed for totally public sharing, it may end up attracting more brands looking to promote than people looking to say something new.

Editors' Recommendations

Kate Knibbs
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kate Knibbs is a writer from Chicago. She is very happy that her borderline-unhealthy Internet habits are rewarded with a…
How to make a GIF from a YouTube video
woman sitting and using laptop

Sometimes, whether you're chatting with friends or posting on social media, words just aren't enough -- you need a GIF to fully convey your feelings. If there's a moment from a YouTube video that you want to snip into a GIF, the good news is that you don't need complex software to so it. There are now a bunch of ways to make a GIF from a YouTube video right in your browser.

If you want to use desktop software like Photoshop to make a GIF, then you'll need to download the YouTube video first before you can start making a GIF. However, if you don't want to go through that bother then there are several ways you can make a GIF right in your browser, without the need to download anything. That's ideal if you're working with a low-specced laptop or on a phone, as all the processing to make the GIF is done in the cloud rather than on your machine. With these options you can make quick and fun GIFs from YouTube videos in just a few minutes.
Use GIFs.com for great customization
Step 1: Find the YouTube video that you want to turn into a GIF (perhaps a NASA archive?) and copy its URL.

Read more
I paid Meta to ‘verify’ me — here’s what actually happened
An Instagram profile on an iPhone.

In the fall of 2023 I decided to do a little experiment in the height of the “blue check” hysteria. Twitter had shifted from verifying accounts based (more or less) on merit or importance and instead would let users pay for a blue checkmark. That obviously went (and still goes) badly. Meanwhile, Meta opened its own verification service earlier in the year, called Meta Verified.

Mostly aimed at “creators,” Meta Verified costs $15 a month and helps you “establish your account authenticity and help[s] your community know it’s the real us with a verified badge." It also gives you “proactive account protection” to help fight impersonation by (in part) requiring you to use two-factor authentication. You’ll also get direct account support “from a real person,” and exclusive features like stickers and stars.

Read more
Here’s how to delete your YouTube account on any device
How to delete your YouTube account

Wanting to get out of the YouTube business? If you want to delete your YouTube account, all you need to do is go to your YouTube Studio page, go to the Advanced Settings, and follow the section that will guide you to permanently delete your account. If you need help with these steps, or want to do so on a platform that isn't your computer, you can follow the steps below.

Note that the following steps will delete your YouTube channel, not your associated Google account.

Read more