Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

Apple ordered to pay $85 million to WiLan in patent-infringement case

In a long and drawn-out case over patent infringement, Apple has been ordered to pay $85 million to Canadian company WiLan, as reported by Bloomberg.

The court case has been bouncing around for several years, and this latest ruling comes from the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California (San Diego). A jury ruled that Apple did infringe patents and will have to fork over a payment to WiLan’s parent organization, Quarterhill Inc.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Although that’s a hefty sum for Apple to pay out, it could have been worse. In 2018, a different jury in the same case ruled that Apple should pay a sum of $145.1 million for damages related to patent infringement.

Apple disagreed with the 2018 court’s decision, saying that the way the damages were calculated was inaccurate. After the previous award was disputed, a judge agreed with Apple that the damages were too high and offered WiLan the option to accept $10 million in damages or go back to court. The case went back to court again, resulting in the $85 million figure.

The specific technology at the center of the lawsuit is two wireless communications patents held by WiLan, one being “a method and apparatus for allocating bandwidth in a broadband wireless communication system” (U.S. patent 8457145), and the other related “to communication systems and to systems and methods for implementing adaptive call admission control” (U.S. patent 8537757).

This comes after a long history of animosity between the two companies. Quarterhill has been mostly unsuccessful in its fight with Apple over the last years, with judges not often convinced that its patents entitled it to compensation from the sales of devices like iPhones. In 2013, Apple was taken to court over another WiLan patent, this one regarding MDA and HSPA wireless communication technologies.

Apple has also been accused of patent infringement by other companies, including a long legal battle with Qualcomm over royalties for the Intel modems used in certain iPhone models. Then there’s a claim from Israeli firm Corephotonics that Apple copied its dual-lens camera technology for the iPhone. On the other hand, Apple has also taken Samsung to court over claims that Samsung copied the iPhone.

Apple has not yet announced whether it plans to appeal this latest ruling, although it seems likely it will.

Georgina Torbet
Georgina is the Digital Trends space writer, covering human space exploration, planetary science, and cosmology. She…
How to download YouTube videos on PC, iOS, Android, and Mac
A smartphone displaying YouTube on its screen as it lays on top of a laptop's keyboard.

If you're a YouTube fan like us, you might want to know what the most viewed YouTube videos are, and how to download YouTube videos.

Downloading a video from YouTube doesn’t seem like a big deal at first glance, but it comes with ethical concerns to consider, depending on the original post’s intent. As we've already mentioned, it's something Google definitely doesn't want you doing — it's a clear violation of YouTube's Terms of Service, but it's even more important to keep the original content creators in mind.

Read more
A new Best Buy sale just started – our 11 favorite deals
Presidents Day sales with electonic devices packed in open boxes.

If you've been looking to do some shopping recently but haven't found the best time, you're in luck! Best Buy has just started an excellent weekend sale with many different products, but, to help save you some hassle, we've collected our 11 favorite deals from the bunch, ranging from robot vacuums to gaming laptops. So, without further ado, let's dive right in!
Shark ION Robot RV761 -- $143, was $260

If you're looking to dip your toes into robot vacuums without spending a lot, the Shark ION Robot RV761 falls within the Shark Ion 700 range and has a few nifty features, making it a good starting robot vacuum. For example, it has a triple brush mechanism that makes it great for picking up pet hair and does relatively well on carpeted flooring. It also has its own that allows you to schedule and control it to fit your schedule, and it comes with sensing technology that lets it avoid bumping into things. On the other hand, it doesn't have home mapping, which is great for the privacy-minded, but that does mean the occasional bump does happen. The Shark ION RV761 has about 90 minutes of battery life before it takes itself in for recharging.

Read more
When is Prime Day 2023? Dates confirmed for the shopping event
Best Prime Day 2022 Deals graphic with multiple products.

After weeks of speculation, we finally know when Prime Day 2023 is kicking off. Amazon has announced that the event will start July 11 at 3AM ET and will run through July 12. As always, Prime members can score some fantastic deals from the sale with popular brands like Peloton, Victoria's Secret, YETI, and Sony just some of the names being touted by Amazon as featuring in the big sale. Members will also be able to shop more deals on small business products than ever before too. As always, expect great discounts on Amazon-owned properties like Kindles, Ring doorbells, Amazon Echo units, and so much more. It's the sale we've all been waiting for since Black Friday.

The Prime Day deals promise to drop every 30 minutes during select periods with deep discounts expected. Select discounts on other Amazon-related things are already available such as 20% off in-store purchases at

Read more