Apple Trounces Psystar in Court Ruling

By Geoff Duncan November 16, 2009

Image used with permission by copyright holder

It’s a legal fight that’s been brewing for over a year, but now a heavy hammer has come down: U.S. District Judge William Alsup has ruled categorically against Mac clone maker Psystar, finding the company violated Apple’s copyrights by pre-installing Mac OS X on its own Intel-based computers. The judge also threw out Psystar’s motions that Apple was misusing copyright law to monopolize a market, and that Psystar had the right to do anything it liked with Mac OS X under the “first sale” doctrine.

“Psystar has violated Apple’s exclusive reproduction right, distribution right, and right to create derivative works,” Judge Alsup wrote in his ruling (available as a PDF via Groklaw). “Accordingly, Apple’s motion for summary judgment on copyright infringement must be granted.” The ruling also found that Psystar violated the anti-circumvention and anti-trafficking provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA).

The ruling provides legal backbone to end-user license agreements (EULAs) included with most commercial software and operating systems. Apple’s EULA for Mac OS X restricts the software to use on Apple computers and specifically disallows using the operating system on non-Apple systems.

While the ruling is a sweeping victory for Apple—and few in the legal community expected any other outcome—it does not mean an end to the legal wrangling between Psystar and Apple: Judge Alsup did not rule on damages from copyright infringement, or on Apple’s claims involving trademark infringement, breach of contract, and other issues. Psystar also has a case pending against Apple in Florida, in which it claims Apple illegally ties Mac OS X 10.6 “Snow Leopard” to Apple hardware; however, in light of Judge Alsup’s ruling, Psystar’s Florida case seems like a very, very dim hope.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Apple

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Computing

Best Apple Studio Display deals: Save $299 on 5K monitors

Apple Mac Studio and Studio Display.

If you're working on things that require a high-end monitor with excellent resolution and image fidelity, then the Apple Studio Display is what you're looking for, especially if you're in the Apple ecosystem and using things like the Apple MacBook Pro and the Apple MacBook Air. As a 5k monitor, it blows a lot of other monitors out of the water, although it does come with a deep price tag, so if you're the sort of creative pro that's looking to up their game, you'll likely want to grab yourself a good monitor deal. Lukcily, you can get some good discounts on the Apple Studio Display, depending on which model your looking for, and if you're thinking of pairing this with a new Apple computer, check out some of these Apple deals as well.
Apple Studio Display — $1,300, was $1,599

The Apple Studio Display is one of the more premium monitors on the market. It’s not to be confused with the Apple Pro Display XDR, which is Apple’s professional, high end monitor. And while the Apple Studio Display and Pro Display XDR have some similarities, the Studio Display comes in at a much lower price tag. It has a 27-inch screen that comes with 5K resolution and 600 nits of brightness, as well as support for one billion colors and the P3 wide color gamut. It also has a six-speaker sound system with Spatial Audio, which makes it a great place to sit down and watch movie.

Computing

How to create a Smart Playlist in Apple Music

Creating a Smart Playlist in Music on a MacBook.

If you own a Mac, one of the best ways to take advantage of the built-in Music app is with Smart Playlists. These are automated song libraries that will periodically update, based on criteria you select when building this special playlist. It’s totally free to make a Smart Playlist, and there’s no cap on how many you can have either.

Computing

Best Apple deals: Save on AirPods, Apple Watch, iPad, MacBook

Apple MacBook Air M1 open, on a table.

Apple has been a big player in the tech space for a long time, and it has pioneered some of the technology we use today, such as best wireless earbuds and the best smartwatches. If that wasn't enough, it even makes some of the best best laptops and best tablets on the market, so pretty much whatever tech you're looking for, Apple has an excellent version of it. Not only that, but Apple's ecosystem is also easily one of the best available, with only Samsung really competing in that space, and if you're already in the Apple ecosystem, then it makes sense to continue buying stuff from Apple.

Of course, Apple tech can be quite pricey, which is why we've gone out and searched through various big retailers to find you some of the best deals we can find. That includes everything from the MacBook to the AirTag, so hopefully, you can find the perfect deal that fits your needs and budget.
Apple AirTag (4-Pack) -- $80, was $99