Skip to main content

Gamer Sues Developer after Spending 20,000 Hours Playing Game

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Hawaii native Craig Smallwood is claiming that the game Lineage II is so addictive that for five years, he apparently lost all measure of self-control and became  “unable to function independently in usual daily activities such as getting up, getting dressed, bathing or communicating with family and friends.”

Smallwood is suing Lineage maker, NCsoft of South Korea, claiming that the developer should pay an unspecified amount of money due to the addictive nature of the game. The suit states that Smallwood played the game between 2004 and 2009 for 20,000 hours, but would not have played if he were aware of the addictive nature of the game.  To put that in context, that entire five year period was only 43,848 hours, meaning that for nearly half of every moment over the five years, Smallwood was playing Lineage II, which Smallwood blames on the game.

”In light of plaintiff’s allegations, the court finds that plaintiff has stated a claim for both negligence and gross negligence,” U.S. District Judge Alan Kay stated in a ruling that was obtained by Wired.

For those that have not spent nearly half of the last five years playing it, Lineage II is a MMORPG that was released in 2003. Since the initial release, the game has seen several updates and expansion packs, and even now more are planned. As recently as 2007, the game still counted over 610,000 potential victims as active players.

This isn’t the first such claim against a game publisher. Typically, the defendant companies move for the suit to be immediately dismissed, and typically the judge agrees. NCsoft has again asked that the judge dismiss the claim, but for whatever reason, Judge Kay has decided that the case has enough merit to proceed.

Editors' Recommendations

Ryan Fleming
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Fleming is the Gaming and Cinema Editor for Digital Trends. He joined the DT staff in 2009 after spending time covering…
Ubisoft and more offer ways to play purchased Google Stadia games elsewhere
The protagonist of Assassin's Creed: Valhalla shouting in battle and wielding two axes.

Google recently announced that it plans to shutter its cloud gaming service Stadia in early 2023, leaving players who used it as one of their primary platforms in an awkward situation. Google already promised to refund people for their Google Stadia hardware and software purchases, but people are still losing access to games they enjoyed and save files they possibly dumped hours into. Thankfully, some developers are working on ways to help Stadia players.
The most notable studio to help Stadia players is Ubisoft, which was Google's earliest partner for the technology via an Assassin's Creed Odyssey demo. "While Stadia will shut down on January 18, 2023, we're happy to share that we're working to bring the games you own on Stadia to PC through Ubisoft Connect," Ubisoft tweeted. "We'll have more to share regarding specific details, as well as the impact for Ubisoft+ subscribers, at a later date." Thankfully, the Stadia versions of Assassin’s Creed Valhalla, Far Cry 6, Immortals Fenyx Rising, Tom Clancy’s The Division 2, and Watch Dogs: Legion support cross-progression, so players won't lose their save files. 
https://twitter.com/UbisoftSupport/status/1575922767593078793
Ubisoft isn't the only developer to help. Developer Muse Games is giving Embr Steam codes to those who played its comedic co-op firefighting game on Stadia if they email the developer with screenshots of Embr in their Stadia library. Meanwhile, IO Interactive confirmed that it is "looking into ways for you to continue your Hitman experience on other platforms," as the World of Assassination trilogy was available on Google Stadia. 
There's still the matter of the five Google Stadia exclusives: Gylt, Hello Engineer, Outcasters, Pac-Man Mega Tunnel Battle, and PixelJunk Raiders. So far, only one of those games seems like it will be saved. PixelJunk Raiders developer Q-Games said in a blog post that "we hope to find a way to continue to share the vibrant worlds of Planet Tantal in the future, and we’re open to discussing opportunities to find the right publishing partner to make it happen.. Tequila Works, tinyBuild, Splash Damage, and Bandai Namco Entertainment did not respond to requests for comment from Digital Trends.
While the shutdown of Google Stadia is disappointing for players like myself who enjoy cloud gaming, at least players will be get refunds, and in some cases get the game for a new platform.

Read more
U.K. government won’t ban loot boxes, but urges the games industry to police itself
Loot boxes in different games like Fortnite, Rocket League, PUBG, Dota 2

The U.K.'s Department of Digital, Culture, Media, and Sport (DCMS) has announced that it will not enact any laws regarding loot boxes, which are common in mobile games and some console games. Instead, it's calling on the video game industry to regulate loot boxes themselves after releasing its report containing the results of its investigation into the predatory gaming element on Sunday.

Two years ago, the DCMS launched a call for evidence into the effects loot boxes may cause on children and teens, as well as their impact on mental health, finances, and online gambling. The investigation elicited 32,000 responses to a player survey and 50 submissions from game companies, researchers and third-party organizations, as well as an independent rapid evidence assessment by the Innovation for Games and Media Enterprise (InGame), which was commissioned by the DCMS.

Read more
Don’t miss out on these great games from early 2022
Nobody Saves the World all forms

The first quarter of 2022 was packed with fantastic games. Elden Ring will likely go down as one of the best games ever made, and excellent titles like Kirby and the Forgotten Land, Sifu, and Horizon Forbidden West will give players dozens, if not hundreds of hours of entertainment. Those games will eventually end, and April and May 2022 are looking fairly light in terms of compelling releases.
We've rounded up several amazing indie and AA games that players might have missed during the first three crowded months of 2022. Those looking for something new to play before game announcements and launches pick up again in June can't go wrong with any of these six titles.
Nobody Saves the World
Nobody Saves the World - Launch Trailer
Nobody Saves the World seems like a relatively standard Zelda-like adventure game on its surface, but in actuality, it's a hilarious masterclass in engaging game progression. Players can change their wimpy main character into seventeen different forms, including a horse, rat, and more. Each form has unique abilities and skills, which can be mixed and matched with other forms to create countless loadouts. 
To level up, players must clear dungeons and complete form-specific challenges. There's always a dungeon to clear, a challenge to complete, or an ability combination to try in Nobody Saves the World, so it never gets old. On top of all of that, it features an amazing soundtrack and legitimately funny writing.
Nobody Saves the World is included with Xbox Games Pass, but there's no need to worry if you don't have an Xbox or PC. Nobody Saves the World will be released for PS4, PS5, and Nintendo Switch on April 15, so you'll be able to play it anywhere very soon.
OlliOlli World

Like Nobody Saves the World, Olli Olli World is quietly one of the best games of the year. OlliOlli World is an easy-to-pick-up 2D side-scrolling skateboarding game that features intricately designed levels and a lot of gameplay depth for those looking for it. 
"OlliOlli World is more than just a skateboarding game -- it's one of the best 2D platformers since Celeste," I wrote in a four-and-a-half star review. "Like the best games of the genre, it knows that easy-to-learn-but-hard-to-master mechanics, rewarding obstacles, and high speeds that test one's reaction time are the hallmarks of a great platformer."
Horizon Forbidden West, Sifu, and Elden Ring all came out around the time this game was released, so it didn't get much attention despite being published by Private Division, a prominent AA publisher. Still, this skateboarding game is secretly one of the best games of the year, so make sure you don't miss out on it. OlliOlli World is available on PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X, and Nintendo Switch, so there's no reason you need to miss out on it. 
Grapple Dog

Read more