Skip to main content

Following Kalamazoo tragedy, Uber faces questions about its driver vetting process

woman in back seat of car
Image used with permission by copyright holder
As Michigan begins its long healing process in the days after the Kalamazoo tragedy, our nation as a whole has been forced (yet again) to grapple with a number of recurring debates. Out of loss, it seems, must come some sense of learning to provide some small hope that lives were not lost in vain. While the gun control argument is one that we’ve heard a thousand times, a newer and perhaps more unique question now being raised lies in the Uber vetting process. Uber has showed no signs of slowing in terms of its almost meteoric rise to the top of the transportation industry, and as it grows larger, provides more rides, and hires more drivers, a very serious issue now stands — how well do we know the people whose cars we so willingly (and so frequently) enter?

Jason Dalton, the 45-year-old man responsible for the devastating attacks in Michigan, was revealed to be a driver for Uber Technologies Inc., spurring new interest in the company’s review process for its employees. This is by no means the first time the San Francisco-based startup has received flack for its seemingly lax driver guidelines — reports of assault, rape, and otherwise have been noted for years, both in the United States and internationally.

While Uber says that it is fully cooperating with the police’s investigation, the company has maintained that its “safety protocol is robust and adequate.” And on Monday, Uber’s Chief Security Officer Joe Sullivan noted that the company had no plans to change the way it vets its drivers as a result of the tragedy.

“If there is nothing on someone’s record, no background check will raise a red flag,” Sullivan said on a media conference call. Indeed, Uber’s Rachel Whetstone told People Magazine, “[Dalton] had no criminal background so nothing would have turned up for him during the background check he passed. Unfortunately, this man just decided to go and do what he did. It is hard to know how to deal with these people who go rogue.”

But some believe that it is, in fact, Uber’s responsibility to ensure that its drivers do not, as Whetstone says, “go rogue,” resulting in the consequences involving human life. Or at the very least, that Uber must somehow do better in determining who among its vast employee base has a greater chance of erratic and violent behavior.

Other critics have noted that Uber’s background check policy is not nearly as robust as it could be. Not only does Uber “never meet (drivers) in person to see if they get a strange vibe,” according to Who’s Driving You spokesman Dave Sutton, but neither Uber nor Lyft actually have a fingerprint check in place.

“This driver was acting irrationally and operating his vehicle erratically … in the hours leading up to and between these senseless shootings,” said Gary Buffo, the president of the National Limousine Association. And whether a more robust background check system — whether that means in-person interviews or more record-checking — could’ve saved lives, we’ll simply never know.

Editors' Recommendations

Lulu Chang
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
Visible’s affordable 5G plans just got even cheaper
The Visible logo on a smartphone.

Visible has a new offer that can help you save significant money when switching to its service. Both Visible and Visible+ packages are now available for purchase upfront on an annual basis. These new annual plans are available for new Visible customers starting today, while existing customers will gain access to them this May.

With this new deal, the Visible+ plan costs $395 per year when paid upfront instead of $540 when paid in 12 monthly installments of $45 each. This means you can save $145, which is 26%. That's an incredible savings. When paying upfront for the regular Visible plan, it will cost $275 per year, saving you $25. If you pay for it monthly, the standard Visible plan costs $25 per month (or $300 per year).

Read more
iPhone SE 4: news, rumored price, release date, and more
The Apple iPhone SE (2022) and Apple iPhone SE (2020) together.

While the spotlight always seems to be on Apple’s mainline iPhones, the iPhone SE is a great pick for those who are on a budget. If you want an iPhone that doesn't break the bank, the SE is the way to go.

The original iPhone SE came out in 2016, and then Apple revamped it in 2020 and 2022 by giving it some more modern hardware. The iPhone SE tends to get updated every two or so years rather than annually like the traditional iPhone. This means  that we should see a new iPhone SE 4 this year, but it’s not so cut-and-dried with this particular model.

Read more
Hurry! This Apple Watch just had its price slashed to $189
The app grid view on the Apple Watch SE 2.

For great smartwatch deals, head to Amazon immediately. Today, it has the Apple Watch SE (2nd gen) for $60 off bringing it down to just $189 from $249. A fantastic price for an exceptionally well-made smartwatch, this tops our list of the best Apple deals right now. If you’re keen to buy a watch that will motivate you to move more while also looking good, check it out by tapping the button below. Alternatively, read on while we explain all.

Why you should buy the Apple Watch SE (2nd gen)
One of the best smartwatches around, the Apple Watch SE (2nd gen) is best described as “simple, cheap, and brilliant”. It’s designed to help you exercise more effectively, while keeping connected with your digital life, and also staying safe.

Read more