Skip to main content

SUV love killed America’s most ambitious efforts to boost fuel economy

Gas pump
Image used with permission by copyright holder
It’s still not clear who killed the electric car, but it’s apparent who did in the efficient one: We did.

In 2012, the Obama administration unveiled new Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards that required carmakers to achieve a fleet average of 54.5 mpg by 2025. The target, which is actually closer to 40 mpg in terms of the figures consumers see on window stickers, was the most ambitious of its type ever enacted in the U.S.

But now the regulatory agencies overseeing CAFE are backtracking. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), and California Air Resources Board (CARB) now say the 54.5-mpg standard is off the table, according to Automotive News (subscription required).

The decision came as part of a scheduled assessment of carmakers’ progress toward improving fuel economy. And here’s the zinger: CAFE standards must be reassessed not because carmakers aren’t improving efficiency, but because consumers don’t want to buy efficient cars, regulators said.

The auto industry is “adopting fuel economy technologies at an unprecedented rate,” the agencies said in a statement. They also said carmakers have been able to meet current regulations at the same cost or less than predicted in 2012, and will be able to meet upcoming standards with improvements to gasoline engines, rather than heavier reliance on hybrids and electric cars.

What regulators didn’t account for was Americans’ insatiable demand for SUVs and pickup trucks. Low gas prices have led to a boom in SUV sales, while sales of more efficient models have remained stagnant. Most of those SUVs get better fuel economy than the gas guzzlers of a decade ago, but they still drag down fleet averages, because those averages are sales weighted.

Officials now say the 54.5-mpg target was never a mandate, but rather an estimate of where the industry could be in 2025. That estimate was based on the assumption that 67 percent of the market would be cars and 33 percent would be SUVs, pickups, and other light trucks. New estimates assume a more even split between car and truck sales.

Accounting for greater SUV sales, regulators believe average fuel economy will hit 50 to 52.6 mpg by 2025. The change likely has carmakers popping champagne, but environmental groups probably won’t be happy. The EPA will make a final decision on adjusting fuel-economy targets for model years 2022 to 2025 by April 1, 2018.

Editors' Recommendations

Stephen Edelstein
Stephen is a freelance automotive journalist covering all things cars. He likes anything with four wheels, from classic cars…
Rivian R2 vs R1S: How will Rivian’s cheaper SUV compare?
The front three-quarter view of a 2022 Rivian against a rocky backdrop.

Rivian has finally unveiled the R2, its long-awaited attempt at a more affordable electric SUV. The new vehicle may not be available just yet, but fans of Rivian's design aesthetics and feature set are already looking forward to being able to order the new car. The R2 is targeted at being a more affordable take on the electric SUV and will sit alongside the flagship-tier R1S.

Let's get this out of the way right now: The R1S is most likely going to be a better vehicle than the R2. Rivian isn't replacing the R1S with the R2 — it's releasing the R2 as a more affordable alternative, and there will be some compromises when buying the R2 over the R1S.

Read more
Cybertruck production reportedly halted over pedal issue
Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck. Tesla

Tesla’s Cybertruck has been hit by a production delay caused by an issue with a part of the vehicle, a number of media reports have claimed.

Read more
Don’t let the gimmicks fool you. The Ioniq 5 N is a serious track car
2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N drifting.

We’re finally getting to the fun part of automakers’ methodical quest to replicate their lineups with electric cars.

Performance versions of ordinary cars have been a staple of the auto industry for decades. But while we’ve already seen some variants of EVs boasting more power and more impressive stats — think Tesla Model S Plaid or Lucid Air Sapphire — the 2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N is the first to truly apply that format to an EV.

Read more