Oracle wins bid to depose Google CEO Larry Page

By Geoff Duncan July 22, 2011

Larry Page — Image used with permission by copyright holder

A federal judge has ruled that Oracle may depose current Google CEO Larry Page in Oracle’s lawsuit over Java technology in Android—but only for two hours, and only in matters relevant to the allegation of copyright infringement and Android’s overall value to Google. The move is another way for Oracle to increase pressure on Google in what’s turning into a high-stakes case: Oracle has said it believes it’s owed at least $2.6 billion over infringement in Android.

The approval to depose Page was first reported by FOSS Patents.

Oracle says deposing Page is important to their case, since—before stepping into the CEO role at Google—Page headed up negotiations between Google and Sun to use Java technology in Android. Oracle also says Page may have been responsible for Google’s acquisition of Android, and likely played a role in Google’s decision not to license Java from Sun but instead to run with the alternative Dalvik engine for handling Java.

Google characterized Oracle’s request to depose Page as simple harassment.

Although Google’s Android operating system is touted as being “free,” the mobile operating system faces a number of patent challenges, often by proxy: Apple is suing Taiwanese phone maker FTC, alleging its Android devices violate Apple patents. Apple recently won a victory in the case; if Apple is able to win the case or wrest a settlement from HTC, it will be in a powerful position to assert patent infringement claims against other Android device makers. Similarly, Microsoft has eagerly been locking up patent licensing agreements with Android device makers, offering to exempt them from any litigation if it decided to launch infringement claims against Android: Microsoft reportedly wants $15 for every Android device Samsung sells.

Oracle alleges the Dalvik engine used in Android violates Java copyrights, and that Google even directly copied Java source code into Android. Oracle acquired Java when it took over Sun Microsystems in 2010.

Google denies any wrongdoing.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Mobile

How to transfer photos from an iPhone to a computer

The Apple iPhone 15 Plus's gallery app.

As the old saying goes, the best camera is the one you always have with you. If you're like most iPhone users, that means you've likely amassed a sizeable collection of photos on your device. However, while Apple's Photos app is a great way to manage and view your photo library, it's never a good idea to keep all your eggs in one basket. After all, suffering a lost or broken iPhone is painful enough without also losing all your precious digital memories in the process.

Even if you're backing up your iPhone to iCloud or your computer, it's a good idea to keep your photos backed up separately. After all, opening a folder or a photo management app is a much easier way to get at your photos than trying to extract them from an iCloud or iTunes/Finder backup, which requires either restoring them to another iPhone or relying on special software tools.

Mobile

Google Pixel 7a just dropped to its cheapest ever price

The Google Pixel 7a face down on a table.

Woot is just full of great phone deals with 32% off the Google Pixel 7a bringing it down to $340 from $499. As well as that, you can also buy the for $260 instead of $349 if you want to keep costs even lower. The Google Pixel 7a is the better phone so keep reading while we take you through everything it has to offer.

Why you should buy the Google Pixel 7a
The Google Pixel 7a is a huge upgrade from its predecessor (also on sale) with its significant flaw of being expensive instantly no longer an issue now that it’s on sale. The Google Pixel 7a has a 6.1-inch full HD OLED display with a 1080 x 2400 resolution along with a 20:9 aspect ratio. It has Corning Gorilla Glass 3 for durability while there’s a 90Hz adaptive refresh rate known as Smooth Display, which means you get smoother scrolling, animations, and generally a better experience.

Mobile

I spent four days with the AI gadget of the future, and it was a mess

Someone holding the Rabbit R1 with its screen turned on.

This past January, a company called Rabbit took CES 2024 by storm. Rabbit used CES to announce its new gadget — the Rabbit R1 — and it was immediately captivating. With a retro design, bright orange paint job, and adorable rabbit logo, it was hard not to get excited about the R1 ... even if it wasn't immediately clear what it was supposed to do.

I've now spent the past four days living with the Rabbit R1. While I love its design, unapologetically orange color, and the bouncing rabbit on its display, almost everything else about the R1 has been, to put it nicely, a mess.
What the Rabbit R1 is supposed to do