Apple fined $670,000 in Taiwan for interfering with iPhone pricing

By Trevor Mogg December 26, 2013

white iphone rumors version 1478513320 5s apps — Image used with permission by copyright holder

Apple has been slapped with a sizable NT$20 million (US$670,000) fine by Taiwan’s Fair Trade Commission (FTC) for interfering with pricing procedures carried out by mobile service providers and mobile phone distributors, the Wall Street Journal reported.

The fine, which was handed down Wednesday, came after it was found the tech giant had been instructing Taiwan’s top three mobile providers on how to price the iPhone, behavior that violated a section of Taiwan’s Fair Trade Act.

The FTC said that Apple “has no right to meddle in companies’ iPhone pricing plans after selling them distribution rights”, the Journal reported, adding that they have the right to resell or distribute the Cupertino company’s handsets in any manner they wish having paid out for those rights.

The commission said that after examining email correspondence between the iPhone maker and the Taiwanese mobile companies, “we discovered the companies submit their pricing plans to Apple to be approved or confirmed before the products hit the market.” The ruling doesn’t apply to other Apple products, such as the iPad.

Selling the iPhone and other products at premium prices is part of Apple’s strategy to portray itself an aspirational brand, which is likely why it was reluctant to see the Taiwanese mobile providers possibly enter into a price war with its handset.

In October, Taiwan’s FTC also punished Apple’s Korean rival Samsung after it was discovered the company had been paying students to post negative comments in local forums about devices made by Taiwanese tech firm HTC. Despite Samsung’s Taiwan base promising to adopt a marketing strategy that fell in line with Samsung’s philosophy of “transparent and honest communications with consumers,” the FTC fined the company NT$10 million ($335,000).

As for Apple’s fine, the FTC said the tech giant can appeal if it wishes, though failure to comply with Wednesday’s ruling could result in an even larger fine of up to NT$50 million ($1.7 million).

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Contributing Editor

Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…

Mobile

Best refurbished iPhone deals: Get an iPhone 14 for $513

An iPhone 13 in white color option.

The Apple iPhone is one of the best phones on the market, and because of it they don’t often come cheap. There are some great iPhone deals out there, but it’s rare to find significant discounts on newer models without having to commit to a longterm contract with a carrier, and it’s even less frequent you come across one of the best iPhones with a major price drop. This is where shopping refurbished can come in handy. Refurbished iPhones — for the most part — will come backed with a functionality guarantee or extended return window, making refurbished iPhones as safe of a purchase as shopping new. There are a lot of refurbished iPhone models seeing great price drops right now, which is why we’ve done the heavy lifting of rounding up all of the best refurbished iPhone deals. You’ll find them below, as well as some information on which refurbished iPhone might be best for you.
iPhone XR -- from $136

A refurbished model but one that's unlocked and comes with a full one-year warranty, the Apple iPhone XR is still pretty stylish for its age. It has a large 6.1-inch LCD screen with 1,792 x 828 resolution with Liquid Retina technology ensuring it looks super sharp. Powered by the A12 Bionic chip, it's starting to show its age but still has potential. There's also a 12MP back camera that can shoot 4K videos while the front-facing camera is 7MP and ideal for selfie-taking.

Mobile

Nomad’s new iPhone case and Apple Watch band may be its coolest yet

Nomad Glow 2.0 Sport Case and Apple Watch Sport Band in daylight.

Though the world of Apple accessories is a dime a dozen, one of the better brands that you can buy is Nomad. Nomad has a variety of amazing leather Apple Watch bands and cases, as well as non-leather options, too. In August 2023, Nomad released a one-of-a-kind Glow in the Dark Apple Watch band that sold out in about 12 hours.

Since that Glow in the Dark band was a limited edition, no one was sure if Nomad was going to re-release it, and this explains the high resale prices you’ll find on eBay. But Nomad just released the Glow 2.0 Apple Watch Sport Band as well as a new Glow 2.0 Sport Case for the iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max. And, yes, they're just as wonderful as before.
The new and improved Glow 2.0

Mobile

An Apple insider just revealed how iOS 18’s AI features will work

An iPhone 15 Pro Max laying face-down outside, showing the Natural Titanium color.

As Apple’s Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) inches closer, the chatter around the company’s AI work has taken a feverish turn. In a year when smartphone and computing brands have focused solely on AI niceties, Apple has been uncharacteristically silent around the AI hype — eliciting concern about the brand missing the train.

However, a new report has given us a closer look at how Apple's AI dreams may come to fruition with its iOS 18 update later this year.
New details on Apple's AI plans