Skip to main content

Band of Brothers: May and Hammond not coming back to Top Gear without Clarkson

James May: Man Lab BBC America
BBC America
If anyone with their head buried in the sand needed further proof that Top Gear as we know it is gone, a few more show critical members of the team have officially jumped ship.

Front and center of it was co-presenter James May telling The Guardian in no uncertain terms that he wouldn’t return to the show without his comrades in cars.

“Me and Hammond with a surrogate Jeremy is a non-starter, it just wouldn’t work. That would be lame,” May said. “It has to be the three of us. You can’t just put a surrogate Jeremy in and expect it to carry on. It would be forced.”

James May Top Gear
Image used with permission by copyright holder

May is of course referring to the incident in which the Top Gear frontman verbally and physically assaulted a producer on the show, after which the BBC decided not to renew his contract. May and the show’s other co-presenter, Richard Hammond, consequently allowed their contracts to run out without further renewal.

Therein lies a key factor that May points out people have overlooked: He technically wasn’t fired.

“The BBC haven’t completely closed the door on Jeremy’s return. They’ve not banned him or fired him, only just not renewed his contract for the moment. It’s a subtle difference but an important one,” May explains. This nugget may leave fans hopeful that the trio will somehow come back, and May doesn’t rule this out. “In the future, when all this has blown over, there might be an opportunity for three of us to get back together on the BBC to do Top Gear or a car show of some sort.”

As for Hammond, his only statement on the matter has been on twitter, addressing the same technicality that “There’s nothing for [him] to ‘quit.’ ” He then reaffirms his commitment to the trio, albeit all in a very nebulous 140 characters.

The biggest death knell blown to the existing format of Top Gear is that the show’s long time Executive Producer, Andy Wilman, announced his departure from the show. Wilman had very much been the unseen fourth member (or fifth member, if the Stig counts), largely contributing to the personality the show had been imbued with.

Screen Shot 2015-04-24 at 11.48.58 AM
Image used with permission by copyright holder

He was the one Clarkson tasked in revitalizing the show after its previous incarnation ran its course, subsequently building the successful program into what it is (was) today. Wilman previously denied he was leaving the show as a response to a “goodbye email” he had sent to the show’s crew.

“… In 2002, the brief was to reinvigorate a car show and get an audience of three million. What you all ended up making was one of the most iconic programmes in TV history, a show about cars that went global, won countless awards, was devoured by non car fans and ended up in the Guinness Book of Records,” Wilman said in the email.

What Wilman plans to do next is unknown. Same goes for the presenting trio, but it looks like whatever happens, the three of them are sticking together.

Editors' Recommendations

Alexander Kalogianni
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Alex K is an automotive writer based in New York. When not at his keyboard or behind the wheel of a car, Alex spends a lot of…
Rivian R2 vs R1S: How will Rivian’s cheaper SUV compare?
The front three-quarter view of a 2022 Rivian against a rocky backdrop.

Rivian has finally unveiled the R2, its long-awaited attempt at a more affordable electric SUV. The new vehicle may not be available just yet, but fans of Rivian's design aesthetics and feature set are already looking forward to being able to order the new car. The R2 is targeted at being a more affordable take on the electric SUV and will sit alongside the flagship-tier R1S.

Let's get this out of the way right now: The R1S is most likely going to be a better vehicle than the R2. Rivian isn't replacing the R1S with the R2 — it's releasing the R2 as a more affordable alternative, and there will be some compromises when buying the R2 over the R1S.

Read more
Cybertruck production reportedly halted over pedal issue
Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck. Tesla

Tesla’s Cybertruck has been hit by a production delay caused by an issue with a part of the vehicle, a number of media reports have claimed.

Read more
Don’t let the gimmicks fool you. The Ioniq 5 N is a serious track car
2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N drifting.

We’re finally getting to the fun part of automakers’ methodical quest to replicate their lineups with electric cars.

Performance versions of ordinary cars have been a staple of the auto industry for decades. But while we’ve already seen some variants of EVs boasting more power and more impressive stats — think Tesla Model S Plaid or Lucid Air Sapphire — the 2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N is the first to truly apply that format to an EV.

Read more