Samsung’s case for a mistrial in the Apple lawsuit emerges as jury foreman’s patent history revealed


New details have emerged about Samsung’s claims of juror misconduct in the recent trial with Apple. It seems that the jury foreman, Velvin Hogan, failed to disclose a lawsuit and a personal bankruptcy when he was questioned during jury selection. The experienced electrical engineer spoke about a trial with a former employee of his over software ownership and he mentioned a patent he holds related to “video compression software”. What he didn’t mention was being sued by former employer, Seagate Technology Inc. and filing for bankruptcy in 1993.

Seagate and Samsung have a “strategic alignment” that means Seagate drives are used in Samsung laptops and Samsung semi-conductors go into Seagate SSDs. As part of the deal, Samsung actually sold its HDD business to Seagate in 2011. Samsung said in its filing, “Mr. Hogan’s failure to disclose the Seagate suit raises issues of bias that Samsung should have been allowed to explore in questioning.”

According to Bloomberg, Hogan explained in a phone interview yesterday that there was no misconduct. He says jurors were instructed to disclose litigation from the last ten years and the Seagate case and bankruptcy were outside that time limit. There isn’t actually any mention of a ten year limit in the transcript. Hogan also pointed out that one of Samsung’s lawyers is married to the lawyer who filed against him at Seagate, so how could Samsung not have known about this? Hogan wonders if Samsung “let me in the jury just to have an excuse for a new trial if it didn’t go in their favor.”

We asked Stanley M. Gibson, an experienced technology and IP trial lawyer at Jeffer, Mangels, Butler & Mitchell, about this action by Samsung and he told us, “these are always difficult issues to win and expect the Court to want to understand when Samsung had this information. If it was before the trial was over, why did they wait?” He also suggested it will be interesting to see, “whether Judge Koh will hear this issue earlier than December since it involves a private citizen who served on the jury and the press coverage is, obviously, intense. Deciding the issue sooner, would put an end to it.”

It’s no surprise that Samsung is determined to challenge the verdict which resulted in a $1.05 billion verdict for Apple. We reported on developments between the two electronics giants since the California jury returned a victorious verdict for Apple. While the Cupertino company seeks more damages and sales bans, Samsung has been pushing for a mistrial. We also saw Samsung add the iPhone 5 to another patent infringement suit it is bringing against Apple. That one concerns infringement of eight patents and Samsung is pushing for sales bans on several Apple devices.

The patent war rages on.


Here’s how you can watch today’s Nvidia GTC 2019 keynote live

Nvidia's rumored 7nm Ampere graphics could debut soon. The company will be kicking off its GPU Technology conference at 2 p.m. PT today, Monday, March 18, and you can watch the opening keynote here.

5G's arrival is transforming tech. Here's everything you need to know to keep up

It has been years in the making, but 5G is finally becoming a reality. While 5G coverage is still extremely limited, expect to see it expand in 2019. Not sure what 5G even is? Here's everything you need to know.
Home Theater

Here’s what’s new on HBO and what’s leaving in April 2019

Whether you're a cable lifer or a staunch cord cutter, there's never been a better time to get down with premium TV. April 2019 brings Game of Thrones season 8, BlacKkKlansman, and Crazy Rich Asians to HBO.

Google hit with another fine by the EU, this time for $1.7 billion

Google has been fined for the third time by the EU, this time for breaching antitrust laws by requiring third-party websites using its search function to prioritize its ads over competitors.

You can now use the innovative Red Hydrogen One on Google Fi

The Red Hydrogen One was first announced in 2017 and has been delayed a few times since then. Now, the Red Hydrogen One is finally available, featuring a Qualcomm Snapdragon 835, 6GB of RAM, and 128GB of storage.

The best Apple AirPods alternatives for Android, Windows, and iOS devices

Apple AirPods might be new and improved, but they aren't the only game in town. Other makers are offering their own truly wireless earbuds, with attractive features. These are the best AirPod alternatives on the market today.
Social Media

Facebook Messenger adds quoted replies to better organize group chats

Facebook is rolling out a feature that should help make group chats a whole lot more organized. The feature allows you to reply to specific messages within a group chat, so others will be able to tell what you're replying to.

Browse safely and securely with Opera’s unlimited VPN on Android

Opera has added a new VPN to its Android browser, offering an easy way to keep your privacy and data locked up solid, and with no limits on usage or cost, you can keep it on all the time.

Need a quick battery boost? Try one of our favorite portable chargers

Battery life still tops the polls when it comes to smartphone concerns. If it’s bugging you, then maybe it’s time to snag yourself a portable charger. Here are our picks for the best portable chargers.

The Samsung Galaxy S10 5G might be a few short weeks away from launch

Samsung has announced a whopping four new Galaxy S10 devices, from the low-cost S10e to the triple-camera S10 and S10 Plus. But it's the Galaxy S10 5G that steals the show as it's among the first 5G-ready smartphones to hit the market.

Fossil made a smartwatch in 2004, and it’s part of a new brand retrospective

Fossil has been making watches for 35 years, and to celebrate the anniversary, it has a new retrospective exhibit complete with the first smartwatch it made — the Wrist Net watch from 2004.

Fossil is working on a smartwatch with BMW, and it’s coming next year

Fossil, the watch company that makes smartwatches under its own name and partners with other major brands too, intends to launch a smartwatch with car manufacturer BMW in the future.

Diesel’s denim-inspired smartwatch straps are a casual, colorful must-own

Diesel will release two new versions of the On Full Guard 2.5 smartwatch later this year, with seriously cool, denim-inspired straps in classic Diesel colors. We tried them on at the Baselworld 2019 show.

The Moto G7 Power, with its massive battery, is now available for purchase

After a number of leaks and rumors, the Motorola Moto G7, Moto G7 Play, and Moto G7 Power are finally here. The devices represent quite a spec bump over the previous-generation Moto G6 phones, yet still come at a reasonable price.