Smart travelers don’t need smart luggage yet, but we haven’t lost hope

airport smart luggage pickup
If you peruse our list of smart luggage, you’ll find plenty of options, from rolling trunks with built-in scales to bags that beep when you get too far from them — and that’s only just a handful of what’s available. We often receive notices of new models coming out, whether it’s from a renowned manufacturer or a startup looking for crowdsource funding. There’s also no sign of this trend stopping: The travel luggage industry is a big business, and according to one forecast, sales of smart bags will reach nearly $2.4 billion by 2022. In New York City, ads for the Away bag are plastered inside entire subway cars – when was the last time you saw ads for luggage?

But, what is smart luggage? It’s a label that’s applied broadly to any bags that incorporate technologies such as hot spots, battery chargers, tracking devices, digital scales, and companion mobile apps, as well as features designed to alleviate the stress from traveling, like built-in organizers, collapsible constructions, and even — we kid you not — a motorized scooter.

Are these travel accessories truly the next-generation of travel, or a marketing exercise in developing solutions for a non-existent problem? Samsonite’s CEO, Ramesh Tainwala, told CNN that smart luggage is gimmicky and does not deliver value to consumers – never mind that Samsonite is one of several big companies to enter the business, as well as Delsey, Rimowa, and Travelpro (he probably wasn’t talking about his company’s products). Whatever the opinion, the smart luggage is here to stay. Whether you want one, is another question.

To find out, we brought a smart bag along on a recent one-week trip to see if it would really ease travel, or just get in the way.

It’s not techie, but it’s smart

San Francisco-based smart luggage maker  Barracuda provided us with its carry-on bag for a weeklong trip we took on Viking River Cruises. We like to travel light, and compact luggage makes it easy to bring onboard. The Barracuda received critical praise, and coming in a variety of colors, it helps to stand out from the ho-hum black (although black is available).

The collapsible system is the Barracuda’s most attractive feature.

Like most smart luggage, the Barracuda comes with a location tracker, USB charger, and digital scale. Anyone who flies has most likely exceeded the weight limit on a checked bag, had the airline lose it, or struggled to find an outlet for charging. Barracuda’s tech is supposed to address those problems.

As it turned out, we didn’t really encounter them. Since the bag was small enough to carry aboard, we didn’t check it, and had no use for the digital scale or location tracker. Even if we had, the small size would have made it challenging to fill with anything heavy enough to require a scale. And the tracker only works when you’re in proximity of the bag; so if it had gone missing, the tracker, which works over Bluetooth via the Barracuda app, would be useless. The battery was handy, but it’s a generic 10,000mAh unit that’s large and heavy – you can buy a comparable model on Amazon for $25.

But we appreciated Barracuda’s bag for reasons that had nothing to do with tech. For instance, it’s designed to be collapsible. Detach a few interior clips, and the Barracuda folds down to fit inside a closet or under the bed — great for storage when not in use, whether at home or in the cozy cabin of the Viking longship. Luggage tends to take up space, especially in a small hotel room or tiny apartment, so this simple yet ingenious system is nice.

The luggage also contains a laptop tray that’s built into the handle. While we didn’t need it, it’s a nice benefit if you need a surface to work or eat lunch.

Barracuda suitcase coffee table

With a fabric construction, the Barracuda is lightweight (when not in use, it can hang on a closet rod), but not as durable as we would have liked. The zipper jammed so badly when we closed the bag, that we were afraid we would rip the thing apart if we applied too much pressure. It’s not expandable, so it wasn’t as forgiving as our non-smart Samsonite. And the fixed wheels don’t allow for easy turning in tight spots.

Despite the battle scars, the Barracuda held up well before, during, and after the trip.  However, at $350 ($400 if you want the location tracker), the “smarts” don’t justify the price. If you don’t need the features, you can purchase larger, more durable luggage for less money. The collapsible system is the Barracuda’s most attractive feature, but you can also get large duffel bags that easily fold away.

So what’s the point?

Smart luggage came about as a way to deal with the headaches associated with air travel. When Bluesmart launched on Indiegogo in 2014, it jumpstarted the smart-luggage industry with innovative features like a USB charger battery, smooth traveling wheels, digital scale, remote lock, and location tracker. “After decades of no innovation in the luggage industry, we re-imagined the suitcase to solve the problems of the modern traveler,” Bluesmart’s Indiegogo campaign page proclaimed. Having raised more than $2 million on Indiegogo from nearly 11,000 backers, it seems a lot of people agreed.

Unlike a Bluetooth tracker, the 3G-based tracking system can help locate bags almost anywhere.

Since then, air travel has experienced developments that negate the need for some of the features. Free Wi-Fi and power outlets are becoming more common at airports, allowing you stay connected longer. Airlines are also losing fewer bags: According to a report from SITA, the company that provides IT services to the air travel industry, mishandled bags dropped 70 percent over the past 10 years.

The Bluesmart also had its own shortcomings. It’s only available in a small carry-on size, which means you’d still need bigger luggage for longer trips. The USB port is blocked by the handle, making it less efficient. Because you have to register the bag to use the remote lock, it’s restricted to one user – you have to get in touch with customer service to switch users, which we found annoying.

This isn’t lost on bag makers. Bluesmart is already making its second-generation luggage – this time, a full smart series that includes a 29-inch check-in luggage, laptop bag, and passport pouch. It addresses the other limitations: It has a fast-charging battery that powers even laptops; a scale that’s synced to various airlines’ guidelines; stronger build quality; and other tech upgrades. Hopefully, it has also fixed the wiring problem that had The Next Web’s reviewer held up in airport security like a potential terrorist.

do you really need smart luggage bluesmart phone

Perhaps more useful is the Bluesmart Series 2’s GPS and 3G-based tracking system. Unlike a Bluetooth tracker, this system can help locate bags almost anywhere. Considering that bags are more likely to go missing during connections, according to SITA, you have a better chance of locating a bag with GPS and cellular than you would with Bluetooth, which is ineffective beyond 30 feet.

Build your own smart bag

Many of the most useful tech elements in these bags can be added to existing luggage using third-party accessories. You can purchase tracking devices, digital scales, power banks, and even laptop stands, mini hot spots, and servers. These features aren’t unique, and you already own some of the gadgets you need to add them.

If you want a smart bag right now, we recommend purchasing high-quality luggage, and then adding these smart features separately, rather than paying a high price for something that might be too limiting.

Not all smart luggage is dumb

While we equip ourselves with more tech than most travelers (one person couldn’t help comment on the multiple phones and tablets we had on our flight to Europe for the Viking cruise), we can say that you don’t need to invest in smart luggage right now.

That’s doesn’t mean we won’t ever need it. Once the industry moves beyond its first attempts, we will start to see products that make more sense. We want to see better apps and unique technologies, like the Electronic Tag that Rimowa launched with Lufthansa, EVA Air, and Swiss, which provides updated info that a paper tag can’t. How about luggage that acts as a server and streams movies to our phones, or knows how to get to our destination if it misses the connection? (We’re still a little iffy on the scooter.)

Luggage doesn’t need to be smart today, but in the future, all luggage will be smart.

Features

Where Toronto sees smart sidewalks, residents see ‘1984.’ So what now?

Google-parent Alphabet is partnering with Toronto to develop a new, smart neighborhood, but some are concerned about privacy and the company’s motives. Could residents derail the project?
Deals

19 portable tech gadgets you’ll want to use every day

If you're looking for portable tech to keep you charged up while on the go (or for some great stocking stuffer ideas), we've rounded up 19 must-have gadgets. You'll find everything from a mini gaming controller to a folding Bluetooth…
Outdoors

Lime’s dockless electric bikes land in London, but its scooters aren’t allowed

Lime has landed in London with its dockless bikesharing service. The pedal-assisted electric bikes are unlocked via Lime's app and can reach speeds of 15 mph. It plans to have 1,000 bikes on the streets before the end of the year.
Deals

Save money and control your home’s temperature with these smart thermostat deals

With the winter season in full blast, there's no better time to save money with a smart home thermostat. We found the best deals available on smart home thermostats. Control your home's heating via smartphone or voice assistants.
Smart Home

Is old-school Airstream finally embracing smart home technology?

Airstream's vintage-looking trailers have a huge audience but its 2019 Classic camping trailers are getting a modern upgrade with the addition of app-controlled smart home technology to bring modern convenience online.
Home Theater

AT&T’s new three-tiered streaming service will include movies, possibly HBO

AT&T has laid out new details for its planned streaming service that's set to launch in 2019. It will include three different price tiers, and will feature movies, original programming, and content from its acquisition of Time Warner.
Social Media

Ride the rails and share your stories with Amtrak’s new social media residency

Amtrak is looking for travel fans with a knack for telling stories on social media. The new Amtrak social media residency program wants amateur travelers to share photos, video, and written content from aboard long-distance trips.
Computing

A second Wells Fargo glitch results in the foreclosure of more homes

A computer error has struck Wells Fargo once again, resulting in hundreds more homes being mistakenly foreclosed after a first glitch was reported in August. To compensate one customer, the bank sent a check for $25,000.
Mobile

Sprint confirms it will launch a 5G smartphone with Samsung in 2019

Like other carriers, Sprint is working hard on bringing the next generation of cellular connectivity to customers. In fact, the company has even announced that it's working with HTC and Qualcomm on a new 5G smart hub.
Mobile

Samsung partners with AT&T to create a multi-band 5G smartphone for late 2019

Ready to experience a radical transformation in mobile communication? AT&T is launching mobile 5G in cities across the country over the next few months. Here's everything you need to know about the AT&T 5G rollout.
Mobile

Qualcomm's 3D Sonic fingerprint sensor could make your next phone more secure

Almost exactly a year after the launch of the Snapdragon 845, Qualcomm took the wraps off of its next-generation mobile platform, the new Snapdragon 855. The new chip puts an emphasis on A.I. performance.
Movies & TV

Movies Anywhere service adds Comcast films to its library and devices

Movies Anywhere lets you watch movies purchased from different services all in one place, and it just got even better with the addition of Comcast, which joins Microsoft, Amazon, iTunes, Google Play, Vudu, and FandangoNow.
Web

Can Microsoft’s Airband Initiative close broadband gap for 25M Americans?

A new report from the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) says that 25 million Americans do not have access to broadband internet. Of these, more than 19 million are living in rural communities. Can Microsoft help out?
Business

Amazon scouted airport locations for its cashier-free Amazon Go stores

Representatives of Amazon Go checkout-free retail stores connected with officials at Los Angeles and San Jose airports in June to discuss the possibility of cashier-free grab-and-go locations in busy terminals.