Skip to main content

Don’t ditch gasoline just yet: BMW argues electric cars are overhyped

2018 BMW i3

BMW is spending millions of dollars developing electric cars that motorists don’t want to buy, according to the head of its research and development. The German company needs to add battery-powered cars to its portfolio to comply with the draconian emissions regulations coming into effect soon in the early 2020s in key markets, including Europe, but it doesn’t expect electric cars will outsell gasoline-powered models anytime soon.

“There is no customer request for battery-electric vehicles. There are regulator requests for battery-electric vehicles,” explained Klaus Frölich, the man who oversees BMW’s research efforts, in an interview with Australian website Motoring.

Frölich spoke from experience. BMW began experimenting with electric cars in the early 1970s, and its i3 (pictured) introduced in 2013 entered production well before many of its rivals jumped into the segment. It was developed as an electric car from the ground up, which makes it a better electric car than one converted from gasoline to kilowatts, but it hasn’t been the sales success many hoped it would be. Frölich argued electric cars are still too expensive to buy, and the cost of electricity remains relatively high in some European countries. In Munich, the company’s hometown, it’s cheaper to drive a car powered by a fuel-sipping, four-cylinder turbodiesel engine than to drive a comparable electric car.

He added the story is a little bit different in the United States, where the incentives awarded to motorists who buy an electric car tend to be higher, and consumers often have more than one car in their household. The idea of buying a car with a plug is much more attractive when motorists are eligible for a $7,500 tax credit, and living with it is easier when they can forget the phrase “range anxiety” behind the wheel of an SUV.

BMW will continue investing in electric technology, it recently showed a 720-horsepower electric test mule, but Frölich believes plug-in hybrid technology is the best compromise between range and emissions. His team plans to develop a gasoline-electric powertrain capable of running on electricity alone for 50 miles, and he argued the internal combustion engine (in both gasoline- and diesel-burning forms) still has several decades left to live. Even the mighty, turbocharged 4.4-liter V8 that powers its bigger cars will stick around for at least 15 more years.

“From what we see, battery-electric vehicles are good for China and California, and everywhere else is better off with plug-in hybrids that have a good electric range,” he summed up, later adding “the shift to electrification is overhyped.”

Editors' Recommendations

Ronan Glon
Ronan Glon is an American automotive and tech journalist based in southern France. As a long-time contributor to Digital…
How do electric cars work? EV motors and batteries explained
Electric GT e-Crate Motor Tesla battery

Electric vehicles function in fundamentally different ways than traditional cars. Internal combustion engines have loads of moving parts, and while EVs have their own complexities, they're much more digital than mechanical. Let's take a closer look at exactly how electric vehicles work.
How does an EV battery pack work?
Instead of gasoline, EVs derive their power from a battery pack, which usually stretches along the underside of the car to keep the weight as low as possible. It's composed of multiple modules, which are in turn broken down into individual battery cells, similar in size to AA batteries. A layer of coolant runs between cells since hot batteries are explodey batteries. A battery management system regulates that coolant and ensures that each cell drains at the same rate, which prolongs the life of the pack.


Read more
BMW shipping cars without advertised Apple and Google features
2014 BMW M235i back logo

The global chip shortage continues to cause problems for automakers, to the point where some are shipping vehicles without all of their advertised features.

BMW, for example, is shipping some of its new cars without support for Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, according to a recent report by Automotive News.

Read more
The all-electric BMW i7 is a home theater on wheels
Front three quarter view of the 2023 BMW i7.

BMW is no stranger to electric vehicles. It launched the quirky i3 hatchback in 2014, and followed it up more recently with the i4 and iX. But now BMW is making its flagship vehicle electric.

The BMW 7 Series is the automaker’s biggest, most opulent sedan, and for the 2023 model year, it gets a redesign that includes a first-ever electric variant. The 2023 BMW i7 xDrive60 (to use its full name) will start shipping to U.S. dealerships in November alongside gasoline 7 Series models (a hybrid version will arrive later as well).

Read more