Skip to main content

Tesla settles Autopilot class-action lawsuit with Model S, Model X owners

Tesla Model S and Model X buyers who brought a lawsuit against Telsa had their day in court — and it looks like they’ve won. On Thursday, Tesla agreed to settle with the buyers who said the optional Autopilot driver assistance system was “essentially unusable and demonstrably dangerous,” Reuters reported.

Relying on what they claimed was misrepresentation by the company, the buyers spent $5,000 for automated emergency braking, side collision warning, and the Autopilot software. In the lawsuit, the owners said the features were “completely inoperable.”

The settlement agreement refers to the time delay in activating the Autopilot features but does not address the issue of safety raised by the claimants.

In a company statement Tesla said, “Since rolling out our second generation of Autopilot hardware in October 2016, we have continued to provide software updates that have led to a major improvement in Autopilot functionality.” Tesla said it would compensate “all customers globally in the same way,” even though only U.S. customers brought the lawsuit.

The winners won’t get much in financial compensation if the settlement is accepted. According to Reuters, customers in the suit who paid for the Autopilot upgrade during 2016 and 2017 will receive from $20 to $280. Telsa will put $5 million-plus in a fund to compensate the buyers and pay lawyers’ fees.

The customer lawsuit was the “only known court challenge” of Tesla’s Autopilot driver assistance suite, the article notes.

The settlement offer is not the final word on the case, however. Filed late Thursday in San Jose federal court, the settlement must be approved by U.S. District Court Judge Beth Labson Freeman.

The lawsuit was filed in San Jose, California in 2017 by six Tesla Model S and Model X owners from California, Colorado, Florida, and New Jersey. In filing as a class action, the Tesla buyers wanted to represent a class consisting of all buyers in the United States.

Tesla and its CEO Elon Musk have said Autopilot use results in 40 percent fewer crashes than humans driving without the driver-assistance system.

There have been only a few fatalities involving Teslas or other cars using self-driving technology, but those that have occurred have drawn scrutiny. Consumers and regulators question whether the technologies are sufficiently advanced at this time for use — or even testing on public roads.

Drivers in some cases have demonstrated too much reliance on the emerging technology, despite warnings from manufacturers that they should to pay attention and keep their hands on the steering wheel to take over when needed.

Editors' Recommendations

Bruce Brown
Digital Trends Contributing Editor Bruce Brown is a member of the Smart Homes and Commerce teams. Bruce uses smart devices…
A gaming Tesla? New Model S to use same GPU as PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X
Displays in a Tesla Model S.

Tesla's newly redesigned Model S sedan for 2021 could be the perfect road trip companion. Alongside a top cruising speed of 200 miles per hour, you're also getting the power of Sony's PlayStation 5 inside your ride to keep you entertained for the entire journey.

In its press announcement in late January, Tesla didn't reveal which processor or GPU will be powering its 2021 Model S, but we are now learning that the rig could be powered by the same AMD graphics architecture found across game consoles and PCs. A leaked schematic posted by Patrick Schur revealed Tesla could be using AMD's Navi 23 graphics processor inside the new Model S, which would mean that the car would share the same RDNA 2 architecture as some popular gaming systems.

Read more
Tesla gives the Model S over 1,000 hp and a spaceship-like steering wheel
2021 Tesla Model S

Released in 2012, the Model S is the oldest member of the Tesla range. It's about to look a lot newer than its age suggests thanks to a much-needed update that brings a fully redesigned interior and a lot more power.

Not much has changed on the outside, and the sedan remains recognizable as a Model S. Look closely and you might notice stylists gave it a nip-and-tuck that brings a redesigned front bumper, small aerodynamic tweaks out back, and new wheels. Visually, it takes a well-trained eye to tell the latest evolution of the S apart from its predecessor.

Read more
What is Tesla Autopilot and how does it work?
A Tesla Model 3 electric car.

Don't let the name Autopilot fool you: None of the cars in Tesla's current range are capable of driving themselves. Instead, Autopilot is a partially automated system that is regularly improved via over-the-air software updates. It relies on eight surround-view cameras that give the car 360-degree visibility for up to 820 feet, 12 ultrasonic sensors, and a forward-facing radar. Tesla has regularly stressed that, unlike its rivals, it doesn't believe in lidar technology.

The data gathered by Autopilot's hardware allows the car to steer, accelerate, and brake automatically within its lane, commonly called adaptive cruise control, though the company warns the system requires active driver supervision. In other words, even if your Model S can steer itself around a bend, you shouldn't be watching a movie while you cruise down I-80 at 75 mph. There are many circumstances Autopilot can't handle on its own, and the driver could be asked to take over without notice.

Read more