Tesla Model S vs. Tesla Model 3 — Which comes out on top?

Tesla Model 3
Tesla Model 3
One of the Model 3’s main rivals is Tesla’s very own Model S. It’s bigger all around, more refined, and more expensive, but a high-end Model 3 falls in the same price bracket as a lightly used Model S. Tesla is well aware of this, so company boss Elon Musk has been trying to anti-sell the car in order to steer buyers toward a Model S.

If you’re not sure whether to get a Tesla Model 3 or a Model S, read on to find out how they’re alike and how they’re different.

Tech features

Tech is one of Tesla’s most important selling points, and neither model disappoints. Both cars can be configured with the brand’s Autopilot suite of electronic driving aids. It keeps the car in its lane, automatically changes lanes, navigates freeway on- and off-ramps, and even parks the car on its own. It’s available as an extra-cost option on the 3 and the S. The Tesla sedans also benefit from an over-the-air software updating system, navigation, and keyless entry, among other features.

Performance and range

The most basic version of the rear-wheel drive Model 3 (the one which corresponds to the often-advertised $35,000 base price) offers 220 miles of range from a 50-kilowatt-hour battery pack. It performs the benchmark 0-to-60-mph sprint in 5.6 seconds, and it goes up to a top speed of 130 mph if you give it enough tarmac. Don’t look for horsepower and torque figures; Tesla won’t release them for the time being. The company argues range is a much more important statistic.

You can get a 70-kWh battery pack and quicker charging if you’ve got an extra $9,000 in your pocket. Range goes up to a more usable 310-mile range, though the 3’s base price also goes up to true luxury car territory – and within a stone’s throw of a used Model S. The bigger battery pack reduces the 3’s 0-to-60-mph time to 5.1 seconds.

Performance and range for the Model S is all over the board. The most basic model is called 75D. Its 75-kWh battery pack provides 259 miles of range, and it helps propel the car from 0 to 60 mph in a brisk 4.2 seconds. Top speed is reached at 140 mph, though it’s a figure very few owners will ever see.

Tesla Model S P100d
Tesla Model S P100D

The next model up in the Model S hierarchy is called 100D. Built around a 100-kWh battery pack, it sees its range bumped up to 335 miles and its top speed bumped to 155 mph. It’s a tenth of a second quicker to 60 mph. Finally, the P100D is a high-performance version of the 100D. Range goes down to 315 miles, but it posts a jaw-dropping 0-to-60-mph time of 2.5 seconds. That’s about on par with the Bugatti Chiron, and it can fit the entire family plus gear.

Production of the all-wheel drive Model 3 hasn’t started yet, so it’s rear-wheel drive-only for the time being. Every Model S is equipped with Tesla’s dual-motor all-wheel drive.

All Tesla owners can take advantage of the company’s ever-growing network of Supercharger stations. Filling up the battery is free for Model S (and Model X) owners, but Model 3 owners will need to pay every time they plug in. Rates haven’t been announced yet.

Interior and exterior design

The Model 3 takes interior design to the next level. Its most striking visual aspect is the dashboard, which is dominated by a horizontal screen you’d expect to find in the television aisle at Best Buy. It replaces nearly every single button, switch, and gauge normally scattered across the cockpit. It’s a unique solution that makes the Model 3 considerably easier to build. It’s worth noting every part of the 3’s interior was designed in-house by Tesla.

The Model S is futuristic, but it looks a lot more conventional inside than its smaller sibling. For starters, components like the massive vertical touch screen, the instrument cluster, and the air vents are exactly where you expect them to be. But since the Model S was Tesla’s first mass-produced car, the company sourced components from other manufacturers when possible. You’ll immediately recognize the switchgear if you’ve ever driven a late-model Mercedes-Benz.

Tesla thankfully avoided the Russian doll approach to design its German rivals are stuck in. Its sedans share a handful of defining styling cues, like a grille-less front end and a fastback-like roof line, but one isn’t a Xerox copy of the other.

The Model S is unquestionably the better option if you routinely haul around people or gear. It offers space for five adults plus two jump seats suitable for small children, and up to 30 cubic feet of trunk space. Note the jump seats and the trunk space are mutually exclusive. The most you’ll fit in the Model 3 are five adults and 15 cubes of your stuff.

Pricing and availability

The base Tesla Model 3 starts at $35,000 before incentives, which sounds attractive until you look precisely up how to get your hands on one. Waiting times are excruciatingly long. Tesla estimates customers who recently placed an order likely won’t get their car until halfway through next year at the earliest.

The cheapest Model S currently available on the Tesla website is a 60-kWh model priced at $45,000. The company’s inventory of used cars includes every variant of the S released over the past couple of years, and the selection changes on a regular basis. All of them come with free Supercharging, and they’re available right now. You could be driving one a week from today.

If you’re looking to shop new, the cheapest Model S is the all-wheel drive 75D, which starts at $74,500. The midrange 100D is priced at $99,000, while the P100D flagship — which is one of the quickest cars on the planet — carries a base price of $135,000. Customers should expect to wait between 30 and 60 days before receiving a new, custom-ordered Model S.

Cars

Honda will squeeze another model into its SUV lineup at the Los Angeles show

Honda will introduce a new SUV with a familiar nameplate at the 2018 Los Angeles auto show. It envisioned the 2019 Passport as a five-seater alternative to the eight-seater Pilot. The two models will share a platform and many tech features.
Cars

BMW’s 2020 M340i will show off mix of tech and luxury at the Los Angeles show

The 2020 3 Series represents the seventh generation of BMW's bread-and-butter luxury sedan. Where previous generations emphasized the driving experience, the 2020 3 Series focuses more on tech than ever before.
Cars

Jaguar’s rally-ready F-Type roadster is happiest off the pavement

Jaguar is celebrating the XK120's 70th birthday by turning the F-Type roadster into a rally warrior. Built to FIA specifications, the model receives suspension and braking upgrades plus a full roll cage to protect the occupants.
Cars

Tesla brings track mode to Model 3 Performance

The new Track Mode introduced for the Tesla 3 Performance model adds stability to the drive while you're behind the wheel and is specifically designed for driving on closed track courses.
Cars

Prep your car for the coming snow and sleet with these cold weather tips

Driving in the winter, whether downtown or across the country, is rarely easy. Luckily, we've put together a quick rundown of a few things you should do to winterize your car before the snow officially hits.
Digital Trends Live

DT Daily: Waymo’s driverless cars, ‘Fallout 76’ tips, and Racella

In today's episode of DT Daily, we discuss Waymo's foray into the ridesharing sector, along with various tips for making the most of the recently launched Fallout 76. We also sit down with singer Racella to chat about her new EP, Waves.
Cars

Many adults believe fully self-driving cars are already traversing U.S. highways

The American Automobile Association tested cars with features such as lane-keeping and adaptive cruise control and found them lacking in real-world conditions. Forty percent of surveyed U.S. adults think self-driving cars exist now.
Cars

Want to keep connected on the road? Here are 5 ways to add Bluetooth to your car

The best way to make an old ride feel young again is to bring it up speed with the 21st century. Here's how to properly add Bluetooth to your vehicle, via independent kits, vehicle adapters, or aftermarket head units.
Cars

Jeep’s outdoorsy Gladiator pickup truck bares it all ahead of schedule

Jeep will introduce the long-promised Wrangler-based pickup truck at the 2018 Los Angeles Auto Show. Named Gladiator, the model was designed to conquer the great outdoors, not for the construction site.
Cars

The hamster-friendly 2020 Kia Soul will rock out at the Los Angeles Auto Show

Kia has released a teaser image to preview the next Soul. Scheduled to make its debut at the 2018 Los Angeles Auto Show, the 2020 Soul will keep the outgoing model's boxy proportions but it will wear a sharper design.
Cars

2020 Toyota Corolla sedan aims to offer sharper handling, better tech

The 2020 Toyota Corolla sedan gets the same upgrades as the recently-introduced Corolla hatchback, including a firmer foundation, new engine, and more tech features. Will that be enough to keep the long-lived Corolla nameplate relevant?
Cars

Startup Rivian exits stealth mode with a bold promise to electrify off-roaders

Electric car startup Rivian has finally turned off stealth mode and provided details about what it's been working on since 2009. It will build battery-powered off-roaders instead of taking on Tesla and others in the luxury EV segment.
Cars

Uber rolls out rewards program that lets its most loyal riders lock in prices

Uber launched a new loyalty program today called Uber Rewards. It offers frequent riders credits to Uber Eats, car upgrades, and the ability to lock in prices on their most traveled routes.
Cars

The world’s first 3D-printed titanium wheels are so intricate they look fake

HRE Performance Wheels and GE Additive have teamed up to create the world's first 3D-printed titanium wheels. They are not only impressively durable, but extremely lightweight as well.