Skip to main content

Warranty Direct’s ‘nightmare’ car is the automotive version of Frankenstein’s monster. Is your car a donor?

Warranty Direct 'Nightmare' Car
Image used with permission by copyright holder
What do you get when you combine “the suspension of an Audi, the gearbox of a Jeep, and the electrics of a Mercedes?”

You get something that keeps mechanics up at night; an automotive amalgamation that would make Mary Shelly proud.

U.K. company Warranty Direct has released the details of its ‘nightmare’ car, a vehicle affectionately named the Horrific 40RR0R.

What the 40RR0R does is selects the worst rated components the motoring world has to offer and conceptually sticks them together. It uses Warranty Direct’s in-house Reliability Index as a guide, which “calculates trustworthiness of vehicles by measuring average cost of repair, frequency of failure, age, and mileage.”

The result looks like something out of Sleepy Hollow, and features only the worst of the worst.

Specifically, the ‘nightmare’ equips the engine from a BMW M5 (2004-2011), the suspension from an Audi RS6 (2002 – 2011), the gearbox from a Jeep Grand Cherokee (2006 – present), the electrics from the Mercedes-Benz R-Class (2004 – present), the brakes from a Fiat Multipla (1999 – 2005), the air conditioning from the SEAT Alhambra (1996 – present), and the steering from the Chrysler 300C (2005 – present).

According to the British firm, the average car scores around 100 in the RI. The Horrific 40RR0R earns an RI of nearly 500, and yes, higher numbers are bad. The company estimates the fictional vehicle would cost around $890 each time it breaks down every other month.

Some troubling facts were bundled along with the press release as well, like the revelation that nearly forty percent of Audi RS6s (from the years indicated) require axle and suspension repair each year, and twenty five percent of BMW M5s require work done to the engine in the same time frame. Additionally, the Chrysler 300C received low marks, with over ten percent heading to the doctor with steering issues annually.

Warranty Direct Managing Director David Gerrans says the “large variety of vehicles that goes into the concoction proves how typically reliable cars can be dragged down by one poorly-performing part.”

Just in time for Halloween.

Andrew Hard
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Andrew first started writing in middle school and hasn't put the pen down since. Whether it's technology, music, sports, or…
Rivian R2 vs R1S: How will Rivian’s cheaper SUV compare?
The front three-quarter view of a 2022 Rivian against a rocky backdrop.

Rivian has finally unveiled the R2, its long-awaited attempt at a more affordable electric SUV. The new vehicle may not be available just yet, but fans of Rivian's design aesthetics and feature set are already looking forward to being able to order the new car. The R2 is targeted at being a more affordable take on the electric SUV and will sit alongside the flagship-tier R1S.

Let's get this out of the way right now: The R1S is most likely going to be a better vehicle than the R2. Rivian isn't replacing the R1S with the R2 — it's releasing the R2 as a more affordable alternative, and there will be some compromises when buying the R2 over the R1S.

Read more
Cybertruck production reportedly halted over pedal issue
Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck. Tesla

Tesla’s Cybertruck has been hit by a production delay caused by an issue with a part of the vehicle, a number of media reports have claimed.

Read more
Don’t let the gimmicks fool you. The Ioniq 5 N is a serious track car
2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N drifting.

We’re finally getting to the fun part of automakers’ methodical quest to replicate their lineups with electric cars.

Performance versions of ordinary cars have been a staple of the auto industry for decades. But while we’ve already seen some variants of EVs boasting more power and more impressive stats — think Tesla Model S Plaid or Lucid Air Sapphire — the 2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N is the first to truly apply that format to an EV.

Read more