Skip to main content

Carmax cites service, parts issues for temporarily dropping Tesla

Thousands of used cars are looking for a driveway to call home on CarMax lots across the United States, and some of them are electric, but none are manufactured by Tesla. It hasn’t always been that way. Digital Trends reached out to the retailer and learned why it shunned the California-based automaker, and what it plans to do about it.

Data compiled by Thinknum Media reveals CarMax had hundreds of Tesla models in its inventory in early 2019; it listed 343 cars in February, an all-time peak, but that figure gradually dropped over the following months. It offered 75 cars for sale in April, 48 in May, 17 in July, and it cleared Tesla from its inventory in September of that year. That’s not due to a company policy; CarMax explained to Digital Trends it experienced issues with the brand.

“CarMax does not currently have Teslas available for sale. We were selling them but stopped for a period of time due to Tesla service and parts issues,” a spokesperson clarified. The representative wouldn’t provide details about the types of issues encountered, and Digital Trends reached out to Tesla, but the company chose not to tell its side of the story.

Build quality has improved significantly since the Model 3 entered production in 2017, and Tesla offers one of the most generous warranties in the automotive industry, so I don’t think the problems CarMax alluded to in its email relates to reliability. However, getting a Tesla repaired is easier said than done due to part supply issues that are well documented on the company’s official forum and elsewhere online. Spending weeks waiting for a car to come back from the shop is annoying for a private motorist, but it could turn into a financial nightmare for a dealership.

“We expect to begin selling them again in the future,” the representative told Digital Trends. The spokesperson declined to reveal precisely when the Model 3, the Model S, and the Model X will return to the CarMax inventory.

In the meantime, there are several other ways to buy a used Tesla. Many dealer- and privately owned examples are listed in the classifieds around the United States, and Tesla keeps a well-stocked fleet of certified used cars.

Editors' Recommendations

Ronan Glon
Ronan Glon is an American automotive and tech journalist based in southern France. As a long-time contributor to Digital…
Tesla says Cybertruck resellers could face harsh penalties
Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck. Tesla

Early buyers of Tesla’s new Cybertruck could be forced to hand over $50,000 to the automaker if they try to sell the electric pickup within the first year of purchase.

Read more
Lucid joins other automakers by adopting Tesla charging plug
A Lucid Motors EV.

Lucid Motors has become the latest automaker to announce that it will adopt the North American Charging Standard (NACS) – also known as "the Tesla plug" – for its electric vehicles.

The move follows in the footsteps of more than a dozen other automakers that have also adopted Tesla’s charging connector, among them General Motors, Ford, Toyota, BMW, Jaguar Land Rover, Volvo, and Honda.

Read more
Watch your back, Tesla. Volvo’s EX30 just raised the bar on EV value
Front three quarter view of the 2025 Volvo EX30.

Automakers are quick to say that electric cars are the future, but most aren’t acting that way. In an effort to convince customers to overlook teething problems with charging infrastructure, amortize major investments in battery manufacturing as quickly as possible, and maybe replicate a bit of that Tesla magic, automakers have been emphasizing performance and tech gimmicks instead of what really matters: building cars people can afford. Change is coming, though, and from an unexpected source.

Volvo is known for safety and sensible Swedish design, not value. But the 2025 Volvo EX30 undercuts EVs from mainstream brands like Hyundai, Kia, and Volkswagen in price without compromising range, features, or style. Pricing starts at just $36,245 for the base Single Motor Extended Range Core model, and even the maxed-out price of $47,895 for a Twin Motor Performance Ultra looks inexpensive compared to the stratospheric heights some EV prices can reach when all option boxes are checked.

Read more