Skip to main content

Adobe clarifies new AI terms and conditions after high-profile users revolt

An image-editor app being used to edit photos on a laptop.
Mylene Tremoyet / Pexels

Adobe updated the terms and conditions for its popular Creative Cloud suite of photo and video editing apps on Thursday, setting off a wave of protests and vitriol from its users, who were upset that the new rules seemingly granted the company rights to “access [user] content through both automated and manual methods, such as for content review.” On Friday, the company was forced to clarify those changes and unequivocally state that, no, Adobe does not own artists’ works, nor will it use that content to train its AI systems like Firefly.

The controversy began Thursday when Creative Cloud users opened their apps to discover themselves locked out from using the programs, uninstalling them, or even contacting customer support, until the new terms were agreed to. Users were not amused.

“Hey @Photoshop what the hell was that new agreement you forced us to sign this morning that locked our app until we agree to it,” wrote director Duncan Jones in a tweet. “We are working on a bloody movie here, and NO, you don’t suddenly have the right to any of the work we are doing on it because we pay you to use Photoshop.”

Adobe initially responded on Thursday with the following:

This policy has been in place for many years. As part of our commitment to being transparent with our customers, we added clarifying examples earlier this year to our Terms of Use regarding when Adobe may access user content. Adobe accesses user content for a number of reasons, including the ability to deliver some of our most innovative cloud-based features, such as Photoshop Neural Filters and Remove Background in Adobe Express, as well as to take action against prohibited content. Adobe does not access, view, or listen to content that is stored locally on any user’s device.

In a blog post Friday, Adobe sought to further clarify its motivations for changing the terms and conditions. “The focus of this update was to be clearer about the improvements to our moderation processes that we have in place,” the Adobe Communications Team wrote. “Given the explosion of Generative AI and our commitment to responsible innovation, we have added more human moderation to our content submissions review processes.”

screenshot of the changes to Adobe terms and conditions
Adobe

Adobe explained that its systems need to access user content for a variety of nominal uses, such as “opening and editing files for the user or creating thumbnails or a preview for sharing,” or to apply AI-enhanced tools like Photoshop Neural Filters, Liquid Mode, or Remove Background. The company will also apply machine learning systems in moderation reviews to screen for illegal content like spam and child sexual abuse material (CSAM).

The company went on to further pledge that “Adobe does not train Firefly Gen AI models on customer content” and that “Adobe will never assume ownership of a customer’s work.” The company was quick to point out that while it does host content “to enable customers to use our applications and services, customers own their content and Adobe does not assume any ownership of customer work.”

Adobe plans to push a notification more clearly explaining the Terms and Condition changes when customers next open their editing apps.

Editors' Recommendations

Andrew Tarantola
Andrew has spent more than a decade reporting on emerging technologies ranging from robotics and machine learning to space…
The best password managers for 2024
have i been pwned owner uncovers 13 million plaintext passwords leaked from free webhost is a safe password even possible we

If you're thinking about getting a new password manager, we can help narrow down your choices. Here's a list of the best and most secure solutions for taking your logins with you wherever you go, no matter what device you use.
No more retyping passwords every time you switch from your Windows PC to your iPhone or from a Mac to an Android phone. These premium password managers have more than just the basics, making your life easier and keeping your accounts safe at affordable prices.

1Password (Windows, Mac, iOS, Android, Linux, and Chrome OS)

Read more
This Lenovo laptop is normally $2,919 — today it’s $919
The Lenovo ThinkPad T14s Gen 5 opened up on a table.

Lenovo laptop deals aren’t too difficult to come by, but this promotion was so exceptional, it needed its own spotlighting! Right now, Lenovo is knocking $2,000 off the Lenovo ThinkPad T14s. Since it's normally priced at $2,920, it’s hard to say how long this markdown is going to last. If you’ve been sitting on a laptop upgrade for a minute, now might be the time to get some new gear.

Why you should buy the Lenovo ThinkPad T14s laptop
Built for businesses, the ThinkPad has long been the go-to Lenovo laptop for busy professionals. Portability is one of the strong suits here: At 12.50 inches wide, 8.93 inches from front to back, and 0.65 inches tall, the ultraportable T14s is the ideal PC for frequent travelers. It’s lightweight too, weighing but a mere 2.71 pounds.

Read more
Best Dell laptop deals: Cheap laptops starting at $280
The Dell XPS 13 9315 on a table against a window.

Being one of the best laptop brands on the market, it's no surprise that Dell has a huge selection of laptops that you can potentially pick from. Whether you're going for gaming laptops or just normal day-to-day laptops, there's probably a great option for you. In fact, there are even some great budget laptops for those who don't really need anything fancy and just want something basic to get online and access shows or work-related content.
Of course, having so many options can be a bit overwhelming for somebody who isn't familiar with Dell or the laptop market, which is why we scoured the Dell website and other retailers for our favorite picks and listed them below. This list has a lot of crossover with the best Dell XPS deals, student laptop deals and gaming laptop deals, so make sure to check out some of those other great laptop deals as well.

Dell Inspiron 15 -- $280, was $330

Read more