Skip to main content

How macOS Sonoma could fix widgets — or make them even worse

Apple's 15-inch MacBook Air on a desk, with macOS Sonoma running on its display.

At its Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) earlier this year, Apple revealed that interactive widgets would be coming to macOS Sonoma. That probably sounds like a tiny new feature, and sure, it’s not as earth-shattering as the Vision Pro announcement. But it could turn out to be one of the most divisive new features in the Mac operating system.

In macOS Sonoma, you’ll be able to plant widgets on your desktop instead of hiding them in the Notification Center. Many widgets will be interactive, letting you tick off to-do list items without opening the widget’s app, for example. And you’ll be able to run iOS widgets right on your desktop, even if that app isn’t installed on your Mac. It’s a pretty comprehensive overhaul. Depending on how well these interactive widgets work, though, we could be left with a bunch of annoying distractions or a set of super-helpful timesavers. The way Apple handles them is going to be vital.

We’ve been here before

Image used with permission by copyright holder

This isn’t the first time Apple has redesigned how widgets work on the Mac — in fact, it’s always been in flux. Apple used to offer widgets in OS X as part of its Dashboard feature, which put a few handy tools just a swipe or a shortcut away. But the company eventually ditched Dashboard and shunted everything into the Notification Center in a sideways move that left widgets out of sight and out of mind.

You probably won’t be surprised to hear that I’ve never really used macOS widgets — whether in Dashboard or the Notification Center — simply because they’ve never felt all that useful. I don’t use the Notification Center much anyway, so most of the time I just forget the widgets are even there.

Is Apple’s latest idea — letting you put widgets on your desktop — a better idea, or will we just end up getting bored of them the way we did with every other Mac widget attempt Apple has made? Will they just clutter up our desktops like the bad old days of Windows Vista, with its ugly sticky notes and performance widgets constantly getting in the way? I shudder at the thought, but there’s certainly promise here if Apple can pull it off.

Porting widgets

Apple's Craig Federighi introducing widgets in macOS Sonoma at the 2023 Worldwide Developers Conference.

There’s a potential ray of hope in the fact that Apple is opening up its macOS widgets to third-party developers, just as it did with iOS and iPadOS widgets. As on those platforms, we could end up with a huge array of fun and interesting widgets, only this time with delightful interactive elements. It’s a great opportunity for developers to flex their creative muscles.

Yet here, too, is a potential stumbling block. Right now, you can run iPad apps on your Mac, and there are some beautifully thought-out iPadOS ports that work flawlessly in their new home. But just as often I’ve come across lazy box-ticking exercises that feel absolutely jarring and out of place on a Mac, complete with oversized text and weird resizing glitches. When that happens, it’s an unpleasant experience.

We’ve got to hope we don’t get the same treatment with widgets, and that Apple encourages developers to port them thoughtfully and in ways that make sense for a desktop operating system. Apple already provides extensive guidance to devs when it comes to app design, and the Apple community is full of amazingly talented developers who will no doubt cook up plenty of superb widgets. Let the good outweigh the bad.

Naturally interactive

A widget being moved into place in macOS Sonoma. The placement grid is shown beneath the widget.
A widget being moved into place in macOS Sonoma. The placement grid is shown beneath the widget. Digital Trends

In the end, it’s a different piece of the puzzle that could end up saving widgets in macOS Sonoma: their interactivity. I’ve tried a few widgets in the macOS Sonoma beta that have interactive elements, and every time using them feels so completely natural that, perversely, it’s almost unremarkable. After all, it feels like this is the way widgets should be.

You could say that’s great news for Apple’s new widget features. If using them feels utterly intuitive, people are more likely to give them a go and stick with them. Ticking off checklist items or running shortcuts right from the widget saves time and makes far more sense than having to open the app before interacting with it.

That could be the killer feature of widgets in macOS Sonoma. You might think that interactivity is such a small feature that it almost feels unnecessary to highlight it. Yet at the same time, it could be exactly what helps widgets take off on the Mac.

There’s still plenty of time for Apple to refine widgets’ rough edges and add new features to the public beta, and macOS Sonoma won’t launch until the fall. By then, we’ll know for sure whether Apple’s latest operating system has gained another brilliant feature — or another half-baked flop.

Editors' Recommendations

Alex Blake
In ancient times, people like Alex would have been shunned for their nerdy ways and strange opinions on cheese. Today, he…
The next MacBook Air could come with a major disappointment
A MacBook Air on a desk with an open book in front of it.

It’s something of an open secret that Apple is working on a couple of fresh MacBook Air models, including an all-new 15-inch MacBook Air. Many details about these devices have been shrouded in mystery, but a prominent analyst has just shed some much-needed light on them -- and it’s not all good news.

Posting on Twitter, Apple analyst Ming-Chi Kuo updated his previous predictions for Apple’s lightweight laptop. In the new post, Kuo outlined a slate of ideas for what could be coming next.

Read more
The one thing the next version of macOS needs to address
The MacBook Pro open on a wooden table.

Every year we get a new version of macOS, and that usually comes with an assortment of tweaks and features. But with the massive uptick in interest in generative AI, 2023 isn't like any other year in the world of tech.

Apple hasn't commented on or announced anything in response to tools like ChatGPT or Midjourney, making it one of the few big tech companies that haven't dipped their toe in yet. But WWDC 2023 is just around the corner, and rather than focus on all the iterative features Apple likely has in the works, generative AI will feel like the elephant in the room if it isn't addressed in macOS 14.

Read more
Here’s why WWDC could be a ‘critical event’ for Apple
Apple CEO Tim Cook looks at a display of brand new redesigned MacBook Air laptop during the WWDC22

Apple is planning a packed line-up for its Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) on June 5, which could become “one of the most critical events in the company’s history.” Aside from the company’s upcoming Reality Pro headset, there will be major updates to Apple’s software systems, including the biggest watchOS revamp since the Apple Watch launched in 2015.

That’s according to a new report from Bloomberg journalist Mark Gurman, who has a history of accurate predictions and leaks surrounding Apple products. It suggests that WWDC will be a chance for Apple to set out its future ambitions for a “post-iPhone era.”

Read more