Skip to main content

Apple Sues Psystar, Admits MobileMe Mess

Apple began rolling out its MobileMe collection of "cloud-based" Internet services last week just before the iPhone 3G went on sale…and days later, the company was still trying to get the services up and running smoothly, with the company’s much-touted Web applications proving more difficult to bring online than they were to demo at a WWDC keynote. Apple says the services are all up and running now, and by way of apology it’s giving MobileMe early adopters an automatic 30-day extension on their MobileMe subscriptions.

Interestingly, Apple also says it’s going to stop using the word "push" to describe synchronization between email, contact, and calendar data handled by the service: while Apple says changes from iPhones and Web applications are indeed very speedy, changes made from a PC or Mac might take 15 minutes to propagate, so the company is going to stop using the word "push" to describe the services until Macs and PCs can get near-instant synchronization too.

Recommended Videos

On another front, remember Psystar, the Florida company that began offering the Open Computer Mac clone for $399? The company announced additional hardware models and even an Openserv server unit to compete with Apple’s Xserve, and everyone’s been waiting for the day when Apple will finally take notice—after all, if there really is an open season for running Mac OS X on non-Apple hardware, the company could face a serious challenge to its lucrative Macintosh sales. Now, word comes that Apple has finally gotten around to suing Psystar, alleging eight claims of copyright infringement, trademark and trade infringement, and unfair competition.

Apple is, of course, asking for statutory and actual damages, along with any profits Psystar has gleaned from selling Mac clones. However, the company is also asking the court to order Psystar recall Mac clones it has already sold.

"By misappropriating Apple’s proprietary software and intellectual property for its own use," Apple wrote in its complaint, "Psystar’s actions harm consumers by selling to them a poor product that is advertised and promoted in a manner that falsely and unfairly implies an affiliation with Apple."

Psystar could not be reached for comment; Apple representatives declined to comment on the suit.

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Window management in macOS annoys me. This free app was the fix I needed
Swift Shift app running on a MacBook.

Apple’s approach to Mac computing is rather odd. The unwavering focus on simplicity, fluidity, and elegance sets it apart from Windows. But at the same time, it can feel a lot restrictive. Nothing exemplifies that better than app windows in macOS.

Until macOS Sequoia, Apple didn’t even offer proper window tiling and snapping options. Windows has served them for a while now, and in a fashion that even power users would approve. 

Read more
Apple is right to make iPadOS more Mac-like, but I’ll never buy an iPad that runs macOS
Magic Keyboard and iPad Pro.

Do you use a Mac or an iPad? Huge numbers of people use both, yet there are growing calls for Apple to merge the two devices into some kind of all-in-one super product. I’m not one of those people -- in fact I think it would be a terrible idea -- and I’m determined to steer clear of any hypothetical iPad that runs macOS.

Over the past few years, Apple’s best iPads have grown closer to the Mac. We’ve seen the devices get outfitted with Mac-grade chips like the M4, gain macOS-like software features such as Stage Manager, and gain increased compatibility with mice and keyboards.

Read more
The Oppo Find N5 put a Mac in my pocket, and Apple needs to take note.
An Oppo Find N5 is being used for remote access to a Mac.

It’s no secret that the biggest strength of Apple’s ecosystem is the seamless cross-device connectivity it offers. Yet, despite commanding the world’s biggest mobile-computing duopoly, Apple hasn’t offered two-way control for iPhones and Macs to remotely operate each other. It’s a shame, because given Apple’s security-first approach, it’s in the best spot to offer such a facility. 

The situation only changed last year, but only halfway through. With the arrival of iOS 18 and macOS Sequoia, Apple finally introduced iPhone Mirroring. However, there’s still no equivalent that allows you to access and control your Mac desktop on your iPhone. Or an iPad. Some third-party options have existed, though, but haven't really been stellar. 

Read more