Skip to main content

Ex-police officer jailed indefinitely for refusing to decrypt hard drives

A former police sergeant in the Philadelphia Police Department has been held in jail for seven months with no sign of release, despite not being charged with a crime. He is suspected of being in possession of child pornography, and refuses to decrypt the hard drives that could convict him. The court has ruled he’ll stay in jail until he does.

This case comes at an interesting time given the ongoing public debate over encryption. The argument “nothing to hide, nothing to fear” is often offered by encryption opponents, while encryption proponents suggest personal privacy is a right and shouldn’t be infringed upon without due process.

Recommended Videos

The real-world effect of these two conflicting arguments is no more apparent than in the case of this particular police officer. The evidence against him is thin, with previous device searches finding no child pornography. The only relevant evidence involves circumstantial statements from his sister and an expert who offered a “best guess” that underage pornography was on his encrypted drives.

But even if there is illegal material on those drives, the Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination could protect the officer from having to do so, since opening them up could lead to his conviction (thanks Ars).

This is the argument the defense is putting forward on the officer’s behalf. His attorneys are also highlighting the overuse of the 1789 All Writs Act, which the court is using to try and force the defendant to comply.

Because of his non-compliance, the officer is being held in contempt of court, and the judge for his case has ruled he will not be allowed to leave jail until he does comply.

As highly charged as the potential charges of child pornography are, the defense argues that this sets a dangerous precedent, permitting someone who has not been charged with a crime, and against whom only minimal evidence has been presented, to be held indefinitely in jail.

Weighing in on the situation is the pro-privacy Electronic Frontier Foundation, which also highlighted how forcing decryption on an alleged criminal could violate their Fifth Amendment rights.

“The Fifth Amendment provides an absolute privilege against such self-incriminating compelled decryption,” the Foundation asserted in a related statement.

Jon Martindale
Jon Martindale is a freelance evergreen writer and occasional section coordinator, covering how to guides, best-of lists, and…
The new Reachy Mini robot can let kids turn play into innovation
The Reachy Mini robot.

The Reachy Mini is an exciting new desktop robot aimed primarily at developers, educators, students, and enthusiasts, or basically anyone interested in creative coding.

There are actually two of them -- Reachy Mini Lite ($299) and Reachy Mini Wireless ($449) -- and both were developed by the prominent AI platform Hugging Face following its recent acquisition of Pollen Robotics. 

Read more
If you’re itching for an HP OMEN MAX gaming laptop, this deal will save you $500
The HP Omen Max gaming laptop with Valorant on the screen.

We've recently published a stunningly positive review of the HP OMEN Max 16. It's got a list of "Pros" a mile long. The single, obligatory con is "Thick and heavy." Considering that it's a gaming laptop, that's practically the equivalent of saying a flashlight is too bright to look at. Thick, and a bit heavy, just comes with the territory. All of this is to say that the review was great and we're fans of the HP OMEN Max 16. As a deal hunter it made me want to go and see if I could find a deal on the HP OMEN Max 16 and I did, sort of. Right now you can get a customizable HP OMEN Max 16t — a laptop that, if it didn't have a separate store page, I would think is identical to the one we reviewed — with a $500 discount, no matter what settings you choose. With the base settings of the laptop, that discount brings it from $2,100 to just $1,600, but you're free to upgrade to your heart's content. Tap the button below to start customizing to your whimsy or keep reading for some advice on how to do so and what to expect from the 16t.

Buy Now

Read more
Google’s AI agent ‘Big Sleep’ just stopped a cyberattack before it started
Sundar Pichai

Google's AI agent, dubbed Big Sleep, has achieved a cybersecurity milestone by detecting and blocking an imminent exploit in the wild—marking the first time an AI has proactively foiled a cyber threat. Developed by Google DeepMind and Project Zero, Big Sleep identified a critical vulnerability in SQLite (CVE-2025-6965), an open-source database engine, that was on the verge of being exploited by malicious actors, allowing Google to patch it before damage occurred. “We believe this is the first time an AI agent has been used to directly foil efforts to exploit a vulnerability in the wild,” the company said.

Why it matters: As cyberattacks surge—costing businesses trillions annually—this breakthrough shifts defense from reactive patching to AI-driven prediction and prevention. It gives security teams a powerful new tool to stay ahead of hackers, potentially saving devices and data worldwide. CEO Sundar Pichai called it "a first for an AI agent—definitely not the last" according to Live Mint.

Read more