Skip to main content

Screen showdown: Amazon Echo Show vs. Google Home with a Chromecast

If you are looking to buy a voice assistant, you will inevitably run into the problem of choosing between a product from Google or Amazon. Both companies have voice assistants and, recently, have begun to include video. Google has Google Home with Chromecast, while Amazon has the Echo Show. The question most consumers have regarding the two is: Can the Google Home with Chromecast keep up with the Echo Show?

Since the Google Home does not come with a screen attached, you will need to buy Chromecast, which is a $35 investment. The Chromecast will attach to a screen, such as a TV, and will allow you to stream video to that TV; the Google Home can cast YouTube videos and Netflix to your TV once Chromecast has been set up. At the moment, however, Google Home cannot turn the TV on. This means you will have to either turn the TV on and then tell Google Home to play a video or leave the TV on all the time.

Beyond videos, the Echo Show dominates the added video field.

Both devices can play specific YouTube videos and recipe videos. However, Google Home will pick a random video from YouTube that it thinks best fits what you want, while the Echo Show will show you options for videos. Also, Google Home will only show you a video, not any instructions for recipes or other videos.

Beyond videos, the Echo Show dominates the added video field. The Echo Show can show you lists of movies that are playing in the area, shopping lists, lyrics to songs, news highlights, and calendar events. The Google Home just isn’t able to provide these features with Chromecast.

Another feature that the Echo Show has that the Google Home does not have is Drop In. Drop In allows users with the Alexa app to connect directly with the Echo Show in a FaceTime-esque scenario. This video call connects directly to the screen on the Echo Show, but only users with the Alexa app are able to connect. Google Home can make calls to any other US phone, but there is no video calling that is available, yet.

When comparing these two devices it is clear they are not on the same level. The Echo Show simply does the video features much better than the Google Home. That being said, the Google Home is much better at knowledge questions simply because it has access to Google’s knowledge. Overall, the Echo Show has a much better integrated video system that Chromecast can’t compare to.

David Cogen, a regular contributor here at Digital Trends, runs a popular tech blog that focuses on tech news, tips and tricks, and the latest tech. You can also find him over at Twitter discussing the latest tech trends.

Editors' Recommendations

Nicole Edsall
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Amazon drops crazy Echo Dot deal foreshadowing best Prime Day yet
amazon echo dot sengled smart light  3rd generation sandstone with 2 bulb kit by 03

Prime Day 2020 hasn't started yet, but Amazon has already hinted that it's going to be its best one yet. How? Because it has just kicked off an utterly ridiculous Prime Day Amazon Echo deal that sees the Echo Dot (3rd Gen) on sale for just $19 -- down a $31 from the usual $50. Pricing aside, what's interesting here it has been to date, beating the discount we saw on Black Friday by $3.

If the rainforest-named retailer takes that same approach for the million-odd items that will be on sale tomorrow, we're certainly in for a treat. In fact, we already know that'll be the case. Confirming the Prime Day 2020 date at the end of September, Amazon told Digital Trends that items discounted on Prime Day 2020 won't be cheaper on Black Friday 2020 or Cyber Monday 2020.
What does this Echo Dot deal mean for Prime Day 2020?
Looking at some of the other Amazon device deals the e-commerce titan launched today, one thing is clear: It isn't playing around when it comes to discounts. We've seen the Amazon Echo Studio discounted from $200 down to just $150, the fan-favorite Fire HD 10 tablet on sale for just $80 from $150, and Fire TV Recast (500GB) in the bargain bin at $100 below sticker.

Read more
Amazon’s Echo Show 10 (3rd Gen) has a screen that moves so you don’t have to

At its annual fall event, Amazon announced new and refreshed Echo Show devices, including the Echo Show 10 (3rd Gen) that can use the camera to act as a security camera.

The most impressive part of the Echo Show 10 is the intelligent movement feature. Amazon noted that while the device may be stationary, it understands that users are not. Since the Echo Show is so often depicted as being used in the kitchen, a room where customers move around a lot while cooking, the Echo Show 10 (3rd Gen) is equipped with a motor that allows the screen to follow you.

Read more
Amazon Echo still king among smart speakers despite declining U.S. market share
amazon echo google home smart speakers deals 5 768x768

Both Apple and Google have rabid followings in the smart speaker market, but neither one comes close to Amazon’s market share. According to a recent report from eMarketer, Amazon will continue to comfortably hold its market lead throughout 2021, with roughly 70% of smart speaker users choosing an Amazon Echo device. On the other hand, 70% is lower than last year’s reported usage of 72.9%.

Market analysis firm eMarketer predicts that Amazon’s market lead will continue to decrease as both Google and Apple strengthen their product offerings and bring more to the smart assistant market. They estimate that next year, 69.7% of smart speaker users will be loyal to Amazon, 31.7% will use Google-branded smart speakers, and 18.4% will use other types of smart speakers. eMarketer notes this percentage adds up to over 100% because some users employ multiple brands.

Read more