Skip to main content

Google Defends Net Neutrality Proposal with Verizon

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Google has moved to clarify the net neutrality proposal it put forward earlier this week with Verizon, saying that the largely negative coverage and discussion about the proposed regulator framework has been misleading and inaccurate. Google now wants to dispel “myths” that that it has sold out on network neutrality and consigned its famous “Don’t be evil” mantra to the dustbins of Internet history.

“We believe this proposal represents real progress on what has become a very contentious issue, and we think it could help move the network neutrality debate forward constructively,” wrote Google’s Washington Telecom and Media Counsel Richard Whitt in the company’s public policy blog. “We don’t expect everyone to agree with every aspect of our proposal, but there has been a number of inaccuracies about it, and we do want to separate fact from fiction.”

Whitt argues that no other company has championed network neutrality as staunchly as Google, but that inaction from Congress and regulators in Washington D.C. has made some sort of compromise necessary. Whitt notes that federal inaction—coupled with Comcast’s recent court victory over FCC regulatory authority—means there are currently no enforceable protections on Internet access, which effectively means any access provider could block any content, application, or service they like and face no repercussions. Whitt argues the joint Google/Verizon policy proposal isn’t perfect, but is considerably better than no consumers protections at all.

In the policy proposal, Google and Verizon would codify the FCC’s Internet Policy Statement as enforceable law, enabling consumers to run any lawful application, service, or device they choose on the public Internet; providers would also have to be fully transparent about their network management practices. However, except for transparency, none of those protections would be applied to mobile Internet services, and carriers would be free to set up managed services separate from the “public Internet” which would not be subject to neutrality regulations.

Google argues stiff competition in the wireless sector will keep operators from abusing openness principles, since failure to offer open access would be a significant competitive disadvantage. It also argues the creation of specialized managed services separate from the “public Internet” would not cannibalize existing Internet services since they would be subject to FCC monitoring and required to be “distinguishable in purpose and scope” from the public Internet.

Industry and public response to the joint Google/Verizon proposal has been roundly negative—critiques from the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Public Knowledge not the complexity of the problem, but roundly knock the proposed framework. In addition to pundits accusing Google of selling out on its openness principles, particularly in the mobile arena, the proposal as even engendered a real-world protest sponsored by and Free Press scheduled to take place today at Google’s Mountain View, California, headquarters.

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Best VPN services 2023: today’s top picks
best VPN services

Looking for the best VPN to ensure your online privacy at an affordable price? In today's internet-driven world, protecting your personal and financial data from cybercriminals is more important than ever. Identity thieves, hackers, and other digital miscreants cause substantial financial losses to businesses and individuals around the world every year. The good news is that a reliable VPN is one of the easiest, cheapest, and most effective ways to safeguard your online activities from unwanted network intruders. However, selecting the most suitable VPN for your specific needs and budget can be challenging. Don't worry — we've got you covered. Our comprehensive guide to the best VPN services covers pricing, features, and all the information you need to make an informed decision.
Best VPN 2023

Hotspot Shield
Private Internet Access
Kaspersky VPN
AdGuard VPN
Mullvad VPN
Strong VPN
Proton VPN
VPN Unlimited

Read more
Best Meta Quest 3 accessories to make your VR experience even better
Meta Quest 3 sitting on a display table.

The Meta Quest 3 is an exciting next-generation VR headset with some impressive features. While there are a couple of different versions with more or less storage, you can also augment your Quest 3 with a range of accessories. From replacement faceplates, to a better headband, extra batteries, and charging stations, here are the best Quest 3 accessories you can use to improve your VR gaming experience.

Note, at the time of writing all of these accessories are available as pre-orders only. They, like the Quest 3, will officially go on sale on October 10, or shortly after.

Read more
Apple fixed one of my biggest macOS gripes with Sonoma — but I still want more
Federighi talking about Continuity Camera.

Apple’s macOS Sonoma update has just been launched and, let’s be honest here, it’s a pretty modest upgrade (probably thanks to the work required on the Vision Pro’s software). Still, when Apple unveiled Sonoma a few months ago, there was one feature that got me excited: Continuity Camera.

This nifty tool lets you use your iPhone as a high-quality webcam. Sure, it actually debuted with macOS Ventura, but this year we’ve got much more control over how it works. Sliders! Toggles! Yes, it’s all here.

Read more