How much has the Intel Haswell HD 4600 really improved integrated graphics?

Intel 4th gen haswell chip

Intel has spent a lot of time talking about its new “Iris” graphics on upcoming Haswell parts, so much so that you could be forgiven for assuming that it would be standard. That, however, is not the case. While Iris and Iris Pro represent the best Intel has to offer, many computers, from desktops to tablets, will have to make do with Intel HD 4600.

The information available prior to launch was vague about HD 4600’s capabilities, and what was said did not seem promising, so we were eager to see how the new mid-range integrated graphics processor (IGP) stacks up against Intel’s previous HD 2500 and HD 4000. To test HD 4600, we fired up several games as well as the world’s most demanding benchmarks.

What has changed in HD 4600


intelhd4600

When Intel released the first new Core processor architecture, known as Nehalem, it did so alongside a long-term commitment to improve the quality of its integrated graphics processors. This happened with the re-launch of the company’s IGP as Intel HD Graphics, a revision that out-performed previous Intel IGPs by a significant margin. In previous generations, Intel has used a two-prong graphics strategy consisting of a low-end variant barely adequate for even old games, and a high-end variant meant to provide acceptable performance in most titles. During the last generation, these were known as HD 2500 and HD 4000, respectively.

The new HD 4600 is essentially a revision of HD 4000, in the same way that Haswell is a revision of the preceding Ivy Bridge. Performance has been improved mainly through a pair of significant changes: an increase in execution units from 16 to 20, and an improvement in clock speed minimum from 350 MHz to 400 MHz. HD 4600, like its predecessor, will automatically overclock itself up to a maximum of 1350 MHz. However, this maximum clock will not be obtainable on certain low-voltage parts, which means not every system with HD 4600 will perform identically.

Intel has also used the revision as an opportunity to upgrade compatibility with graphics standards. The new IGP supports Direct X 11.1, as well as Open CL 1.2 and Open GL 4.0. These tweaks are not hugely important in the short-term, but it’s always good for a graphics component to support the latest standards.

Our testing methods

To test HD graphics we used two older computers in our possession and the Fragbox review unit on loan to us from Falcon Northwest. The specifications of these computers can be found below.

haswelltest

Each system was put through the same five benchmarks, which we ran with the following setting:

  • 3DMark Cloud Gate: Tested with default settings
  • Unigine Heaven 2.1: 1280×1024 Normal Tessellation DirectX 11 AA off AF 1x
  • The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim: 1366×768 DirectX 11 medium detail preset
  • Battlefield 3: 1366×768 DirectX 11 medium detail preset
  • Deus Ex Human Revolution: 1366×768 DirectX 11 normal detail MSAA on

All results are rounded. In the case of games, we started our tests from the same save file on each system (thanks, Steam Cloud!) and performed similar actions during each of our three test runs.

The results

3DMark 06 Cloud Gate

intehdreview1

Cloud Gate is the middle-rung test in the new 3DMark suite, and it’s meant to simulate a modestly demanding current-gen game. Intel HD 4000 performs adequately, but the new HD 4600 absolutely annihilates the older part’s score by almost doubling it. This resulted in a very obvious render improvement: Cloud Gate runs great on the new hardware.

Unigine Heaven

intelhdreview2

This demanding benchmark is known for its high image quality and extensive use of tessellation. Though the benchmark still runs poorly on Intel HD 4600, there’s an approximately 50% performance increase.

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

intelhdreview3

Skyrim is not the latest-and-greatest game anymore, but it remains a popular title and a demanding benchmark. Intel HD 4600 improves performance by only eight frames-per-second, but those eight frames are important.

The game tends to suffer from spurts of stuttering on HD 4000, and any effects (such as magic) can cause the framerate to dip below 20 FPS, which isn’t a pleasure to play. With Intel HD 4600, however, the game runs smoothly (with a few exceptions) and magical effects don’t turn the game into a slideshow.

And remember: we tested at medium detail; going to low makes the game almost butter-smooth on the new IGP.

Battlefield 3

intelhdreview4

We saw a strangely linear progression in this game, with each bump in graphics hardware increasing average FPS by ten. That translates to an almost 50 percent increase of in-game performance, and, as with Skyrim, the extra performance is enough to take the game from un-enjoyable at medium detail (on HD 4000) to just fine (on HD 4600).

Deus Ex Human Revolution

intelhdreview5

Unlike Skyrim and Battlefield 3, Deus Ex was playable and enjoyable on Intel HD 4000 at the settings we tested. Intel HD 4600 increased performance only 42 percent relative to HD 4000, but because the game already ran well, this smaller relative improvement translates to fourteen extra frames per second. Deus Ex ran smoothly at all times, and there’s enough frame-rate headroom to increase a graphics detail.

Intel HD 4600 is quicker, but what does that mean?

The average performance increase among the three real-world games we tested was 39 percent, and adding in the synthetic tests boosts the gain to 53 percent. That’s about in line with what Intel promised, and more importantly, it was enough to make two games that weren’t enjoyable on HD 4000 a treat on HD 4600.

Improvements don’t mean HD 4600 is an acceptable pick for gamers, however. Our tests were performed at 1366 x 768, which is common among inexpensive laptops, but increasingly rare among desktop PCs, Ultrabooks, and multimedia laptops. Gaming at 1080p will slice a huge chunk off these results and make many games unplayable once again.

We also think it’s reasonable to believe graphics quality in AAA games will see a surge in 2014. Why? Next-gen consoles! With the Xbox One and PlayStation 4 out in winter of 2013, developers will be able to explore new limits. While HD 4600 is quicker, it probably won’t stand up well in PC ports of games built for next-gen consoles.

Intel HD 4600 doesn’t change Intel HD’s position as graphics of last resort, but we’re happy to see the last resort become significantly more powerful. Consumers who can’t afford a discrete GPU can at least play 2011’s best games at reasonable detail, something which could not be said of Intel HD 4000.

Computing

We tested Nvidia’s RTX 2080 and 2080 Ti. Are they a worthy upgrade?

We finally have Nvidia's newest graphics cards, the RTX 2080 and 2080 Ti, and put them through our standard suite of benchmarks and game tests to see how they performed in a standard play of Battlefield 1 and Fornite. How do they compare to…
Computing

Heavily overclocked RTX 2080 Ti steals every 3DMark record

Nvidia's RTX 2080 Ti is already the most powerful graphics card ever released, but with liquid nitrogen cooling overclocker Kingpin was able to push the card to new heights and break a bunch of records in the process.
Computing

Nvidia's new RTX GPUs have arrived. Here's what you need to know about them

Nvidia's new RTX 2000 series graphics cards are impressive pieces of hardware, with some amazing advancements and some rather high price tags to match. Here's everything you need to know about Nvidia's new top-tier cards.
Computing

Nvidia GeForce RTX 2080 vs. RTX 2080 Ti

Nvidia's RTX 2080 Ti is a beast of a graphics card, packing in RT, Tensor, and CUDA cores to enhance your gaming experience. We'll compare the Ti variant to the standard RTX 2080, and we'll let you know which card to buy.
Computing

Tap Strap wearable keyboard gains support for VR applications

TAP System's wearable keyboard gains support for virtual reality, now compatible with Windows Mixed Reality, Oculus Rift, and HTV headsets. Type and tap for up to eight hours in VR without needing to look at a physical keyboard.
Computing

Wi-Fi vulnerability could allow attackers to steal your data on unencrypted sites

A 20-year-old security flaw in the design of the Wi-Fi standard and how computers communicate using the transmission control protocol could allow hackers to perform a web cache poisoning attack to steal your data and login information.
Product Review

The powerhouse Alienware 17 R5 will leave your desktop in the dust

With a 17-inch display and a chassis weighing in at nearly 10 pounds, the Alienware 17 R5 is truly massive. Between its weight and its hardware, it’s certainly outfitted like a gaming desktop so let’s find out if it performs like one.
Deals

Walmart takes $380 off the MacBook Air for a limited time

Walmart is offering a steep discount on the MacBook Air. Though the $380 discount is lovely, this offer comes with an extra charger to sweeten the deal. If you're looking to pick up an Apple MacBook for less, now is an excellent time.
Computing

PDF to JPG conversion is quick and easy using these simple methods

Converting file formats can be an absolute pain, but it doesn't have to be. We've put together a comprehensive guide on how to convert a PDF to JPG, no matter which operating system you're running.
Computing

Documentation shows data recovery possible for Macs with T2 coprocessor

New documentation from Apple shows that data recovery is indeed possible for Macs with T2 Coprocessor thanks to internal diagnostics software, giving users of the 2018 MacBook Pro new hope in the event of a system failure.
Computing

Smart Reply not smart enough? Desktop Gmail users can soon opt out

Google will soon give desktop Gmail users the ability to opt out of Smart Reply. If you'd prefer to compose a short email the old-fashioned way, you can do so without seeing the auto-generated suggestions in the future.
Computing

Edit, sign, append, and save with 12 of the best PDF editors

There are plenty of PDF editors to be had online, and though the selection is robust, finding a solid solution with the tools you need can be tough. Here, we've rounded up best PDF editors, so you can edit no matter your budget or OS.
Product Review

The HP Chromebook x2 takes Chrome to the next level

HP’s Chromebook x2 acts a lot like Microsoft’s Surface Book 2, with a well-equipped tablet that plugs into a keyboard base that’s heavy enough to keep the combination mostly stable. Is this premium Chromebook the best one you can buy?
Computing

Pain in the wrists? Type in comfort with one of these great ergonomic keyboards

Long typing sessions can leave anyone's wrists aching, but if you have one of the best ergonomic keyboards, that doesn't have to be the case. Our list of favorites will support good typing posture while being comfortable to use.