Skip to main content

If the Mac gets a Dynamic Island, I’m not sure I want it

The Dynamic Island was one of the standout features at Apple’s iPhone 14 launch event in September, and it contained just enough classic Apple magic to wow audiences tuning in. But it left us wondering — how would it look on a Mac?

Now, we have an answer thanks to Reddit user DavidGamingHDR, who posted a mocked-up render of the Dynamic Island adorning a MacBook Pro to the r/Mac sub-reddit. And now that we’ve seen it, we’re intrigued — and a little concerned.

A mockup of a MacBook Pro with an iPhone-style Dynamic Island replacing the menu bar at the top of the screen.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Like the iPhone version, DavidGamingHDR’s image depicts a black bar at the top of the screen that houses a number of system settings and app options. Gone is the MacBook’s notch and the familiar MacOS menu bar.

In the example, a user has Discord open, with the Mac’s Dynamic Island showing the usual Discord menu bar items — Discord, Edit, View, Window, and Help — on the left-hand side. On the right, you can see a variety of system icons, including Wi-Fi status, battery percentage, the time, and more.

Is this a good idea?

A close up of the 2021 MacBook Pro showing its display notch.
Digital Trends

However, the mockup raises a number of questions. As several users pointed out in the comments, the design might not be particularly usable. The good thing about the current Mac menu bar is it rests right at the top of the screen. If you want to click a menu bar item, you can just fling your mouse into the corners and the edges of the screen to stop the mouse from going too far.

The upshot is you don’t need to be too accurate. With this Dynamic Island mockup, all the buttons are slightly away from the screen edges. That means you need to be more precise when moving the mouse pointer, resulting in longer interaction times and, if you’re as impatient as I am, more frustration.

There are other questions — how dynamic would this Dynamic Island be? If it frequently changes size like the iPhone version, that might mess with your muscle memory, as buttons are no longer where you expect them to be.

That all might go to show why Apple has not implemented the Dynamic Island on the Mac yet — and why it might never attempt it. Would the design obsessives at Apple be happy with something that looks cool but is irritating to use? I doubt it. (Then again, the Magic Mouse 2 still charges upside down, so who knows?)

Still, it’s fun to imagine how a brilliant feature on iOS might play out in MacOS. Just don’t expect to see it any time soon.

Alex Blake
In ancient times, people like Alex would have been shunned for their nerdy ways and strange opinions on cheese. Today, he…
Don’t wait for macOS Sequoia. This app already has its best feature
Apple's Craig Federighi introducing the new window tiling feature in macOS Sequoia at the Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) 2024.

When Apple lifted the shroud on macOS Sequoia at its Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) in June, there were a lot of headline announcements: Apple Intelligence, iPhone mirroring, a new Passwords app, plus a whole lot more. Yet it was the much more modest announcement of window snapping and tiling that really caught my eye.

For years, Windows users have been able to point to the lack of macOS window snapping as proof of the inferiority of Apple’s operating system. After all, if Apple couldn’t even get such a simple productivity feature right, what else was it failing at?

Read more
Apple customers to finally get a share of $50M MacBook settlement
Some 2015 MacBook Pro models use a butterfly keyboard.

A 2018 MacBook Air with a butterfly keyboard. Digital Trends

A $50 million fund paid by Apple to settle a class-action lawsuit over faulty butterfly keyboards on MacBooks is about to be shared among affected customers following an approved claim, MacRumors reported.

Read more
All the M4 Macs that are still coming out in 2024
Apple's Craig Federighi discusses macOS at the Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) 2024.

This year has been a pretty slow one for the Mac so far, with only the M3 MacBook Air bringing any kind of update to Apple’s computer lineup. But that’s all set to change over the course of 2024, with a broad range of Macs poised to get the M4 series of chips in the coming months. In fact, it could be the first time that every Mac will be on the same family of chips.

That means if you’re looking to upgrade your Apple computer, this could be the time to do it. Wait just a few more months and you’ll have a huge range of up-to-date Macs to choose from, with everything from the MacBook Pro to the Mac Studio joining the M4 series by this time next year.

Read more