Skip to main content

A brain scan could help reveal if antidepressants will work for a patient

A doctor who is prescribing antidepressants will largely rely on self-reporting on the part of patients to make their decision. Unfortunately, antidepressants don’t work on every patient. That’s bad news — especially when it comes to treating depressive episodes, which can have a profound impact on people’s lives. Could A.I. and brain-scanning tech help solve the problem?

That’s the ambitious goal of a new piece of research carried out by scientists from Stanford University. Researchers there have been investigating whether EEG brain scans could be used to more accurately predict who is likely to benefit from taking antidepressants.

Related Videos

“Over the past 10 years, as a field we have come to believe that antidepressants may not be effective drugs,” Amit Etkin, Associate Professor of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, told Digital Trends. “On average, response to an antidepressant is only slightly better than placebo. An alternative explanation, however, is that our current diagnostic approach is too imprecise as it relies on subjective reports alone, with no objective biological testing available. As such, perhaps antidepressants work very well, but only for a portion of people — and our current diagnostic approach can’t discern this type of patient from those who will not respond to the antidepressant.”

The study used machine learning A.I. to analyze brainwaves in order to identify who does and does not respond to a particular antidepressant. The group used data from a large National Institutes of Health (NIH)-sponsored study called EMBARC, first started around a decade ago. EMBARC is the largest placebo-controlled antidepressant trial carried out with brain imaging.

Using their newly developed A.I. algorithm, the team tested out the approach on a group of 279 people. 76% of the study participants that the algorithm predicted would benefit from an antidepressant called sertraline did so. Normally the drug is effective in only around one-third of people. That’s still not perfect, but it’s significantly more accurate than the guesswork that would otherwise have seen people prescribed drugs that ultimately wouldn’t work for them. In the future, the team will gather a larger and more clinically diverse data set to help improve these predictive tools.

“This study helps turn a critical corner in psychiatry — away from trial-and-error treatment selection and toward a more individualized and precise approach,” Etkin said. “This is a much-needed change, as conditions like depression are very prevalent, associated with high morbidity and mortality, and tremendous healthcare and societal costs. The impact of translating these findings to the clinic could be huge on both personal and economic levels.”

A paper describing the work was recently published in the journal Nature Biotechnology.

Editors' Recommendations

Sleep Number’s New 360 Smart Bed monitors and improves sleep health as you age
The Sleep Number New 360 Smart Bed set up in a bedroom

Today at CES 2022, Sleep Number, a leader in sleep health and research, has unveiled the latest entry in its smart bed lineup, the new 360 Smart Bed. With the assistance of A.I. and machine learning, this new smart bed has unique features that will help it monitor and improve your sleep health as you age.

Sleep is a significant part of our lives and vital to our general health. Knowing that, Sleep Number created it smart bed years ago to help track sleeping patterns. This new iteration of the smart bed has even more features to track sleep patterns, as well as predict issues and react when they arise.

Read more
French startup Circular unveils promising Oura fitness-tracking competitor
Movano Ring. Credits: Movano official.

Several smartwear products took the center stage at CES 2022. Apart from the heavy hitters such as Garmin and Skagen, a Movano ring was also unveiled, with a design that specifically has female users in mind. Finally, a French company called Circular also unveiled its first product, simply called the Circular Ring. The Circular Ring has changeable outer shells for user customization. The ring is extremely lightweight at only 4 grams. It is also water-resistant up to 5 meters. It also offers up to 22 days of built-in data storage without a Bluetooth connection. The biocompatible resin-based product will be available in different sizes.
The circular ring could give stiff competition to the Movano ring in the coming years. Movano official.
Tracking and features
A 14-day calibration period begins as soon as the user wears the ring for the first time. During this period, the ring establishes the user's baseline health parameters, which helps it to give them personalized and actionable recommendations to make healthy changes in their lives. Circular tracks multiple health metrics, including temperature, heart rate variability, energy levels, and VO2 Max. Circular has a dual PPG sensor in its ring combined with the Circular app that allows it to read heart signals and blood oxygen. It detects if the heart rate shows any signs of cardiac arrhythmia, and if the heart rhythm is steady. The data tracked is purported to be clinically accurate and can be shared with a professional for further advice. Wearing it both during the day and the night can help Circular to correlate the data using machine learning.Circular also seems to be extremely efficient while tracking sleep. It can tell a user how much time they spend in each sleep stage -- light sleep, deep sleep, REM sleep, and when they are lying awake. More importantly, it also calculates how efficiently a user has slept. The app shares data on a number of important criteria to examine sleep quality, including time taken to fall asleep, sleep debt, real sleep time, disturbances while sleeping, etc. It also provides silent vibrations to users in their light sleep stage if they wish to be awakened, without disturbing their surroundings.
Price and availability 
A single charge of the ring gives it four days of battery life. A single charge from 0% to 100% can be completed in one hour. Pre-orders, which will begin soon, will run until February 27, 202. The device will have a cost of 259 euros ($293) during that time. Starting February 28, the price will jump to 289 euros ($327). Shipping and other details are expected to be announced soon by the company.

Read more
The best light therapy lamps

Getting too little exposure to sunlight can result in low levels of vitamin D. In some individuals, a lack of sunlight can worsen symptoms of seasonal affective disorder (SAD).

Light therapy is an option worth looking into if you feel depressed or tired during the winter months. Using a light therapy lamp for a few minutes each day can boost your mood, make you more productive, and give you some energy. You can get all the benefits of light therapy by investing in a light therapy lamp.

Read more