US Marine Corps doesn’t want Google’s ‘Alpha Dog’ LS3 robots because they’re too loud

By Kelly Hodgkins December 29, 2015

marines cancel bigdog alphadog — Wikimedia Commons

After years of testing and evaluation, the United States Marine Corps has decided to defer the use of its Legged Squad Support System (LS3), also known as the AlphaDog robot. The quadruped soldier was developed by Google’s robotic arm Boston Dynamics along with DARPA and the Marine Corps Warfighting Lab. The two-and-a-half-year project cost $32 million.

The Marines initially were hopeful the LS3 robot would provide ground support for troops by carrying up to 400 pounds of gear, food, and other supplies. In 2014, the robot was featured in military exercises in the Pacific Rim, where the robot joined patrols, crossed rugged terrain, and responded to commands as intended.

Recommended Videos

Despite the early success, the Marines decided to shelve the robot because of its operational noise level, which was too high for comfort. “As Marines were using it, there was the challenge of seeing the potential possibility because of the limitations of the robot itself,” said Kyle Olson of the Warfighting Lab to Military.com. “They took it as it was: a loud robot that’s going to give away their position.”

To overcome the noise issue, Boston Dynamics introduced Spot, a smaller robot that is powered by a quieter electric-powered engine. Event though Spot solved the noise problem, it was less effective than the larger AlphaDog because its small frame could only carry 40 pounds and it lacked the autonomous technology that made the AlphaDog so successful.

Currently, both the Spot and the AlphaDog robots are in storage with no plans for deploying them in a military capacity. The Marine Corps’ Warfighting Lab has learned a great deal from the robot project and is not giving up on autonomous technology. The military lab will continue to develop drone and other unmanned technologies for use in medical supply and reconnaissance missions.

*An earlier version of this article mistakenly referred to the LS3 as the “BigDog” instead of the “Alpha Dog”. The article has since been amended to include the correct nickname.

Topics

Contributor

Kelly's been writing online for ten years, working at Gizmodo, TUAW, and BGR among others. Living near the White Mountains of…

Branded Content

Unitree Go2: Through the power of innovation you, too, can have a robot companion

Unitree Go2 robot companion with owner

How many of you can say you own an AI-powered robot companion to do your bidding? More specifically, an intelligent robot dog from the likes of Unitree. Probably not many of you, we'd wager, but there is an opportunity to change that. In the spirit of technical innovation and industrial leadership, Unitree has returned to its glorious bionic robotics roots -- please welcome the Unitree Go2. Available in three variants: Air, Pro, and Edu, the Go2 has been dubbed a "new creature of embodied AI." It's the next generation of the brand's innovative robotics, equipped with 4D LiDAR upgrades, an advanced AI mode, improved endurance and battery life, and a newly enhanced intelligent side-follow system with better positioning accuracy. What does it all mean, and what can it do? We'll get to that.

For now, know there's a 5% discount on the Go2 Pro with or without the controller when you use code UR5OFF at checkout. That saves you $140 on the Go2 Pro without a controller, bringing the price to $2,660. Or save $152 on the Go2 Pro with a controller, bringing the price down to $2,898. The controller allows you to operate and manually adjust the system without a phone. Meanwhile, you can use your phone and mobile app to interact with the Go2 Pro if you don't have a controller.

Cars

Toyota bets big on air taxis with $500M investment in Joby

Joby Aviation's electric aircraft flying in New York City in 2023.

Flying taxis, once the stuff of sci-fi movies, were widely expected to make a big splash by whizzing over the city of lights during festivities at the Paris Olympics last summer -- before getting scrapped due to certification concerns.

That isn’t stopping Toyota from pouring more money into air mobility.

Cars

The Tesla Supercharger network is expanding again

Teslas parked using the Tesla Superchargers.

EV owners worried about getting stranded before their next charge may breathe a bit easier now: The Tesla Supercharger network has resumed its expansion over the last three months, after massive layoffs at Tesla had led to a slide in new stalls earlier this year.Tesla opened 2,800 new Supercharger stalls globally during the three-month period ending September 30, an increase of 23% from the year earlier, according to the company’s official Tesla Charging account on X (formerly Twitter).Tesla also delivered 1.4 terawatt hours (TWh) of energy during the third quarter, which translates to 27% year-over-year growth. The Tesla Charging account said the amount of energy delivered enabled Tesla owners to save over 150 million gallons of gasoline, offsetting more than 3 billion pounds of CO2.According to the website Supercharge.info, which relies on user contributions to track the opening of new stalls, there were 2,677 Supercharger stations in North America at the end of September, 125 more than at the end of the third quarter.The additions of new stalls, however, comes in the wake of a 31% slide in the second quarter, after a massive round of firings at the company removed 500 employees from the Supercharger team in April.The third-quarter expansion should still go some ways to appease the concerns of Tesla and non-Tesla electric vehicle (EV) owners, as EV manufacturers are lining up in droves to be able to use the Supercharger network.In September, General Motors electric vehicles made by Chevrolet, GMC and Cadillac joined the growing list of vehicles to have adopted Tesla’s North American Charging Standard (NACS). The network already allows access, via adapters, to EVs made by Ford, Rivian, Honda and Volvo. The likes of Nissan, Hyundai, Toyota, BMW, Volkswagen, Volvo and Jaguar have also signed agreements to start allowing access in 2025.
The Tesla map of Superchargers across the U.S. reveals they are concentrated in major cities and across East-West transit corridors.According to Tesla, a Supercharger can add up to 200 miles of range in 15 minutes.