Electric bikes and scooters are here to save the world! But here’s the thing …

Depending on your point of view, electric bicycles and electric scooters are either blights on the streets of major cities or represent the salvation for metropolitan areas choked by traffic and smog. Battery powered e-bikes and e-scooters have flooded cities from Los Angeles to Tel Aviv, simultaneously delighting riders and aggravating city planners.

“I do think this is disruptive,” said William Riggs, a professor in the University of San Francisco’s School of Management who studies transportation, told Digital Trends. “It’s a hugely disruptive time in the era of transportation.”

Major companies are jumping on the trend: Ford purchased e-scooter company Spin. GM has designed its own e-bike. Uber acquired the e-bike rental firm Jump (possibly for more than $100 million!). And Lyft has started offering e-scooter rentals in Denver, Colorado; Santa Monica, California; and Washington, D.C. Major players in the e-wheeled world — Lime, Bird, and Skip — are proliferating like locusts, leaving cities — and all their smart city plans — struggling to adapt.

smart cities contend with benefits and headaches of e bikes scooters escooter feature 1
Les Shu/Digital Trends

In California, pedestrians complain that riders speed dangerously down sidewalks and tourists who rent the electric devices often dump them in places like the boardwalk along Venice Beach (where the scooters are technically not allowed). Anecdotally, hospital emergency rooms report an uptick in ER visits due to e-scooter accidents, and at least two Lime riders have died in recent accidents in Dallas and D.C.

Cities have taken a diversity of approaches to dealing with the e-wheeled phenomena. San Francisco, for example, banned e-scooters until it created a permit system for companies offering rentals; subsequently, Skip and Scoot won permits to operate in the City by the Bay. In Tel Aviv, where e-bikes and e-scooters have crowded city sidewalks and streets for a couple of years, there are new regulations coming that require helmets and licenses for electric bicycles.

Meanwhile, the governor of California recently enacted a law allowing adults to ride scooters without a helmet on roads with speed limits of up to 35 mph. And New York City, which started seeing extensive traffic in e-bikes about a year ago, has gone from identifying any kind of e-assist bike or scooter as illegal to allowing pedal-assist e-bikes (which require the rider to pedal at all times), but banning so-called throttle e-bikes (which can operate under battery power only and go faster, 20 to 28 mph). Enforcement, however, has been negligible.

“Not every place is like Manhattan or San Francisco,” Riggs said. “The physical infrastructure in a lot of these places is not ready for this disruption. So the question is, are we just throwing them out there in an environment that is unsafe for them.” Not to mention, unsafe for pedestrians and drivers.

smart cities contend with benefits and headaches of e bikes scooters escooter feature fullwide
Les Shu/Digital Trends

Bicycles and the three D’s

Of course, dealing with two-wheeled transportation is not a new issue. What’s new is the electrification of that transportation and the associated boost in speeds. Riggs said that as communities strive to create smart towns and cities some basic civil engineering principles should still apply in managing the e-wheeled trend.

“There are the three D’s: density, diversity, and design,” Riggs explained.

Traditional bicycle riders don’t want to share the pavement with zippier e-bikes and upstart e-scooters.

The adoption of this or any new form of transportation has to be supported by the urban density. Dockless solutions, for example, only work if there are enough riders to pick up the abandoned bikes and scooters. Sprawling Paris has struggled with e-bike docking systems, whereas the docking approach seems to have worked well in Manhattan.

Diversity has to do with understanding different types of riders and different uses for e-scooters and e-bikes. In Santa Monica, primarily tourists seem to be riding the gadgets — and to be oblivious to local laws and rules. In other places, people commuting to work seem to be the principle riders, with much more predictable routes and times.

smart cities contend with benefits and headaches of e bikes scooters jump bike san francisco les shu
Les Shu/Digital Trends

Once a city has answered the first two D’s, it can then tackle the third: designing a safe physical infrastructure to accommodate the new wheels. That isn’t always a simple matter, according to Riggs, especially in the United States. In places where there are special bike lanes, traditional bicycle riders don’t want to share the pavement with zippier e-bikes and upstart e-scooters.

“And we do have a culture of driving that is being disrupted,” Riggs said, since carving out more lanes to keep e-bikes and e-scooters off sidewalks means cutting into lanes previously left to cars. “So people that drive will experience more delays, and culturally, that’s unacceptable in the U.S.”

Where it’s working

There are places where e-bikes and e-scooters seem to be integrating with the city infrastructures successfully, primarily in the Netherlands and Germany. Part of the reason why is that there were already established thriving bicycle cultures in those places. So the smart city multimodal approach to transportation is not unfamiliar to people in Amsterdam and Berlin. But according to Riggs, the two European countries have taken quite different approaches to handling e-wheelers.

Smart cities need a public and private sector partnership where cities work with vendors and educate the public.

“In Germany, the perspective is pure modal separation,” he said. There are multi-use lanes, where e-bikes can travel, for example, and also so-called “Class 1” lanes where traditional bikes rule. This keeps all riders separate from each other and away from pedestrians, much in the same way the faster freeway traffic is completely separate from slower local automobile traffic.

The Dutch philosophy, as one might have guessed, is much more provocative, Riggs said. In the Netherlands, where children riding on the handlebars of their parent’s bicycles without a helmet is quite common, municipalities do not work to separate the different modes of transportation. Everyone — cyclists, e-cyclists, e-scooter riders, and pedestrians (and in some cases cars, as well) — operate in the same space. It’s based on the idea of an uncontrolled or “naked intersection” that has maximum interaction between different forms of transport and therefore maximum uncertainty. The theory is that in such uncertain situations people pay more attention and therefore there are fewer accidents.

But what’s good for the Dutch and Germans, probably isn’t good for Americans.

smart cities contend with benefits and headaches of e bikes scooters escooter feature 3

“Many places in the U.S. are way behind in terms of the physical side” of accommodating these different forms of transportation, Riggs said.

Smart cities need to take a smart approach to the seemingly inevitable influx of e-bikes and e-scooters. A key element of that is a public and private sector partnership approach where cities work with vendors — and educate the public at the same time. That means convincing hardcore cyclists that e-cyclists aren’t the enemy, and at same time teaching the e-riders how to adhere to the rules of the road and proper safety.

Most cities feel they got really burned by Uber and Lyft who rode into towns without any thought about how they would impact the environment, Riggs said. So there’s some reluctance on the part of municipalities to work with companies whose ethos is to disrupt current systems. But smart cities take a wider view now and consider how such changes will effect the whole infrastructure.

Ultimately, Riggs said, smarter towns will have to take a more multimodal view of their transportation systems. A recent study at his university found that places that just emphasized cycling and walking over other forms of transportation didn’t lead to better outcomes for their citizens. People who experienced the best health turned out to be those who lived in areas with the most number of transportation options, not just walking and biking. In other words, if you want your smarter city to improve the lives of its citizens, take everything in moderation, even transportation.


These are the best video games you shouldn't leave 2018 without

Developers showed up with a number of amazing games this year. Each capitalized on something unique but there's always one that outdoes them all. Here are our picks for the best video games of 2018 and game of the year.

5G’s arrival is transforming tech. Here’s everything you need to know to keep up

It has been years in the making, but 5G is finally becoming a reality. While 5G coverage is still extremely limited, expect to see it expand in 2019. Not sure what 5G even is? Here's everything you need to know.
Home Theater

What is Terrarium TV? Here’s everything you need to know

Terrarium TV offered a way to watch movies & TV for free, but now after a troubled existence, the app's developer has shut it down, and offered an ominous message to users on his way out.

Here are the best laptop deals for December 2018

Whether you need a new laptop for school or work or you're just doing some holiday shopping for a special someone, we've got you covered: These are the best laptop deals going right now, from discounted MacBooks to on-the-go gaming PCs.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Booze-filled ski poles and crypto piggy banks

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!
Emerging Tech

Bright ‘hyperactive’ comet should be visible in the sky this weekend

An unusual green comet, 46P/Wirtanen, will be visible in the night sky this month as it makes its closest approach to Earth in 20 years. It may even be possible to see the comet without a telescope.
Emerging Tech

Meet the MIT scientist who’s growing semi-sentient cyborg houseplants

Elowan is a cybernetic plant that can respond to its surroundings. Tethered by a few wires and silver electrodes, the plant-robot hybrid can move in response to bioelectrochemical signals that reflect the plant’s light demands.
Emerging Tech

Gorgeous images show storms and cloud formations in the atmosphere of Jupiter

NASA's Juno mission arrived at Jupiter in 2016 and has been collecting data since then. NASA has shared an update on the progress of the mission as it reaches its halfway point, releasing stunning images of the planet as seen from orbit.
Emerging Tech

Beautiful image of young planets sheds new light on planet formation

Researchers examining protoplanetary disks -- the belts of dust that eventually form planets -- have shared fascinating images of the planets from their survey, showing the various stages of planet formation.
Emerging Tech

Delivery robot goes up in flames while out and about in California

A small meal-delivery robot suddenly caught fire in Berkeley, California, on Friday. The blaze was quickly tackled and no one was hurt, but the incident is nevertheless a troubling one for the fledgling robot delivery industry.
Emerging Tech

High-tech dancing robot turns out to be a guy in a costume

A Russian TV audience was impressed recently by an adult-sized "robot" that could dance and talk. But when some people began pointing out that its actions were a bit odd, the truth emerged ... it was a fella in a robot suit.
Emerging Tech

MIT’s smart capsule could be used to release drugs in response to a fever

Researchers have developed a 3D-printed capsule which can monitor patients' vital signs, transmit this information to a connected device, and release drugs in response to symptoms.
Emerging Tech

‘Crop duster’ robot is helping reseed the Great Barrier Reef with coral

In a world first, an undersea robot has delivered microscopic coral larvae to the Great Barrier Reef. Meet Larvalbot: the robot "crop duster" which dispenses coral babies on troubled reefs.
Emerging Tech

Self-driving dirt rally vehicle offers crash course in autonomous car safety

Georgia Tech's AutoRally initiative pushes self-driving cars to their limit by getting scaled-down autonomous vehicles to drive really, really fast and aggressively on dirt roads. Here's why.