Super Mario Maker 2 hands-on preview

Super Mario Maker 2 lets you invite friends to your DIY torture castles

Super Mario Maker 2 has everything the game needs to break out of its niche
Super Mario Maker 2 has everything the game needs to break out of its niche
Super Mario Maker 2 has everything the game needs to break out of its niche


  • Local/Online Co-op and multiplayer bring group fun
  • Quality of life improvements to Course Builder
  • Story Mode offers a more casual player experience
  • Clear Conditions add more variety and challenge


  • Wait times on building in Story Mode feel like filler
  • Creating levels on Pro controller doesn't feel great

Super Mario Maker placed the tools of our favorite plumber into the hands of its players, and for the first time ever, gave us the power to create, play, and share our levels. It was a bold move for Nintendo, a company known for holding on tightly to its franchises as if they were little baby Yoshi. Nearly four years after passing Mario’s hammer to its players, Nintendo continues to reap the benefits.

Super Mario Maker retains a fanbase so loyal that Twitch and YouTube creators have made entire careers out of playing their viewers’ creations, often failing miserably at them, but still garnering hundreds of thousands of views. Knowing this, it makes sense we’re getting Super Mario Maker 2. With Story Mode, online and local multiplayer/co-op, and a more robust Course Maker, the sequel tries to broaden the game’s appeal while adding much-wanted features for hardcore fans.

Mario the Hustler

Mario may have ditched his plunger in exchange for an adventure abroad, but Story Mode in Super Mario Maker 2 sees him assume the role of a real hustler. Something terrible has happened to Peach’s castle and, of course, it’s up to Nintendo’s best boy to fix it.

You’re taken to a castle site where you’ll find Taskmaster Toad, Chief Toadette, and the Builder Toads all working on the restoration of the Princess’ castle. The problem is that in order to start rebuilding the castle, the Toads need some coin. Lots of it.

super mario maker 2 review smm2 20190528 006

It’s a premise that struck me as a bit strange. When Nintendo announced that there would be a Story Mode in Super Mario Maker 2, I thought it would be in a more traditional sense, with an overworld Mario could explore and themed levels that set the tone of the story.

Instead, you end up speaking with Taskmaster Toad, who will pull up a board where you’ll find a handful of “Jobs” to complete, each with its own difficulty level and reward. The difficulty is shown using a five-star rating system, with one star being the easiest and five being the hardest. Levels have no direct link to the story, it seems, which was disappointing. They come from strangers with generic names who will pay you to complete them.

Clear Conditions will up the ante as levels become more and more challenging.

The first few Jobs are simple, with a one-star difficulty and a mere 100-coin reward in exchange for completion. The term Jobs is just another word for levels, but the twist is that Super Mario Maker 2 introduces “Clear Conditions.” These are goals that make crossing the finish line in a level the bare minimum. Clear conditions can range from collecting a specific number of coins to killing a certain number of enemies.

This adds what Super Mario Maker 2’s Story Mode needs to keep Jobs interesting, and although I only played through the first few, I can see Clear Conditions upping the ante as levels become more and more challenging. Completion rewards for Jobs can only be collected once, which seems fair considering you can earn more coins by replaying the levels and picking them up the old-fashioned way.

Once you secure the number of coins needed to start the next step in rebuilding the castle, you’ll talk to Chief Toadette, who will take the money from you and start construction. Building a castle takes time, however, and Super Mario Maker 2 wants to make sure you know that. Near the construction site is a timer that uses hammer icons to indicate how long completion will take and how much time is left. Frustratingly, I couldn’t start the next part of the castle if something else was already in progress.

That made me wonder if there’s a potential for microtransactions in Super Mario Maker 2. While nothing shown in the demo indicated that, this is the kind of mechanic I often see in mobile games, like Nintendo’s own Animal Crossing: Pocket Camp or Bethesda’s Elder Scrolls: Blades. Those games time-gate progress that can be expedited with in-game currency you can buy with real money. It would be uncharacteristic of Nintendo to put microtransactions in its console games, so it’s possible this is just a quirky mechanic meant to lengthen the play time of Super Mario Maker 2’s Story Mode.

Worries of microtransactions aside, the demo we experienced didn’t show anything in the way of an actual story, or the expected structure of a single-player Mario game. While it’s obvious Nintendo wouldn’t want to spoil the intro, all I gathered was the basic premise and structure for Story Mode, which doesn’t feel much like a story at all.

Instead, the single-player mode feels more like a place where casual single players can play levels that aren’t going to have the same absurd difficulty as the ones you’re likely to find in Course World. A noble thing to include, for sure — but maybe give it another name.

Itsa Mario Party

Outside of Super Mario Maker’s Story Mode is the Course Maker and Course World hub. Many players will be familiar with these modes as they make a return from the first game, but this time around, they come bearing new features — and fans will be pleased.

The Course Maker in Super Mario Maker 2 is way easier to use. The overwhelming task of building a level feels much more feasible. The preset bar from Super Mario Maker now displays your most recently used items, which is nice, since I didn’t have to go searching for an item that I just used a few moments ago. You can also hold down on the item and let go to pin it to the bar. Selecting and hanging on an item will reveal all the available customization options for that piece, once again streamlining the creative process. These tweaks should make levels far quicker, and less frustrating, to build.

super mario maker 2 review smm2 20190528 001

Super Mario Maker 2 also replaces the stodgy old navigation with radial menus that display all possible items for each category, a change that is not only easy on the eyes, but far easier to navigate.

The Course Maker in Super Mario Maker 2 is more user-friendly.

Understanding Super Mario Maker 2 Course Creator takes time, especially with the transition to the Nintendo Switch. Creating levels on Switch in handheld mode is easier than on the Pro controller. It makes sense, as the original arrived on the Wii-U and Nintendo 3DS, two systems with handheld touchscreen controls.

There are quite a few more new features, many of which we saw during the Super Mario Maker 2 Nintendo Direct, including the Super Mario 3D game style, day/night mechanics, auto-scrolling, the addition of slopes, and Clear Conditions.

All about those clear conditions

Clear Conditions add an entirely new way to build levels. They’re divided into Actions like reaching the goal without taking damage, Parts like reaching the goal after defeating (x) number of Galoombas, or Status like reach the goal as Super Mario. Clear Conditions are going to be a hit with creators, who will no doubt use them to create clever level designs that feel entirely different from the normal Mario fare.

The biggest game-changer, though, is adding a second player to the creative process. This was alluded to during the intro of the Super Mario Maker 2 Nintendo Direct, where you see Luigi and Mario creating a level together. While I didn’t get to try this new feature out, I think it’s a wonderful way to introduce newcomers to the Course Creator by having someone more skilled at building guiding the way. It’s also a nice addition for parents who want to play with their kids.

super mario maker 2 review smm2 20190528 005

Co-op not only makes its way to the Course Maker, but also to the Course World hub. While you can still enjoy levels as a single player, you can invite up to four other players locally or online to participate. This raises the stakes significantly when you must work together to meet a Clear Condition for a level. During the demo, we spent the most time playing as a group, and it was the most enjoyable part of the entire event.

Four of us were dropped into a castle with a very simple goal: make it to the end. Trying to achieve that, however, was a delightful disaster. With a ton of complicated platforming that left little room for all of us to navigate, and the floor always covered with lava, we found ourselves dying more than we made progress. Luckily, one lone Mario was able to cross the finish line, earning us a win that most of us did not feel proud of. It was chaotic fun, and an experience I’m looking forward to having again.

Super Mario Maker 2 makes the shift from a niche level creator for players that want to be challenged to an experience that offers something for everyone. Yet hardcore fans should be pleased, because the Clear Conditions and other new features make devilish new challenges possible.

I was disappointed in Story Mode, which so far looks like the game’s weak point. Still, I came away with positive vibes. I honestly can’t wait to play it again – only this time, alongside my loved ones. I have a feeling that it will be an even bigger hit than its predecessor when it arrives for Nintendo Switch on June 28.

Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Plant-based shoes and a ukulele learning aid

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!

The best Nintendo Switch games, from Breath of the Wild to Rocket League

The Nintendo Switch's lineup started off small, but games have steadily released as the console continues through its second year. Here are the best Nintendo Switch games available now.
Home Theater

Don’t cash in that 401(k)! These are the best 4K TVs you can get for under $500

These days, you can land a pretty epic 4K TV for under $500. Still, sorting through the litany of options online can be both time-consuming and overwhelming. Check out our list of the best 4K TVs under $500.
Movies & TV

The best movies on Amazon Prime Video right now (June 2019)

Amazon Prime Video provides subscribers with access to a host of fantastic films, but sorting through the catalog can be a major undertaking. Luckily, we've done the work for you. Here are the best movies on Amazon Prime Video right now.
Home Theater

Diagnose and fix some common Apple AirPods problems with our handy guide

Apple’s AirPods are among the best fully wireless earbuds we’ve seen, but they’re not perfect. If you’re having trouble, take a look at our guide to the most common problems and what you can do to fix them.

Put down the controller and pick up the best phones for gaming on the go

Which phones are the best if all you want to do is play some mobile games? We've done the hard work and put together a list of the best gaming phones on Android and iOS, so you can keep playing and winning.

New Nintendo Switch models are reportedly already in production and coming soon

The rumored two new Nintendo Switch models have already reportedly entered production. Some of the components were moved out of China and into Southeast Asia, as Nintendo looks to limit the impact of proposed tariffs.

Square Enix has no clue how many episodes Final Fantasy VII Remake will take

The initial release of the Final Fantasy VII Remake on March 3, 2020 will feature the part of the adventure that takes place in Midgar. Square Enix has no idea on how many episodes it will take to tell the full story of the original RPG.

Nintendo 3DS nowhere to be seen at E3 2019, but apparently not yet dead

The Nintendo 3DS was missing at E3 2019, but it appears that support for the console will continue. No first-party games are planned for the device, but it offers a collection of titles that may still attract both old and new players.

Microsoft reportedly wanted Halo: The Master Chief Collection on PlayStation 4

Microsoft reportedly considered launching Halo: The Master Chief Collection on the PlayStation 4 a few years ago. It remains unclear if the desire for the Halo series to make a platform jump is still there ahead of Halo Infinite.

Why OLED gaming monitors may be further from reality than we thought

Earlier this year, Dell showed us the promise of an exciting new future for gaming monitors with the reveal of the Alienware 55-inch OLED gaming display. We loved it. But according to new reports, it may never see the light of day.

Walmart cuts $300 off Dell Inspiron 5680 gaming desktop for gamers on a budget

If you're stashing money but want an upgradeable rig that will go a long way, then this solid deal on the Dell Inspiron Gaming Desktop 5680 with Intel Core i5-8400 is for you. It is now available for only $700 at Walmart.

Walmart drops sweet $20 discount on the Sony PS4 DualShock 4 Controller

Walmart is offering a $20 discount on the Sony PlayStation 4 DualShock 4 Controller. New features include the touchpad, speaker, and light bar. It's also compatible with Windows-based PCs. This controller was originally priced at $60, but…

Check out Walmart’s steep discounts on Dell and LG gaming monitors

If you're a gamer looking for high-quality computer displays, you definitely need to take advantage of this deals from Dell and LG. These gaming monitors will fit your budget and your GPU.