Skip to main content

Top family-friendly Google Play Store apps track children’s personal data

Parents, check the apps and games your children use on Android mobile devices. Many of the top programs for kids may collect their personal information without parental permission.

Unfortunately, even with apps that offer privacy protection by resetting personal information, most still transmit non-resettable hardware information advertisers can use to identify users.

A large-scale study discovered that a majority of the most popular free children’s apps in the Google Play Store track information on kids under 13, and thus were potentially in violation of federal COPPA regulations.

COPPA, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC)’s Children’s Online Privacy Protection Rule, is directed at apps and services for children under 13. The COPPA laws were enacted to give parents control of any online entity that collects personally identifiable information (PII) from children. Collecting PII from children under 13 without explicit parental permission violates the law.

An international research team drawn from North American and European universities and organizations developed an automated analysis tool to evaluate app privacy behaviors. The team’s methodology examines how and how often applications access the types of information protected by the laws. In addition, the group used a network monitoring tool to determine when apps accessed private data and where that data was sent.

The team’s analytical tool found all the free mobile apps on the Google Play Store from November 2016 through March 2018. Part of the research procedure included checking for new versions and releases. In all the team scraped more than 80,000 apps, but not all were subject to COPPA regulations, which narrowed the field.

The group focused on 5,855 children’s apps developers and publishers placed under Google Play’s Designated for Families (DFF) program. Any app in the DFF program indicates the developer represented to Google that the game is designed for children under 13, the developer received COPPA compliance guidance, and the app does not violate COPPA regulations.

The 5,855 apps were in 63 different Play Store categories — 60 percent in the Casual Games, Brain Games, and Educational Games categories.

The study found that the majority of apps potentially violated COPPA rules – most often because they used software development tools (SDKs) not in alignment with required practices. Most apps didn’t correctly offer or implement options to disable personal data tracking. The team found 19 percent of the apps collected information specifically prohibited by COPPA.

Even among the 3,454 apps that allowed users to reset their IDs, 66 percent transmitted identifiable non-resettable information. For example, while users could reset email address, phone number, and GPS location, two-thirds of the apps still sent advertisers Wi-Fi addresses, SIM card IDs, and Android Advertising IDs (AAIDs).

The study concludes that regulators could benefit from automated tools to check COPPA compliance. Because industry self-regulation hasn’t proved effective, the study argues, outside monitoring is essential.

Editors' Recommendations

Bruce Brown
Digital Trends Contributing Editor Bruce Brown is a member of the Smart Homes and Commerce teams. Bruce uses smart devices…
Google drops developer fees in the Play Store to as low as 10%
Google Play Store.

Google today announced new moves to make selling on the Play Store more attractive to developers. Currently, the company charges 30% for all subscription sales, then drops it to 15% after a year. Starting in 2022, developers will now be charged 15% on payments from the first day, while Google also moves to reduce fees for apps registered under the Play Media Experience Program to 10%.

"Digital subscriptions have become one of the fastest-growing models for developers, but we know that subscription businesses face specific challenges in customer acquisition and retention. We’ve worked with our partners in dating, fitness, education and other sectors to understand the nuances of their businesses," Google's Sameer Samat, vice president of product management, explained in an announcement. "Our current service fee drops from 30% to 15% after 12 months of a recurring subscription. But we’ve heard that customer churn makes it challenging for subscription businesses to benefit from that reduced rate. So, we’re simplifying things to ensure they can."

Read more
Apple and Google are going to need to open up their app stores in South Korea
The Apple logo is displayed at the Apple Store June 17, 2015 on Fifth Avenue in New York City

Apple and Google will now be mandated to allow for alternate payment systems for apps in the App Store and Play Store, respectively, at least in South Korea. The move comes as part of an amendment to the Telecommunications Business Act that bars companies from forcing third-party developers to use their in-app payment systems for in-app purchases. It will also require app store operators to speedily approve apps and prevent them from deleting apps from the stores without a reasonable explanation, the Wall Street Journal reports.

Apple and Google's app store practices have come under scrutiny over the past few years. In addition to rules around what content may or may not be admitted, developers have increasingly expressed ire about the standardized 30% commission required for each in-app transaction. This comes as a result of both companies mandating the use of their respective billing systems, with exceptions being made to select types of apps (food delivery services, for example.)

Read more
Google made $8.5 billion in gross profit off the Play app store in 2019
A MacBook with Google Chrome loaded.

A court filing that was unsealed on Saturday shows that Alphabet Inc's Google Play store generated $11.2 billion in revenue -- and $8.5 billion in gross profit -- from app sales, in-app purchases, and app store ads over the course of 2019. The story, initially broken by Paresh Dave at Reuters, is a rare glimpse into the actual numbers behind Google's app store.

Typically, Google will group up the Play store's financial results with some other service in its earnings report, which effectively obfuscates the store's numbers. For example, Play is not mentioned by name at all in Google's numbers for the second quarter of 2021. This isn't illegal or even particularly unusual for a tech company, but it also means there hasn't been any reliable way for anyone outside Google itself to get an idea of just how lucrative the Play Store actually is until now.

Read more