Skip to main content

Lenovo’s leaked Legion Play cloud gaming console is a flawed idea

Lenovo is making its own video game system, according to a recent leak. Images of a handheld called the Lenovo Legion Play appeared in the source code of the manufacturer’s Mobile World Congress 2021 website.

The system, discovered by Lilputing, is described as “the first Android cloud gaming console.” It looks a bit like the Nintendo Switch, with a standard-layout ABXY attached to a 7-inch FHD display. The website source code mentions a few other specs too, like HDR 10, dual speakers, and a 700mAh battery. The console would supposedly play cloud games, allowing players to stream their PC games to the device.

A leaked image of the Lenovo Legion Play.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

It’s an impressive piece of tech on paper, but that last part gives me pause. The idea of a “cloud gaming console” is, simply put, absurd.

Cloud gaming is still relatively new territory in video games. The service allows players to stream powerful AAA games to devices that normally couldn’t run them. Microsoft’s cloud service lets players enjoy titles like Gears 5 on a phone. Google Stadia allows players to stream a game like Cyberpunk 2077 on their potato of a PC, a feat that would normally be impossible. Even Nintendo utilizes cloud services now, with games like Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy coming to the system via streaming.

The entire appeal of Cloud gaming is that players don’t need to buy a $500 console or build an expensive PC to run the highest-end games. Instead, they can play them with the devices they already own. That’s where the very concept of the Lenovo Legion Play, and cloud gaming consoles in general, starts to fall apart. Why would you buy an expensive device to do what your phone does? It defeats the entire purpose.

A leaked image of the Lenovo Legion Play's screen.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

There’s a more inherent flaw in the concept of a portable console built for this purpose: Cloud gaming requires a constant internet connection. That means you’ll need fast and stable internet at all times when streaming a game. The entire appeal of a portable device is that you can take it on the go. But at present, that’s not possible with Cloud gaming. Were something like a Legion Play to exist, players would need to sit in their homes connected to Wi-Fi to play. It’d be a fun device to take on vacation, but you wouldn’t be able to play it on your morning train commute.

The puzzling leak underscores the current trouble with Cloud gaming and why it has been so slow to take off. In theory, a service like Google Stadia should be wildly popular as it makes games more accessible. But the technology is one built on limitations that early experiments have yet to fix. The need for stable internet severely limits how players can actually enjoy games. We’re simply not at a point where taking a AAA game on the go is possible, regardless of how impressive the device running it is. That makes devices like the upcoming Steam Deck, which is essentially a handheld PC, more appealing.

It’s worth noting that the Lenovo Legion Play was never officially revealed. Despite appearing on the company’s MWC website, it didn’t debut at the event. Perhaps the Legion Play was just a proof of concept that still needed work. Or maybe we’ll see it pop up at an event like CES. If it does eventually appear, hopefully, there’s more than meets the eye here. As it stands, the entire premise of a “Cloud gaming console” is fundamentally flawed, so Lenovo would need to have a tight elevator pitch ready to make it seem like a viable option.

Editors' Recommendations

Giovanni Colantonio
Giovanni is a writer and video producer focusing on happenings in the video game industry. He has contributed stories to…
The Steam Deck and Nintendo Switch had a baby, and it’s Lenovo’s Legion Go
A Lenovo Legion Gop sits on a pink backdrop.

The race is on. After Valve released its popular Steam Deck last year, hardware manufacturers have rushed to put out their own portable PCs. We already have a viable rival in the Asus ROG Ally from this year, and there are plenty of offbeat options like the Ayaneo 2S out there, but now Lenovo is joining the scene with the Legion Go.

At first glance, the Legion Go might just look like your standard portable PC. It’s a hefty Windows handheld packed with some impressive specs. Look closer, though, and you’ll find that Lenovo is bringing some genuine innovation to the table. With detachable controllers, a kickstand, an innovative “mouse mode,” and more, the Legion Go sets itself apart from its competitors in plenty of ways. But is it worth plopping down $700 this October for yet another portable gaming device?

Read more
PlayStation Portal misunderstands remote play and cloud gaming’s appeal
A PlayStation Portal boots up.

Sony finally revealed more details about its upcoming handheld, now called PlayStation Portal, but these announcements have soured my opinion on the device rather than hyped me up for it. I enjoy cloud gaming and have used a variety of services like Google Stadia, Amazon Luna, and Xbox Cloud Gaming - across my phone and even dedicated devices like the Logitech G Cloud Gaming Handheld. Because of that, I was really excited to see what PlayStation could do as it entered the space. Unfortunately, some specific exclusions from PlayStation Portal's functionality that make it more of a remote-play device rather than a cloud gaming handheld indicate that Sony has a fundamental misunderstanding about what people would want out of a PlayStation game streaming handheld.

Namely, the device's positioning as primarily a "remote play dedicated device" and the exclusion of PlayStation Plus Premium cloud gaming compatibility drastically shrinks the number of reasons people should pick the device up. Cloud gaming and devices built around it have been around long enough to show that an inclusive approach to the number of services, games, and kinds of game streaming available is vital to success, and for a $200 handheld, PlayStation Portal seems like it's excluding way too much.
Narrowing its appeal
Remote play differs from what's more ubiquitously referred to as cloud gaming players are running the games on their own consoles rather than a third-party console or server. Still, it's a form of streaming games over a Wi-Fi connection, typically through an app on a phone or device like the Logitech G Cloud Gaming Handheld. That means you'll have to stick around your own home to use the PlayStation Portal, and its game library is limited to whatever the user owns on the console. That's limiting (it's like if Steam Deck only ran Steam Link) but does have some use cases. Still, it doesn't necessarily feel like it warrants a dedicated $200 device over a phone and a nice mobile controller like the Razer Kishi V2 or Backbone One - PlayStation Edition; haptic feedback and adaptive triggers only go so far.

Read more
Sony’s cloud handheld, the PlayStation Portal, will only stream certain games
Astro's Playroom booting up on the PlayStation Portal.

Sony has unveiled the price for its upcoming cloud gaming handheld, as well as an official name for the device: PlayStation Portal. However, one significant caveat to its functionality might sour people's interest in the handheld: It only supports PS4 and PS5 native games that the owner purchased.
PlayStation VR2 games can't be streamed to PlayStation Portal, which does make sense. More bafflingly, though, is the fact that the PlayStation Blog post states that "games that are streamed through PlayStation Plus Premium’s cloud streaming are not supported." That means you shouldn't pick up PlayStation Portal expecting to stream some PS3 and PS4 games available through PlayStation Plus Premium to the device. That's certainly an odd omission when it's currently PlayStation's most notable cloud gaming effort.
Although Microsoft is more closely associated with cloud gaming, Sony beat it to releasing a dedicated cloud gaming device. PlayStation Portal was first teased as Project Q during May's PlayStation showcase, but now, a PlayStation Blog post more clearly explains what we can actually expect from the handheld. Most importantly, we learned that PlayStation Portal will cost $200, which puts it underneath the cost of a Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series S, and other cloud gaming devices like the Logitech G Cloud Handheld.
As for what you're getting for that price tag, it's essentially a decent screen attached to two halves of a DualSense controller. The controllers on each side share all the functionality of the DualSense, including things like haptic feedback and adaptive triggers. In-between is an 8-inch LCD screen that streams games over Wi-Fi at up to a 1080p resolution and 60 frames per second. All in all, that's fairly solid for a cloud gaming handheld that is this cheap.
Sony confirmed that the PlayStation Portal will have a 3.5mm audio jack, but also used the same blog post to unveil two new wireless audio options. There's the Pulse Elite wireless headset that features a retractable boom mic and a charging hanger and Pulse Explore wireless earbuds that offer similar audio quality in earbud form.
None of these products are available for preorder or have a specific release date just yet, but they are all expected to launch before the end of the year.

Read more