Skip to main content

Modern-day morality tale or action flick? RoboCop’s remake can’t decide

Paul Verhoeven’s RoboCop has endured for nearly 27 years because it was more than just an action flick. Yes, it was the story of a man melded into a machine, but its subversive satire and deep moral themes tapped into primal fears of the time. Director Jose Padilha’s remake does almost the opposite. It too raises big questions that haunt us, but those themes are merely a veneer for a Hollywood action movie about a man coming into his own and battling to reassert his individuality. 

Again and again, this remake hints at something grander, deeper, and smarter, but ultimately it abandons any meaningful goals. Ethically intriguing characters fall into good-guy bad-guy patterns by the end, and any question of morality is settled down the barrel of a gun. The remake manages to stand on its own as a well-paced action flick, but there are missed opportunities everywhere.

Like the original, Verhoeven’s RoboCop focuses on a Detroit police detective who is badly injured in an attack meant to kill him. To score a PG-13 rating, the details of his near-demise have changed to skirt the ultra-violence that defined the original. Rather than repeating the bloody and gruesome mutilation seen in the 1987 version, Padilha shows Detective Alex Murphy (played by The Killing’s Joel Kinnaman) get severely injured in a car bombing and wake up to find that he has become an experiment in law keeping. 

By the third act, all hints of a deeper movie have been abandoned.

The near-future setting is framed by a raging debate in America over the use of robotic automatons as peacekeepers. On one side, voices like OmniCorp CEO Raymond Sellars (Michael Keaton) and agenda-driven TV pundit Pat Novak (Samuel L. Jackson) assert that robotic soldiers in the battlefield save American lives. On the other side, politicians like Senator Dreyfuss (Zach Grenier) argue that a robot can’t distinguish between right and wrong. Murphy – or what’s left of him – becomes an unwitting pawn in this debate, and a bridge between the two.

Utilizing the best technology, Detective Murphy is rebuilt as RoboCop under the watchful eye of Dr. Dennett Norton (Gary Oldman). Following his re-introduction to the world, he tries to reconnect with his wife Clara (Abbie Cornish) and their son, while also trying to solve his own attempted murder. 

Is it moral to use robots in war? Can we trust a machine to make a judgment call? Both are good questions that plague us today as the use of drone strikes edges further into our collective moral fiber. But after the film raises the questions, it fails to give us any answers.

Like the original, RoboCop questions unchecked capitalism and corporate greed defining public policies, but this is also forgotten once the shooting starts. Rather than forcing the audience to weigh the arguments, heroes and villains are defined solely through their attempts to save a life or end one. Any nuance is blasted to tatters in the ensuing firefights, and the bigger ideals the movie hints at disappear with it. The question of free will crops up in heavy handed ways as well, but this too becomes more of a plot point than an actual theme.


While the film’s philosophical questions end up shelved, Alex’s attempts to reconnect with his family continue, unfortunately. To her credit, Cornish manages to take a one-dimensional wife and breathe some life into her, despite a script that never bothers to really develop her. Without any emotional weight to them, both Alex’s wife and son become little more than plot devices.

The film only really works when it embraces what RoboCop is meant to be: a high-tech member of law enforcement. But even this angle is underdeveloped, and the film shows only a few glimpses of this before returning to its main narrative. For an action movie, there is a surprising lack of action. 

By the third act, all hints of a deeper movie have been abandoned. Bland villains mute any emotional payoffs from Alex’s quest for justice. And the finale works for a Hollywood movie, but would be incredibly messy and complicated in real life. 

RoboCop saves itself with strong performances, which are almost without exception excellent. Kinnaman is especially noteworthy as the emotion-challenged Murphy. The visual effects are also frighteningly plausible – not just the giant ED-209 battle robots, but also smaller details found in the film’s holographic computers and bionic arms. It’s a few years off, but the film does a good job of remaining grounded in reality, constantly teasing new technology that may not be available yet, but could hit the streets in our lifetimes. 


RoboCop is well shot and visually attractive, the cast all turn in good performances, and the pacing keeps things moving at a nice clip. But it could have been so much more. It becomes a predictable story, and loses the edge it starts out with. For a film that ultimately is about the nature of life, RoboCop is sadly devoid of any real spark. 

Editors' Recommendations

Ryan Fleming
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Fleming is the Gaming and Cinema Editor for Digital Trends. He joined the DT staff in 2009 after spending time covering…
How to use emotes in Diablo 4
Diablo 4 promotional image of Lillith

Diablo 4 is no doubt a dark and sinister game full of death and destruction – but that shouldn't stop you from wanting to be in touch with your emotions. When you're ready to share how you're feeling or want to convey a need to a fellow player, you'll want to use the game's emote system. We'll tell you how it all works below and give you some tips for how to make the most of this mechanic.
How to use emotes in Diablo 4
You can bring up the emote wheel by pressing E on your keyboard or Up on the D-pad of a controller, at which point you can select which emote you'd like to perform from a pre-selected group. If you'd like to change the emotes on your wheel, though, you can select Customize, then choose one from the currently unapplied emotes and place it wherever you'd like for future use.

Some very helpful emotes to keep on your wheel include "Help", "Yes", "Thanks", and "Wave", as these are easy ways to show a general sense of friendliness to your fellow demon slayers. Of course, if you're in the mood to be a bit more antagonistic – particularly in PVP – you can always use "Taunt" to give folks a hard time.

Read more
Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater: release date speculation, developer, trailers, and more
Snake stares into the distance in Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater's reveal trailer

Kept you waiting, huh? That's right, Snake is back and looking better than ever. Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater is a project that was rumored for months, if not years, before being officially announced recently. This remake of the hit PS2 title, and third mainline entry in the Metal Gear Solid franchise, is often considered the best by fans and critics alike. However, with the departure of series creator Hideo Kojima from Konami, the idea of a remake being handled by a different team was met with skepticism. It seems that Konami is confident enough in the project, so we'll just have to wait until we get our hands on it to see how the final product shakes out. Oh, what a thrill to see everything we know about Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater.
Release window

There is no release date, or even a window, as of now for Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater. The reveal trailer only states that the game exists.
Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater is currently confirmed for all current-gen systems, including PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, and PC via Steam.

Read more
How to respec skills in Diablo 4
DIABLO 4 Rogue Campfire

Discovering and perfecting the build you want for your character is basically the whole point of Diablo 4, and it can take quite a lot of time and effort to nail down all of the specifics. As such, you're likely to want to mess around with a wide variety of skills in an effort to figure out what works best for you and your endgame goals. Luckily, Diablo 4 makes this pretty easy, allowing you to respec more or less whenever you'd like and as often as you'd like – provided you've got the coin available to do so. Let's take a look at how to respec your character.
How to respec in Diablo 4
Diablo 4 makes it extremely simple to respec your character's skills, meaning you can play around with various playstyles on the fly. Simply head into your skill tree, then press Square (PlayStation), X (Xbox), or right-click (PC) to prompt a full reset.

Alternatively, you can head to a single skill you'd like to remove a point from and hold down the corresponding button to refund one point at a time from that skill.

Read more