Skip to main content

Zynga facing possible mass staff exodus following IPO

If the reports are to be believed and the long expected Zynga IPO does soon happen, the company may then be faced with a mass exodus of staff that are planning to cash out then seek better working conditions.

The San Francisco-based start-up Zynga has been at the forefront of the growing casual and mobile gaming craze, and has produced four of Facebook’s top five most used game applications. The company currently has over 200 million monthly users on the social network, and is estimated to be worth between $15 and $20 billion, so it was no surprise when the developer filed with the SEC on July 1.

Since then, the IPO process has met with numerous delays, but none of them are particularly serious, and Zynga is expected to release a date and price in the next week or two. It should prove to be a very Merry Christmas for CEO Mark Pincus and the Zynga staff, followed by what may be a difficult new year.

According to a report from the NY Times, several of the employees at Zynga are not happy with the working conditions, and may be planning a mass exodus as soon as they can cash out their stock following the IPO. That may seem like a risky move in these financially wacky times, but Zynga employees are highly respected in the development community, and most should have little trouble landing elsewhere. Earlier this month, a recruiting firm even sent around 150 cookie baskets to employees, and others are likely envying the move.

“I expect a lot of game and tech companies will begin recruiting Zynga’s talent after their equity becomes liquid,” Gabrielle Toledano, head of human resources for Electronic Arts told the Times. “Competitors will make the case that they offer much more compelling opportunities for creative people.”

The working conditions at Zynga are no secret to those in the industry, and its reputation is already a source of concern. Earlier this year, Zynga offered $950 million in cash for mobile game developer PopCap, but the company’s founders were concerned with what they had heard about Zynga’s internal workings. PopCap then went on to accept less guaranteed money ($750 million in cash and stock) from EA, as well as potential bonuses for goals met.

Rovio, the maker of the ridiculously successful Angry Birds game, also decided to end negotiations with Zynga, despite a potential deal worth nearly $2.25 billion in cash and stock.

“Zynga should be an example of entrepreneurship at its best,” Roger McNamee, a co-founder of the venture capital firm Elevation Partners said. “Instead it’s going to be a Harvard Business School case study on founder overreach — this will be a cautionary tale.”

According to employees and executives speaking off the record, Zynga is broken up into several departments based on the game each group is working on, and the executive staff nurtures fierce competition both between the groups and within each department. It has been described as a “messy and ruthless war.”

Each week, managers for each department submit reports based on how the game is being received by the public. If the game begins to lose traffic, the managers then turn on the team and force longer working hours while going through the minutia of each employee’s time spent. If a particular employee is falling behind, they will immediately be demoted or fired.

While that might not sound out of the ordinary, Zynga places a heavy focus on its employees’ metrics. Aggressive deadlines are common, as are constant threats from the executive staff. When the employees do well, they are treated like royalty, receiving gifts like vacations and additional stock. If they do poorly, they can lose part of their equity packages and be offered a smaller salary—or the door.

“If I was egregiously failing, then maybe it would be O.K.,” said one former senior employee, who left after being asked to give back some equity. But “it seemed systematically driven.”

Earlier today Venture Beat published the findings from Glass Door, a career services firm that interviews employees and asks them to rate their CEO. On average, CEOs have an approval rating of around 62-percent. Pincus was given a fairly troubling 46-percent, and Zynga as a whole was given a workplace satisfaction rating of 2.6 out of five.  The criticisms ranged from poor hiring practices to overworking employees. 

Last month, more than 1,600 employees responded to a quarterly staff survey with criticisms and complaints. Pincus then read through a few of the choice comments at a meeting a few days later and indicated that changes would be forthcoming, although no specifics were given. To further cast a shadow on the company’s growing image problem, earlier this year it came out that Pincus and several of the Zynga executives were issuing ultimatums to employees: surrender some of their stock or be fired. Pincus dismissed the accusations as “based on hearsay and innuendo.”

In what appears to be somewhat suspicious timing, earlier this month Zynga’s Chief Business Officer, Owen Van Natta, resigned without explanation. His sudden and ill-timed departure means that he will miss out on the IPO payday as a full-time employee, but due to an older Zynga clause, he will still receive the benefits from stock he was given when he was first hired. 

Reports of long hours and demanding working schedules aren’t uncommon these days–especially in the gaming industry–but it could come back to hurt the developer. Zynga is currently the leader in casual and browser-based gaming, but it is facing growing competition. Even now its competitors are likely just as excited by the prospect of Zynga’s IPO as the shareholders are, because it will mean employees can cash out and have very little reason to stay at Zynga. If another company swoops in and offers someone a better work environment, there is very little to keep them from leaving. Zynga is also in the midst of further expansion, and it has two new games on the way, but the possibility of greener pastures following a decent payday from the IPO could cost the developer some crucial employees.

“We’ve learned that when companies treat talent as a commodity, the consequences are severe,” Toledano said. “It takes years to repair a reputation.”

Editors' Recommendations

Ryan Fleming
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Fleming is the Gaming and Cinema Editor for Digital Trends. He joined the DT staff in 2009 after spending time covering…
NYT Connections today: answers and hints for Monday, December 4
New York Times Connection game logo.

Connections is the latest puzzle game from the New York Times. The game tasks you with categorizing a pool of 16 words into four secret (for now) groups by figuring out how the words relate to each other. The puzzle resets every night at midnight and each new puzzle has a varying degree of difficulty. Just like Wordle, you can keep track of your winning streak and compare your scores with friends.

Some days are trickier than others. If you're having a little trouble solving today's Connections puzzle, check out our tips and hints below. And if you still can't get it, we'll tell you today's answers at the very end.
How to play Connections
In Connections, you'll be shown a grid containing 16 words — your objective is to organize these words into four sets of four by identifying the connections that link them. These sets could encompass concepts like titles of video game franchises, book series sequels, shades of red, names of chain restaurants, etc.

Read more
Where to get Grapple Blades in Fortnite and how they work
grapple blade

With each new season of Fortnite, you can count on there being at least some sort of mobility item added that helps you quickly move across the map in a unique and exciting way. With the arrival of chapter 5, season 1, players can now seek out and equip the brand-new Grapple Blade item. If you want all of the mobility of a Web-Slinger with the damage output of a Kinetic Blade, you'll want to pick one of these up. Here's where to find them and how they work.
Where to get Grapple Blades and how they work
Grapple Blades can be found on the ground and in chests all across this season's map. Keep in mind, however, that they're relatively rare, meaning it's sometimes possible to go entire matches without seeing one. Of course, that's just a good incentive to track down and defeat your opponents to see if they leave one behind.

When this hybrid mobility and damage item is equipped, you'll notice that it shows a cursor on surfaces you can grapple to. Doing so will send you propelling toward the surface pretty quickly, making it a great choice for escaping a firefight or finding high ground in the midst of one. But before you get carried away, it's worth noting that you only have four charges at a time with a Grapple Blade, though it will recharge one at a time every 12 seconds.

Read more
Where to get Ballistic Shields in Fortnite and how they work
ballistic shield

You can always count on Epic to find new and exciting ways to keep Fortnite feeling fresh all these years later. Chapter 5, season 1 has kept up that trend with a variety of thrilling items that change up the meta a lot, including the Ballistic Shield, which may be the best personal defensive item ever added to the game. Here's where to find them and how they work.
Where to get Ballistic Shields and how they work
Ballistic Shields can be found on the ground or in chests all across the map. Even so, it's quite a rare item, so you could spend a match or two without seeing one unless you track down and take out your foes – which you'll presumably be doing anyway.

The Ballistic Shield may be one of the new season's most powerful and noteworthy new items, as it offers some substantial defensive possibilities that can really come in handy during firefights. By equipping and holding it up, you'll gain a significant amount of protection for your body while being granted a pistol that you can use to shoot your foes. While the shield can be temporarily disabled after taking enough hits, it absorbs quite a lot of bullets that would otherwise be going into you.

Read more