Skip to main content

Appeal Finds Cablevision Remote DVR Legal

Appeal Finds Cablevision Remote DVR Legal

Almost a year and a half ago, Cablevision lost a copyright suit brought by content owners over “remote DVR” service. The basic idea behind remote DVR service is to take hard drive-based video recorders out of cable subscribers’ homes and instead let them set up their recording preferences and store their preferred shows on servers managed by the cable provider. When users want to watch recorded video, it streams to the user’s residence just like any other on-demand programming.

From the point of view of cable providers, remote DVR capabilities make sense: DVR systems can be managed directly in a proper data center, instead of distributed through living rooms and dens in their service area. Fixing a DVR system means sending a tech to swap out a rack unit, rather than rolling a truck out to a subscribers’ residence.

Recommended Videos

Content providers sued Cablevision over the system, claiming that storing the video content remotely and re-streaming it to subscribers amounted making an illegal copy of their content and retransmitting the the data; re-transmission would violate the licenses cable companies had to distribute the content in the first place. They also complained the service stored their content in an temporary buffer, also in violation of Cablevision’s license and copyright.

However, Cablevision appealed the decision…and the appeal has paid off in a big way. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the lower court’s summary judgement an injunction on the remote DVR service (PDF), finding that the temporary buffers used by the Cablevision system were transitory and therefore did not infringe. The court also ruled that, since recordings are made at the direction of subscribers in advance of broadcast, therefore the subscribers really do the copying, rather than Cablevision, even though the cable company owns and maintains the systems. The appeals court also ruled that re-streamed recorded content did not violate copyright because the re-transmission was intended for the subscriber rather than a public performance, and thus doesn’t violate the Copyright Act.

Although content providers may continue the battle in court, the ruling appears to clear the way for Cablevision (and other cable operators) to build remote DVR systems and offer the service to subscribers. (Comcast is known to have been working on a such a service.) Remote DVR capability may be less expensive for subscribers than DVRs supplied by a cable operator, since the cable company will be able to manage the resources (and their software) more efficiently; however, by storing recording schedules and programming on cable operator servers, remote DVR services may also raise privacy concerns, particularly if recording choices or programming information for subscribers were compromised.

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
The latest Amazon Echo Buds 2 with ANC are a huge 61% off right now
Amazon Echo Buds 2 in charging case.

Despite their best efforts with Fire TV devices, Kindles, and the surprisingly good Amazon Basics line, it is somewhat difficult to remember that Amazon is more than a retailer — that they're also a producer of products themself. This deal — which takes the $140 Amazon Echo Buds 2, drops the price by 61% (a discount of $85), and sells them for just $55 — really reminds you that Amazon is alive and well as a producer. Tap the button below to check out this neat headphones deal yourself or keep reading to see our take.

Why you should buy the Amazon Echo Buds 2

Read more
Buy your dad an Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K, get it by Father’s Day, and save 40%
The newest version of the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K has WiFi 6.

Not every Father's Day gift has to be something new, big, and exciting. If your dad's idea of the best TV ever is the one he already has, but you all know it could use a boost, then you should take a look at this great offer on the latest version of the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K. Usually $50, you can save 40% and get one for just $30 at this time (that's a savings of $20). As of June 12, Amazon says the TV upgrade will arrive two days before Father's Day if you use the fastest shipping (available free with your Amazon Prime free trial). That means I could order it as late as July 14 and get the device on Father's Day. Your particular situation could vary, so tap the button below and check out the info for yourself. Otherwise, keep reading to see all the details and figure out if the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K is a good gift for Dad (or yourself).

Why you should buy the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K

Read more
At $120 off, the most comfortable noise-canceling headphones are now at a comfortable price
Sonos Ace with a Sonos Arc.

One of the best things about wearing noise-canceling headphones is the great deal of comfort they bring when in loud, chaotic environments. However, they need to really fit around your head to get that seal, which can lead to some comfort issues. If you're the type that wants to float away into your music or studies, then the Sonos Ace are your absolute best bet, and they are the headphones we consider to be the overall best noise-canceling headphones for comfort. Unfortunately, they're usually $449, the same price as the brand new Sony WH-1000XM6. Now, however, in a deal you can find at any major retailer, they're discounted by $120, making them just $329. Tap the appropriate button below to make your purchase or keep reading to see just how comfortable the Sonos Ace are, and learn about the special link they have with the best soundbar Sonos makes.

Why you should buy the Sonos Ace

Read more