Skip to main content

Webcasters’ Royalty Rate Appeal Denied


Webcaster’s Royalty Rate Appeal Denied Hundreds of U.S.-based net radio station may go silent Monday, as an appeals court denies a motion to delay the onset of new, significantly higher royalty rates.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia circuit has denied a motion to postpone the implementation of new music royalty rates to be levied on U.S.-based Webcasters and online radio stations. In a brief statement, the court denied the appeal, saying the objections raised by webcasters did not meet the "stringent standard" required of an appeal. The denial shoots down Webcasters’ best hope of avoiding a controversial music royalty rate hike enacted by the Copyright Royalty Board in March of 2007; many Internet broadcasters have complained the new royalty rates are onerous and will immediately put them out of business if enacted.

The new music royalty structure enacted by the Copyright Royalty Board imposes a flat-fee per-song royalty structure on music streamed over the Internet, along with a $500-per-channel fee. The new rates will also be imposed retroactively going back to January 2006, and are scheduled to double at the beginning of 2011. The new rates essentially triple the royalty amounts Internet broadcasters would be forced to pay; Internet broadcasters have characterized the new rates as "irrationally high" and say they will be forced out of business by the new regime.

Under the existing royalty agreement, online broadcasters pay an annual fee and 12 percent of their profits to SoundExchange, a music industry organization established to collect royalties from broadcasters. (SoundExchange represents most acts on major labels, but literally tens of thousands of artists whose work is broadcast via the Internet and elsewhere aren’t represented by SoundExchange, or never receive royalties allegedly collected on their behalf by the organization.) SoundExchange has offered to temporarily cap royalty payments and delay the new rates for "small" online broadcasters, but both options were essentially greeted by broadcasters as a "stay of execution."

The music industry has considered the current royalty regime something of a "discount" to jump-start an online broadcasting business, and feels online broadcasters have had more than enough time to build successful operations. Now, they argue, it’s time for online radio to begin paying "real" royalty rates. The industry argues these royalties reflect fair compensation to the artists whose music is broadcast over the Internet-based stations. The Copyright Royalty Board’s new royalty model is distinctly aimed at online broadcasting operations operated by major corporations—like Clear Channel, Yahoo, AOL, and Microsoft—rather than independent operations like Pandora, SomaFM, and others.

With the request to delay the new royalty regime denied, U.S. online broadcasters are hoping to gain reprieve by way of direct Congressional action, and are urging net radio listeners to contact their congressional representatives. If legislative action does not materialize, broadcasters will either have to shut down, pay the new royalty rates, or shift their formats to music which isn’t represented by SoundExchange, such as music offered via Creative Commons license or in the public domain.

Barring intevention, the new rates will go into effect July 15, 2007.

Appeals courts are generally restricted to correcting significant errors in procedure and interpretation in trail court, as well as some reviewing decisions and rules enacted by some governmental administrative agencies. Previous efforts to appeal the new royalty scheme to judges overseeing the Copyright Royalty Board were rejected on the basis of webcasters failing to offer new evidence which was not considered during the decision-making process.

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
How to map a house with the iRobot Roomba
iRobot Roomba 692 Robot Vacuum.

If you’ve got your eye on a new iRobot Roomba robot vacuum, you already know it can sweep or vacuum your whole home. While you can simply push the button to send out the Roomba or even ask your digital assistant to deploy it on a cleaning mission, the real power in a robot vacuum is its smarts. Today, that means enabling and using the smart mapping features.

Read more
Best portable power station deals: Bluetti, EcoFlow, and more
Bluetti AC300 portable power station

Maybe you know already, or maybe you don't, but not all generators are gas-powered. The downside to a gas generator is, besides needing the fuel itself, you can't use them in various configurations. For example, you should never place a gas generator inside. That's super inconvenient in bad weather like the rain or cold. But portable power stations, on the other hand, which utilize electricity, even solar energy, can be placed indoors. They're safe because they're emission-free. They can also replace traditional gas generators to provide backup power for your home, or if you're living off-grid. Plus, it's all in the name. They're portable so you can use them virtually anywhere, like when you're camping, on outdoor adventures, by the pool, in your backyard during a party or barbecue, and much more. They can also be pretty expensive depending on the capacity you need, but deals and discounts go a long way towards making them both more affordable and more accessible. That's precisely why we've gathered up all of the best portable power station deals right here, in one place.

Our favorite portable power station deal

Read more
Best Amazon Echo deals: Save on on Echo Dot, Echo Show 8, and more
Amazon Echo (4th Gen) on a kitchen counter.

Buying an Amazon Echo device is among the easiest ways to start building or expanding your smart home setup, as you'll get access to all of the capabilities of Amazon's Alexa. Amazon's Echo brand includes smart speakers and smart displays, so choosing the model that's best for you depends on what you want to get out of the smart home device. To help you out, we've gathered the best Amazon Echo deals that we've come across below, but you need to hurry if you want to take advantage of an of them because these discounts never last long.
Best Amazon Echo deals

The focus of Amazon Echo smart speakers is to enable voice commands with Alexa, so that you can access the different types of Alexa skills, in addition to a wide variety of functions such as searching for information, setting alarms and reminders, and making to-do lists. The Amazon Echo models range from the cheap Amazon Echo Pop to the premium Amazon Echo Studio, so you can choose what to buy depending on how much you're willing to spend. With these Amazon Echo deals, you're going to enjoy discounts, but only if you hurry.

Read more