Skip to main content

European court decides that Google must let users censor their own search results

european court rules google must remove links personal material requested
Image used with permission by copyright holder

In a move that could disrupt how Google and other search-engine operators work across Europe, the European Union Court of Justice ruled that Google is forced to remove personal information hosted on third-party websites from its search engine results when requested to do so.

This ruling follows a case in Spain when Mario Costeja González could not secure the deletion of an auction notice for his repossessed home back in 1998, which was on the website of a Spanish newspaper in mass circulation. González argued that, because the matter, which involved having the house auctioned off in order to recover his social security debts, was resolved, it should no longer be linked to him when searching his name on Google.

Google refused to do so, as with other plaintiffs, so the original case was brought to the European Union Court of Justice, the highest court in the European Union. Plaintiffs argued their “right to be forgotten,” which should give them the opportunity to have outdated information about them removed from search engines. The original article or website doesn’t have to be altered, according to the ruling. Rather, only search results would be affected.

According to the court, Google is “obliged to remove links to Web pages” under certain circumstances. “If, following a search made on the basis of a person’s name, the list of results displays a link to a Web page which contains information on the person in question, that data subject may approach the operator directly.” While search-engine operators don’t have to comply with every request, individuals can go to their national data-protection authorities to have them order the removal of the links.

Google isn’t very happy with the ruling.

“This is a disappointing ruling for search engines and online publishers in general,” said Google spokesperson Al Verney to the Wall Street Journal. According to Verney, Google will review the implications of the ruling, though law firm Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati partner Christopher Kuner believes this will have wide implications for the Internet itself and how it’s used. “It sets up a system whereby search engine providers have to, when requested, take down instances of persons names, independently of what the website they’re indexing does.”

Williams Pelegrin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
How to remove personal info from Google search
Google Pixel XL

Recently, Google revealed it is expanding the sphere of personal information that can be removed from search results. As part of this change, users will be able to remove sensitive personal such as contact details and login credentials. Previously, this was limited to just bank details. The updated policy enables users to have more control over their data that can be accessed by a basic Google search.

Read more
New Google privacy features fight phishing, scrub search results
Person using smartphone at home office desk beside open Chromebook.

Google is taking even more steps to help folks protect their privacy and keep their data secure.

At this year’s Google I/O conference, the company announced several new initiatives that will help folks lock down their Google accounts, remove unwanted information from search results, and control the advertising they see.
Keeping your information safe
Google wants you to know that it has teams working around the clock to combat cyber threats behind the scenes, but it’s also working to help people who use its services do their part to keep their data safe from hackers.

Read more
Everything announced at Google I/O 2022: Pixel 6a, Pixel Watch, search enhancements and more!
A phone running Android 13.

Google held its keynote address at its annual developer's conference, Google I/O. As expected, we got a ton of announcements regarding Google's plans for both hardware and software. We got updates about Android 13, Chrome OS, the Pixel 6a, the Pixel Watch, Nest Hub, and more. Here's the rundown of everything from today's keynote.
How to watch Google I/O 2022
Did you miss the keynote? You can still watch the whole thing on YouTube (below) or at Google's I/O website: io.google/2022. While you're there, you can take part in a few other breakout sessions that we recommend.

These sessions and the keynote itself will be available to stream for up to two weeks after the event at the Google I/O website above. Here's what was covered during the keynote.

Read more