The FBI still hasn’t cracked the San Bernardino terrorists’ encrypted smartphone

hacker compromises data of nearly 30000 fbi and dhs employees with a simple phone call j edgar hoover building headquarters
The J. Edgar Hoover Building, headquarters for the Federal Bureau of Investigation, in Washington, D.C..
There’s a reason smartphone encryption is a flashpoint for controversy: in those instances when a secured handset is used to facilitate crime, it sometimes presents a significant roadblock to law enforcement. Two months following the Islamic State-inspired rampage in San Bernardino, California that left 14 people dead, technicians at the Federal Bureau of Investigation have been unable to crack security on a smartphone belonging to the terrorist couple who were responsible.

“We still have one of [the] killers’ phones that we haven’t been able to open,” FBI Director James Comey told the Senate Intelligence Committee on Wednesday. “We are still working on it.”

The agency had previously implied that messages exchanged via the cell phone would shed light on the activities of Syed Rizwan Farook, a county health inspector, and Tashfeen Malik, his wife, who together gunned down attendees of an Inland Regional Center holiday party in December. The FBI hopes to learn whether the couple had planned additional attacks and whether they’d coordinated with other parties prior to the attack. (Short of evidence to the contrary, the FBI believes that Farook became self-radicalized via the Internet.)

The Bernardino barrier is the second such type the agency’s faced in recent months. A handset belonging to one of two gunman involved on an attempted Islamic State attack directed at a cartoon contest in Garland, Texas last year was used to exchange 109 messages with “an overseas terrorist,” messages which Director Comey told the Senate Judiciary Committee in May remain encrypted.

The San Bernardino revelations are sure to reinvigorate the contentious debate over mobile device encryption. Opponents of encryption argue that the privacy it affords isn’t worth the investigative obstructions it presents, and that encryption must at the very least accommodate searches authorized by warrant. This rhetoric has resonated with lawmakers: bills before the state assemblies of New York and California would impose a fine on manufacturers and operating system providers for devices that don’t provide a “backdoor” around encryption for authorities. Senators John McCain and Dianne Feinstein and Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Richard Burr have called for similar legislation at the federal level.

“All of the evidence contained in smartphones and similar devices will be lost to law enforcement, so long as the criminals take the precaution of protecting their devices with passcodes,” reads a statement issued in connection with the proposed New York law. “Simply stated, passcode-protected devices render lawful court orders meaningless and encourage criminals to act with impunity.”

Security proponents refute those claims. A study published by Harvard’s Berkman Center rebuts FBI claims that the use of encryption inhibits law enforcement in terrorism investigations. Tim Cook, NSA Director Admiral Mike Rogers, former CIA analyst John Kiriakou, and others have questioned the need for backdoors in encrypted devices and messaging platforms.

And in an open letter published by digital rights group Access Now in January, nearly 200 cyber security experts and activists from 42 countries urged lawmakers in the U.S., U.K., and China not to curtail encryption on consumer devices. “Users should have the option to use — and companies the option to provide — the strongest encryption available, including end-to-end encryption, without fear that governments will compel access to the content, metadata, or encryption keys without due process and respect for human rights,” the letter says.

Meanwhile, Democratic representative Ted Lieu and Republican representative Blake Farenthold in early February introduced pro-encryption legislation that would make it illegal for state or political representatives to demand the ability to decrypt communications, effectively nullifying the proposed New York and California laws. So as lawmakers on both sides gear up for what’s sure to be a lengthy legislative battle, an end to the decryption debate is nowhere in sight. And tragic attacks like San Bernardino will only prolong it.


Sony’s weird Wena isn’t a smartwatch, it’s a smart watch strap

Sony's Wena smart watch straps have been around since 2015; but the company has now decided to launch them outside of Japan, starting with the U.K.. The straps convert traditional watch straps into smart watches.

Enjoy Windows on a Chromebook with these great tips and tricks

If you want to push the functionality of your new Chromebook to another level, and Linux isn't really your deal, you can try installing Windows on a Chromebook. Here's how to do so in case you're looking to nab some Windows-only software.
Emerging Tech

Caltech sees supernovae, black holes ‘Ned Stark’ and ‘Jon Snow’ shredding stars

A new astronomical project has released its first set of results. It has observed more than one billion of the stars and has made a wealth of discoveries, from 50 small near-Earth asteroids to more than 1,100 supernovae.

Xiaomi Mi 9 will be one of the first phones with monster Snapdragon 855 chip

Xiaomi's next major smartphone release will be the Mi 9, and the company hasn't held back in giving us a good look at the phone, revealing the design, the camera, and a stunning color.

Galaxy Watch Active isn't official yet, but you can see it in Samsung's own app

Samsung may be about to resurrect its Sport line of smartwatches under a new name: The Galaxy Watch Sport Active. Leaks and rumors are building our picture of the device at the moment.

Stop buying old tablets, says Samsung, buy the new Galaxy Tab S5e instead

Samsung has launched the Galaxy Tab S5e -- the E is for Essential -- a reasonably priced tablet that includes many of the features we like from the Tab A 10.5, and the Tab S4. Here's what you need to know.

Focals succeed where Google Glass fumbled (but do we really need smartglasses?)

It’s been seven years since Google took the wraps off Google Glass. Now, we’re finally getting a modern-day equivalent we want to wear. North’s Focals combine subtle style with an intuitive interface to craft smartglasses you’ll…

Bag yourself a bargain with the best budget tablets under $200

The battle for your budget tablet affections is really ramping up. Which tablet, costing less than $200, should be commanding your attention? We take a look at some different options for the budget-conscious.

What is Wi-Fi 6? Here's a look at the next evolution of the wireless standard

We're exploring the new naming convention for wireless standards, how it affects the devices you buy, and what the upcoming Wi-Fi generation is changing for the better.
Home Theater

Samsung accidentally leaks its new Galaxy Buds ahead of launch

It's been all but certain that Samsung would launch a successor to its Gear IconX wireless earbuds soon, but a newly leaked photo and recent FCC certification document seems to indicate that the debut is very close.
Home Theater

Hi-res streaming audio service Qobuz arrives in U.S., threatens Tidal’s monopoly

For several years, Tidal enjoyed a monopoly on hi-res music streaming in the U.S. Now, French company Qobuz is here to offer some competition with a variety of monthly plans starting at $10 a month.

These 13 gadgets walk a fine line between ingenious and insane

The annual avalanche of devices and gadgets is astounding, but how many will succeed? A few are destined to spark new trends, while the majority fade deservedly into obscurity. We look at some gadgets on the border of brilliant and bonkers.

OnePlus 6T vs. Honor View 20: We compare the cameras in these ‘flagship killers’

For less than $600, you can buy either the OnePlus 6T or the Honor View 20, two extremely capable smartphones with plenty of exciting features. But which one has the best camera? We found out on a recent trip to France.

Save space on your iPhone by turning off Live Photos in the camera app

If you want to save storage space on your iPhone or reduce the size of your backup for iCloud, then you should think about turning off Live Photos in the camera app. Find out exactly how to do it with our easy guide.