Skip to main content

South Korea finds Qualcomm prevented Samsung from selling chips to phone makers

Qualcomm and Samsung have a close working relationship — but it’s not always amiable. According to the South Korea Trade Commission (SKTC), chip-maker Qualcomm prevented Samsung from supplying its in-house Exynos processor to third parties.

The Commission’s report claims that Qualcomm abused its standard-essential patents — which define technical standards like Wi-Fi and 4G — to prevent Samsung from selling its modems, integrated processors, and other chips to smartphone makers like LG, Huawei, Xiaomi, and others. The Commission reportedly threatened to file suit against Samsung, which had agreed to license the patents for an undisclosed sum, if the South Korean electronics maker began competing against it in the mobile market.

Related Videos

That bullying ran afoul of the South Korea Trade Commission’s rules, which require that standards-essential patents be licensed on fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms. “Samsung Electronics has been blocked from selling its modem chips to other smartphone manufacturers due to a license deal it signed with Qualcomm,” the commissioners wrote.

The report provides legal justification for the $853 million fine the SKTC placed on Qualcomm in December for “anti-competitive practices.”

Qualcomm intends to appeal. “[We] strongly disagree with the KFTC’s announced decision, which Qualcomm believes is inconsistent with the facts and the law, reflects a flawed process, and represents a violation of due process rights owed American companies” under an applicable agreement between the U.S. and South Korea.

Since late last year, Qualcomm has been embroiled in a tangled legal battle involving Apple, the U.S. Federal Communications Commission, and South Korean regulators. In January, Qualcomm was sued by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission for allegedly using its industry dominance to elbow out the competition. The FTC reports that it maintained a “no license, no chips” policy in which it refused to sell smartphone chips to companies that didn’t agree to pay inflated royalty fees.

Apple has filed several lawsuits against Qualcomm — in China, the U.K., and the U.S — for imposing “restrictive terms” on the use of its patented technology, and “punishing” Apple for cooperating in a South Korea regulatory probe regarding Qualcomm’s licensing practices.

According to Apple, Qualcomm required the company to pay a percentage of iPhone sales in return for access to Qualcomm technology, and demanded that Apple use Qualcomm chips exclusively between 2011 and 2016. While Apple initially received quarterly rebates under the agreement, Qualcomm began withholding those rebates when the Cupertino, California firm began working with the Korea Fair Trade Commission.

“We are extremely disappointed in the way Qualcomm is conducting its business with us and, unfortunately, after years of disagreement over what constitutes a fair and reasonable royalty, we have no choice but to turn to the courts,” an Apple spokesperson said in February.

Editors' Recommendations

Chinese smartphone makers, not Apple, benefited from Samsung’s Note 7 disaster
apple encryption court order news logo

It wouldn't be unreasonable to assume that Samsung's Galaxy Note 7 ordeal drove sales of its nearest competitor, Apple, to record heights. After all, that is what some analysts expected -- research firm KGI Securities was especially bullish, projecting the Cupertino, California-based company would pick up an additional 5 million to 7 million orders in the third fiscal quarter of 2016. But that turned out to be far from the case. According to Gartner, Chinses brands like Huawei and Oppo gained the most from Samsung's woes.

Immediately following Samsung's recall of the Note 7, Samsung's third-quarter market share predictably fell from 23.6 percent to 19.2 percent, the biggest slide in the company's history. Apple, surprisingly, followed suit: the iPhone maker saw a year-on-year dip in market share from 13 percent to 11.5 percent in Q3, its lowest since 2009. The fall was especially acute in U.S. and China, where sales of Apple devices declined by 8.5 and 31 percent, respectively. "The iPhone 7 struggled to simulate ... sales" despite Samsung's decision to recall the Note 7," Gartner wrote in its report.

Read more
Start getting ready for 5G! Samsung and KT complete early trials in South Korea

It appears that 5G is on its way. How soon will we get it? Well, that's up for debate, but we moved one step closer to 5G recently, with both Samsung and KT Corporation (formerly Korea Terlecom) completing early 5G connectivity trials. The two companies conducted tests on Samsung's campus in Suwon, South Korea.

It's not just up to smartphone manufacturers to develop their 5G radios -- the likes of Qualcomm and carriers like AT&T and Verizon are all also conducting tests of their own in an effort to implement 5G in the U.S.

Read more
Apple may open a retail store on Samsung's turf in South Korea
india rules apple stores applestoredisplay4

Apple is considering opening a retail store at the home of its rival, Samsung, which is dealing with a massive recall of its Galaxy Note 7 after reports of some of the smartphones catching fire.

South Korea doesn't have any Apple stores, and that's because Samsung reigns supreme. The smartphone maker accounts for about 23 percent of the country's economy. That's not stopping Apple from building a retail presence, and the store may even sit across Samsung's headquarters.

Read more