Skip to main content

Samsung wins $120 million appeal in ongoing patent fight with Apple

u s appeals court makes 120 million ruling in favor of samsung says apple infringed patent vs samsung5
Samsung notched a big legal victory on Friday when a U.S. appeals court overturned a May 2014 verdict ordering the South Korean company to pay Apple $119.6 million for infringing on smartphone patents. The court also confirmed that Apple had infringed on one of Samsung’s patents, according to Reuters.

The unanimous ruling, which came from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington, D.C., upturned a California jury’s decision in May 2014 that Samsung had infringed on Apple’s “quick links,” slide-to-unlock, and autocorrect patents on all its mobile devices. The court also upheld an earlier decision that Apple violated Samsung’s patent for an “apparatus for recording and reproducing digital image and speech,” which means Apple has to pay Samsung $158,400.

This marks a rare victory for Samsung in its ongoing war with Apple over patent infringements. In December, Samsung was ordered to pay $548 million to Apple, which followed up with the iPhone maker asking a U.S. court in San Jose, California, to force Samsung to pay them an additional $180 million for “supplemental damages for continued infringement, plus interest.”

Apple first sued Samsung for patent violations and design theft in 2011, which resulted in an order for Samsung to pay $930 million to Apple. That figure was subsequently lowered by about $382 million by an appeals court.

Friday’s decision marked a “win for consumer choice and puts competition back where it belongs – in the marketplace, not in the courtroom,” a Samsung spokeswoman said.

An Apple spokeswoman declined to give Reuters a comment about the ruling.

Editors' Recommendations

Jason Hahn
Jason Hahn is a part-time freelance writer based in New Jersey. He earned his master's degree in journalism at Northwestern…
In 2023, it’s time to finally ditch your real wallet for Apple Pay
Front of Apple Card

In the early 2000s, the U.S. started accepting contactless payments at credit card terminals, which used near-field communication (NFC) technology to make it happen. However, it was still too early and not widely adopted until 2008, when the major credit card companies began to offer contactless credit cards.

But contactless payments continued to evolve. Soon enough, Apple added Apple Pay in 2014, allowing you to add your credit and debit cards in the digital Wallet app and pay with your phone. There is also Google Pay for Android devices, and even Samsung has its own version of mobile payments called Samsung Pay.

Read more
Forget AirPods — here’s why I use Samsung earbuds with my iPhone
Galaxy Buds 2 Pro with iPhone 13 Pro Max on a table

AirPods Pro 2 are the go-to flagship earbuds for an iPhone user; you get all the ecosystem benefits alongside brilliant sound quality and active noise cancellation (ANC). But what if you use your iPhone with a Windows laptop, or what if you have an Android phone as a secondary device? That’s where you’ll require a second pair of earbuds — unless you can find something that works well with the iPhone as well as Windows and Android. Surprisingly, the Galaxy Buds 2 Pro are one such product.

I’ve been using the Galaxy Buds 2 Pro with my iPhone 13 Pro Max and Galaxy Z Fold 4. While there are obvious reasons for someone in the Galaxy ecosystem to purchase the flagship Samsung earbuds, they work shockingly well with an iPhone — even if there are a couple of caveats.
Open, pair, and play

Read more
Forget Apple’s newest iPad — the Galaxy Tab S8 should be your next tablet
Samsung Galaxy Tab S8 alongside the tenth-gen iPad.

For a while now, the tablet industry has been rather boring. That's not due to the lack of compelling devices, but because of lopsided competition. Apple’s iPads have reigned supreme, and with the arrival of iPadOS, Apple made it clear that it was serious at playing the tablet game.

The dominance has been particularly evident at the entry level, where the $329 iPad has been the default choice for an affordable, reliable tablet. That’s not the case anymore in 2022. The "entry-level" 10th-gen iPad now starts at $449. It looks fresh, offers USB-C nirvana, and comes with a new Magic Keyboard to sell its computing chops.

Read more